If the physical reaction that takes place in the brain to support the ability to feel were done in a petri dish, who would do the feeling?

This has always puzzled me, I just didn't know how to present the idea until now.

If we're able to feel pain, for example, via the physical/chemical reactions that occur in our brain, what would happen if those same reactions were replicated out in the open? Who would do feeling?

Moreover, when it happens in our brain, why does that feeling belong to us? I'm so confused.

Posted Sep 5, 2015, 2:17 AM UTC

17
bunker_manethics, phil. mind, phil. religion•

If you mean that there's enough in the dish to actually cause the sensation of feeling, then... the stuff in the dish would.

6
lksdjsdk•

/thread

1
ShadowInTehDark•

I believe there are multiple neurons in the process of transmitting pain TO the brain, and then a bunch of neurons that create a logic in the consciousness that tells us something hurts.

It's not just a chemical reaction, but an entire network of neurons working together to give us the conscious feeling of pain... so without a brain it's probably not possible.

2
earthbounding•

Is an entire network of neurons not just a larger chemical reaction?

0
ShadowInTehDark•

It's not really 'a chemical reaction', it'd be closely related to a small circuit board with a bunch of 'wires'.

I think to best answer your question, you can't have 'pain' without consciousness cause that's the realm where it actually exists. And you can't have consciousness without a large processing vessel (such as a brain).

If you were to take a pain sensor, and attach it to a neuron, or a few neurons to replicate the path from pain to muscular response pathway, all it would be doing would be tensing a muscle, no pain would actually be felt by anything.

1
ShadowInTehDark•

I think maybe another way to look at it would be like getting a bad paper cut. It'd mildy hurt cause pain senors would be sending that information to your brain. But if you got hit in the shin by a hammer for example you'd immediately forget that paper cut ever existed (aka not feel the pain anymore). So despite the giant complexity of all the reactions and and mechanisms that make pain exist, it still wouldn't be felt anyway.

1
qdatk•

This is what is at stake in the question of cognitivism, whether subjectivity is reducible to the sum of processes happening in a brain. You might find arguments for and against it helpful.

1