I Am Pleased to Announce a Working Release of the Drop Zone Protocol - a Decentralized Marketplace Layer Written Fully on top of Bitcoin

It is a command line client written in Ruby. It allows for the selling, buying, and facilitation of secure messaging between buyers and sellers using nothing but the Blockchain and testnet. For those unfamiliar with the project, I released the original paper on the cryptography mailing list.

Github Link

Rubygem Link

It is a command line only client for now, but it is perfectly functional, written in Ruby, and tested to the hilt.

  • Install ruby. This program was built on version 2.2.1

  • gem install dropzone_ruby

  • Run "dropzone help" to get started

  • Fund a testnet and mainnet key with BTC/tBTC

  • Create a seller or buyer profile, and start using Drop Zone

The immediate application for Drop Zone is as a nationwide marketplace. However, it is my hope that as adoption increases, Drop Zone will provide instantaneous, convenient hyper-local market services as well.

I hope for active community participation. I would like to see users push for Drop Zone integrations in their preferred mobile wallets, and I hope that those interested in decentralized markets will take up the torch and begin building interesting applications on top of this protocol. All at once, Drop Zone solves the problem of disappearing marketplaces and their associated exit scams w/o need for running any additional supporting infrastructure. Drop Zone is Bitcoin.

Please recognize, in the midst of this blocksize debate, that fungibility is truly the biggest problem facing Bitcoin. Please use the software and begin issuing bug requests. Also, while the Drop Zone release is at the forefront of everyone's minds, I ask that the r/dropzone subreddit be created. Feel free to make me a mod, though I will be moving on to other things as soon I feel like the project is in good hands.

If you are the owner of the following wallets please contact me on Drop Zone:

  • 1PFk4BEZnw5Y2Tzo7TNr8vK8m5n95k1RcR

  • 19aACUwHD5e1wRQpZKaLiiinfxnNFNGSgh

  • 17iUc7dvA8jiCgGouxG2E2b1K3c6Hv8N1H

  • 1Kg24iZDKax1e4CFR6gCCaQCfs2DL4CiBe

Posted Aug 30, 2015, 2:34 AM UTC

34390
btc_trader•

Great Manifesto copied from the GitHub repo:

To whom it may concern,

Markets are objects of censorship and always have been. There is a presumed division, that renders commerce distinct from the notion of free speech. But I will allege that the act of commerce is, itself, indistinct from speech. Where or how one spends their value is a decision as personal and poignant as any words ever spoken or letters ever written.

As a unfortunate consequence of freedom, bad actors will engage in repugnant trade that impinges upon the rights and freedoms of others. It is the job of humanity to cooperate and see to it that trade, such as this, becomes unprofitable. Whether it is accomplished through technological achievement or through the adjustment of social mores, or perhaps a simple appeal to the underlying natural law, it is not the job of bad acting third parties to force into hiding commerce that must be dealt with by means of an adjustment to the global, social conscience.

Cooperation, in the manner I was just speaking about, has never been plausible until the invention of The Blockchain. I will not foist upon Satoshi's humble creation such impracticable possibilities as the achievement of world peace.
But in approaching Drop Zone, I am attempting to do nothing more than what is possible and possibly more efficient than what exists. I wish for Drop Zone to be nothing more than an appendage to The Blockchain. As such, it is every bit as much Bitcoin as Bitcoin itself. Just as a fungible Bitcoin enables the exchange of spaceless value with near impunity, Drop Zone removes the ability of unwelcome parties from glancing over the shoulders of those in the act of an exchange, whatever it entails. This technology disrupts the ability of buyers to gain insight into the identities or movements of suppliers making supply chains far less vulnerable to disruption. It is this innovation that separates this project from all other decentralized market solutions.

Whereas Bitcoin forces us to consider the nature of money and value, Drop Zone will do the same for commerce. At its root, Bitcoin is a message passing system. Those messages that are passed, unlike any electronic message that's come before it, articulate value. Commerce is, and has always been, similarly inclined toward message passing. Whether in-person, over email, or through large, online shopping carts, fundamentally, commerce is composed of messages that are in service of the transaction wherein a final message of value is sent to a recipient in exchange for a negotiated good or service. As such, Drop Zone is a secure message passing protocol inasmuch as it is a platform for commerce. And while the problem is far beyond the scope or capabilities of the protocol in its most fundamental form, the observant might even see the tenuous skeleton of a full-fledged reputation system. Such a project is, in itself, as important and difficult as any facing this decentralized ecosystem.

I hope that Drop Zone lets us all dream of a day when no man will any longer be made to suffer indignity for simply engaging in unpopular or stigmatized commerce. May all commerce be created equal.

Today is a Beautiful day,

Miracle Max quia omnis qui se exaltat humiliabitur et qui se humiliat exaltabitur
38
tor4sure•

How does Drop Zone compare with BitMarkets (https://voluntary.net/bitmarkets/), another fully p2p bitcoin market with no trusted third parties that: fully runs on Tor by default, uses uncensorable BitMessage for listings and buyer/seller communication, and has 2-party escrow to keep buyer/seller incentives aligned?

4
btc_trader•

From what I can tell Drop Zone seems to be more oriented towards local trades, you discover new listings based on your gps position, while still obfuscating sellers' identities.

Also, Drop Zone is a lightweight protocol that comes equipped with a minimal CLI interface, it is cross platform. BitMarkets comes with a full GUI client but is only available on Mac OS.

15
flaim•

only available on Mac OS

lol

6†
Sovereign_Curtis•

Don't worry, its "Coming to Windows and Linux in 2015"

8
sgornick•

For now.

dev path high priority

GNUstep port to Linux and Windows

https://github.com/voluntarynet/Bitmarkets

2
Kichigai•

So start writing a GUI for Windows and Linux. Source code is right there.

1†
_miracle-max_OP•

Drop Zone is designed to be a part and parcel layer over Bitcoin. This means that Drop Zone can be trivially implemented in existing wallets with nothing more than GUI tweaks. That is not the case with other solutions.

5
bobthesponge1•

nationwide marketplace

Worldwide marketplace?

24
zoopz•

Odds that creator is american: 99%

51
Kristkind•

Murica being the third planet from the sun

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0†
_miracle-max_OP•

It would be my hope that it will be used as a global marketplace.

9
mustyoshi•

Is there a built in escrow system? Otherwise I don't see how it would be any more desirable than the current systems which include buyer protection.

13
Lentil-Soup•

I suppose it would be reputation based. Plus it's local.

9
belcher_•

Shouldn't be a problem to create if it doesnt. Just have an escrow agent hold the bitcoin in multisig, which are released when the customer gives the word he's got the goods.

2
briceb8e•

How is this different from Openbazaar? Different use cases maybe?

10
gynoplasty•

It's built directly on top of the BTC blockchain. Isn't openbazaar just a decentralized marketplace that uses BTC for payment?

9
briceb8e•

Interesting, thank you. Then I wonder, why use the testnet for "production"? Should a "test gone bad" happen on the testnet, it would then cripple Drop Zone somewhat, no?

8
gynoplasty•

I'm not sure, it seems like the testnet is open to resets/hard forks more often than the mainnet however it is nearly as immutable...

In truth I don't know why the testnet is needed. It seems to me like kind of a weak point in the system because it is much more vulnerable to a variety of attacks.

2
padkontrol•

It's only used superficially for communication

1
steb2k•

I don't see this being a production release..its a working release, but clearly not production ready, as it runs from a ruby command line.

2
briceb8e•

The white-paper mentions using testnet as part of the protocol.

2
KayRice•

just a decentralized marketplace

3
gynoplasty•

Yeah. I thought that was harsh. I'm not trying to belittle open bazaar. Meant to outline differences not pit it down.

2
Traxx187•

still not anon but r/shadowcash is

0
Yoghurt114•

It isn't decentralized and written fully on top of Bitcoin if it's using centralized APIs.

10
_miracle-max_OP•

I wrote an abstraction layer that will plug into any bitcoind. As a convenience to the initial users of Drop Zone, I chose to interface with blockr.io's library. All the method calls of the interface are directly pulled from bitcoin-cli calls. Feel free to replace this abstraction layer if you prefer.

Additionally, the takeaway from this design, for the uninitiated is that adding support to any mobile wallet is as trivial as writing a GUI.

6
ostracize•

At least it's easily changed.

The blockr.io block/txs method appears to omit some transactions. As such,

we'll be using blockchain.info for this query.

Presumably, a local source could also be supplied.

2
bluelightzero•

Until this happens, it is not decentralized and OP should not advertise it as such.

-2†
ElementsOfDeathClan•

So should open bazaar their store nodes (the most important nodes) are still centralized.

5
Chris_Pacia•

How is it centralized?

2
crypto_bot•
Address: 17Q4MX2hmktmpuUKHFuoRmS5MfB5XPbhod
Balance: 0.02458488 btc
Number of transactions: 7
Total sent: 0.0014516 btc
Total received: 0.02603648 btc

^View ^on ^block ^explorers:

^^Blockchain.info ^^| ^^BlockTrail.com ^^| ^^Blockr.io ^^| ^^Biteasy.com ^^| ^^BitPay.com


^^I ^^am ^^a ^^bot. ^^My ^^commands ^^| ^^/r/crypto_bot ^^| ^^Message ^^my ^^creator

-1
tokyopotato•

Sounds cool. I hope some testers jump onboard.

8
playaspec•

Why leave it to someone else? Everyone should test it.

6
tokyopotato•

I work 60+ hours a week right now, the most I can do at the moment is cheerlead.

Let us know how the testing goes!

4
PotatoBadger•

Potatoes have an excellent work ethic.

2
windsok•

Interesting stuff, thanks for your work.

I'm curious how dropzone queries and post transactions to the blockchain. It looks like it can be used without needing a local full node.

eg. I just installed it and could run this straight away:

$ dropzone profile seller show 17Q4MX2hmktmpuUKHFuoRmS5MfB5XPbhod
+---------------------------------------------------------+
| Seller: 17Q4MX2hmktmpuUKHFuoRmS5MfB5XPbhod              |
+---------------------------------------------------------+
| alias              : Miracle Max                        |
| description        : Creator of the Protocol.           |
| communications_pkey: mw8Ge8HDBStKyn8u4LTkUwueheFNhuo7Ch |
+---------------------------------------------------------+
5
crypto_bot•
Address: 17Q4MX2hmktmpuUKHFuoRmS5MfB5XPbhod
Balance: 0.02458488 btc
Number of transactions: 7
Total sent: 0.0014516 btc
Total received: 0.02603648 btc

^View ^on ^block ^explorers:

^^Blockchain.info ^^| ^^BlockTrail.com ^^| ^^Blockr.io ^^| ^^Biteasy.com ^^| ^^BitPay.com


^^I ^^am ^^a ^^bot. ^^My ^^commands ^^| ^^/r/crypto_bot ^^| ^^Message ^^my ^^creator

4
windsok•

debug option answered my question, it uses blockr.io

4
eragmus•

Does that qualify as a TTP?

2
IIIIIHIIIII•

Using blockrio api (and counterparty i guess) Source

2
crypto_bot•
Address: 17Q4MX2hmktmpuUKHFuoRmS5MfB5XPbhod
Balance: 0.02458488 btc
Number of transactions: 7
Total sent: 0.0014516 btc
Total received: 0.02603648 btc

^View ^on ^block ^explorers:

^^Blockchain.info ^^| ^^BlockTrail.com ^^| ^^Blockr.io ^^| ^^Biteasy.com ^^| ^^BitPay.com


^^I ^^am ^^a ^^bot. ^^My ^^commands ^^| ^^/r/crypto_bot ^^| ^^Message ^^my ^^creator

1
gynoplasty•

when I try to run ruby dropzone I get this in cmd:

ruby dropzone

C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/gems/2.2.0/gems/commander-4.3.5/lib/commander/runner.rb:391:in `block in require_program': program version required (Commander::Runner::CommandError)

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/gems/2.2.0/gems/commander-4.3.5/lib/commander/runner.rb:390:in `each'  

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/gems/2.2.0/gems/commander-4.3.5/lib/commander/runner.rb:390:in `require_program'  

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/gems/2.2.0/gems/commander-4.3.5/lib/commander/runner.rb:52:in `run!'  

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/gems/2.2.0/gems/commander-4.3.5/lib/commander/delegates.rb:15:in `run!'  

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/gems/2.2.0/gems/commander-4.3.5/lib/commander/import.rb:5:in `block in <top (required)>'  

C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/site_ruby/2.2.0/rubygems/core_ext/kernel_require.rb:54:in `require': LoadError: cannot load such file -- sqlite3/sqlite3_native (Sequel::AdapterNotFound)

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/site_ruby/2.2.0/rubygems/core_ext/kernel_require.rb:54:in `require'  

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/gems/2.2.0/gems/sqlite3-1.3.10-x64-mingw32/lib/sqlite3.rb:6:in `rescue in <top (required)>'  

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/gems/2.2.0/gems/sqlite3-1.3.10-x64-mingw32/lib/sqlite3.rb:2:in `<top (required)>'  

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/site_ruby/2.2.0/rubygems/core_ext/kernel_require.rb:128:in `require'  

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/site_ruby/2.2.0/rubygems/core_ext/kernel_require.rb:128:in `rescue in require'  

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/site_ruby/2.2.0/rubygems/core_ext/kernel_require.rb:39:in `require'  

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/gems/2.2.0/gems/sequel-4.25.0/lib/sequel/adapters/sqlite.rb:1:in `<top (required)>'  

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/site_ruby/2.2.0/rubygems/core_ext/kernel_require.rb:54:in `require'  

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/site_ruby/2.2.0/rubygems/core_ext/kernel_require.rb:54:in `require'  

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/gems/2.2.0/gems/sequel-4.25.0/lib/sequel/database/connecting.rb:96:in `load_adapter'  

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/gems/2.2.0/gems/sequel-4.25.0/lib/sequel/database/connecting.rb:26:in `adapter_class'  

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/gems/2.2.0/gems/sequel-4.25.0/lib/sequel/database/connecting.rb:45:in `connect' 

    from C:/Ruby22-x64/lib/ruby/gems/2.2.0/gems/sequel-4.25.0/lib/sequel/core.rb:106:in `connect'  

    from D:/dropzone_ruby-master/lib/dropzone/command.rb:10:in `initialize'  

    from dropzone:34:in `new'  

    from dropzone:34:in `<main>'

Am I missing some dependencies? This is the first ruby gem I have tried running, thanks!

2
IIIIIHIIIII•

Looks like you are missing sqlite3.

gem install sqlite3
4
_miracle-max_OP•

I have not tested this on Windows. If someone wishes to submit a patch for a more Windows friendly installation/persistence layer, I would be enthusiastic about accepting it.

3
Acejam•
$ gem install bundler  
$ bundle install
1
sexibilia•

Interesting. Good luck. Also: very cool name.

2
tasmannn•

Thanks for making this open source u/changetip 100 bits

2
_miracle-max_OP•

I will not be collecting this, but the sentiment is appreciated.

1
devraps•

Why not collect?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
gynoplasty•

This network might not be the best for selling illicit substances though because everything is done completely in the open on the blockchain?

1
shifty4287•

As are the transactions in the current systems.

6
wipeout4wh•

Communication is usually done through Tor, though. People may be able to see that money was exchanged, but they won't know what it was for, assuming Tor is secure and the people involved are using it in a secure way.

3
shifty4287•

Yes but the information sent on the blockchain can also be encrypted.

1
_miracle-max_OP•

All communications between buyers and sellers are performed over testnet secured using CBC mode, 256-bit AES. The reason testnet is used is because it's a trivial implementation for existing wallets to implement and it's sufficiently anonymous for all privacy concern.

4
gynoplasty•

Is it possible to implement this on the main net too?

2
_miracle-max_OP•

Yes. But the presumption is that buyers would not want to pay for that. I haven't tested it, but as is, I'm fairly certain that the protocol would support setting your communications to a mainnet address.

4
briceb8e•

typo on white-paper: "Alice waits a bit for Bob to return the gGPSps coordinates" edit: also, the footer note [5] is an expired domain name: http://www.royalforkblog.com/btc-pgp/ - partially survived by http://archive.is/Hqmhj as of now.

1
futilerebel•

I don't understand how this won't be full of cops pretending to be selling drugs.

1
esterbrae•

Pollutes the blockchain with messaging. relies to testnet to actually work, so it will eventually break, and never scale. Reuses addresses and thus destroys privacy quickly. This will not compete well with other proposals.

0†
ElementsOfDeathClan•

Always improvements to be made indeed.

1
_miracle-max_OP•

Messaging that benefits from the persistence of immutability, such as reputation and product listings, use The Blockchain. Messaging that does not need to be immutable, such as communications between buyers and sellers, use testnet. This is done because immutability is not free, but rarely needed.

Among the many discussions we are not having as a community is how we get more tips to miners. It is my expectation that as projects like Drop Zone are used, tips to miners will increase.

1
esterbrae•

Messaging that benefits from the persistence of immutability, such as reputation and product listings, use The Blockchain.

Sorry, every fullnode on the planet does not need to know that you have a used lawn chair for sale in salamanca.

Also, testnet is inherently unreliable, by design.

counterparty style network hijacking is not the future.

2
Sovereign_Curtis•

However, it is my hope that as adoption increases

What makes you think adoption will increase? When will this progress beyond command line?

-1
_miracle-max_OP•

Because until today, Drop Zone only had only 1 user.

6
wipeout4wh•

Command lines are not as scary and confusing as many people think. You can easily look up the commands you need to do what you're trying to do, and command lines can actually allow you to perform tasks quicker once you've gotten used to using them.

1
Sovereign_Curtis•

Command lines are not as scary and confusing as many people think

Ok, good luck convincing everyone that is the case. As is people think it is scary and confusing, and those people won't touch this so long as it remains command line only, or they believe command line is too scary and confusing. You can't just wish this away.

3
_miracle-max_OP•

I would love to see javascript development of a frontend GUI similar to Blockchain.info.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Hecatonk•

All at once, Drop Zone solves the problem of disappearing marketplaces and their associated exit scams w/o need for running any additional supporting infrastructure. Drop Zone is Bitcoin.

None of this is true, tone down your advertising. I don't see how this "runs on bitcoin" at all, or why that would be desireable. I won't even look at it because you have thrown anonymity to the wind, just like all the other p2p marketplace designers. Waving your hand and saying "tor" does not allow you to claim that your app can be used anonymously, in my book.

-2
_miracle-max_OP•

It runs on Bitcoin. If you don't see that, you simply haven't looked at it.

3
Hecatonk•

Not really. It's a sidechain implementation at best. It's vulnerable to Cybil attack and forced centralization. Yeah, it runs on bitcoin, just without all that pesky proof-of-work, lol.

-4
blazes816•

Cybil attack

Sybil attack

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
mrmishmashmix•

The bitcoin blockchain is used to ensure both listing and reputations can't be changed or 'taken down' like regular DNM. I'm not so sure about the anonymity concerns, but i'd presume that there are ways for those determined enough......

2
Hecatonk•

Ok but the data you are embedding into the blockchain, I'm guessing into OP_RETURN, is in no way validated by the bitcoin nodes or authenticated in any way by their hashing power. It's really a sidechain implementation at best, and thus vulnerable to Cybil attack and centralization enforced by an "official authority". Why should everyone on Earth store your OP_RETURN data forever? Because that's what you are asking all node maintainers to do, to support your p2p marketplace experiment. I'd liken this to bitcoin "maximalism", or even blockchain spam. I just don't see a compelling reason why you should be using the blockchain as your communications mechanism. It's slow, has terrible communications limitations, and wasn't designed for this purpose. You don't need a POW system to verify entries in a ledger unless the POW is actually verifying the entries you are interested in the ledger, and attaching to a 3rd-party POW just seems like bad engineering to me unless you can tell me a compelling reason it should be done this way. A better implementation would just be a "myMarketPlaceCoin" and have the market directly built into the client and the marketplace transactions actually validated by the miners in some way, through some sort of smart-contract / oracle system. Something like Ethereum would make a more logical choice to build this platform on, it seems.

-2