If the physical reaction that takes place in the brain to support the ability to feel were done in a petri dish, who would do the feeling?

[removed]

Posted Sep 5, 2015, 2:04 AM UTC

13
Riss_Rodavure•

Well, to accurately represent the process that is "pain" you would need to create an entire brain with a full stock of neurons and mylination (damn I can't spell). Thus, you'd be creating an entire human consciousness. That newly created consciousness would do the feeling. If you do anything less then you aren't actually recreating the physical process of "pain."

1
corruption93OP•

Thank you for this answer. My post was removed but you've pointed me in the right direction. Yay science!

1
TheGrammarBolshevikMOD•

Your post was removed. A moderator determined that it broke the following rule:

Rule 1: Questions belong in r/askphilosophy

If you are simply posing a question, whether it's for homework, self-directed study, or general curiosity, check out r/askphilosophy as well as our Recommended Reading List. Questions are permissible here only if you clearly state and argue for a position of your own. Any other questions will be removed.

Rule 3: Arguments, Not Opinions

Self posts, blog articles, etc. are encouraged, but must clearly state and argue for a distinctly philosophical position.

Rule 5: Post Titles Cannot be Questions

Posts with titles that consist solely of a question will be removed.

If this is a self-post, you may edit your post to fix this problem and message the moderators to have it reinstated.

1