r/WildStar•
Timiniel

Unofficial reddit survey: What is your opinion on the F2P changes?

Greetings folks.

I'd like to get a bit of a measure of the opinion of the reddit community concerning the changes coming to the ingame experience (aka, nothing about payment method, etc) coming in F2P. Be as much or as little detailed as you want.

Here's my perspective, where ++ is strongly positive, + is positive, - is negative and -- is strongly negative.

Positive:

++ Performance improvements (Self-explanatory)

+ New challenge system (Rewards gold much better, allows you to pick rewards better as well)

+ More streamlined leveling experience (Easier for newer players to understand and less grindy at places)

+ Streamlined instances (less time wasted, more capacity for players to choose their path in some cases)

+ Larger & better housing (Self-explanatory)

Negative:

- Less flavorful stat system (I know some people might like this, but I will miss the spunk the old system had)

- More complex rune system (The randomness and specificity will mean a lot of needless rerolls)

-- Crafting changes (Almost entirely negative... Less content to craft, system is less fun overall, some pieces no longer can be crafted, very high randomness in the colors of the crafting slots, etc etc etc etc)

Share yours, and let's get a perspective of what the people think. If you have not played the beta, well, this might be helpful in giving you a perspective of what those who did think.

Your hyperactive seamstress, Timiniel

Posted Sep 16, 2015, 12:05 PM UTC · edited

017
cooperi3•

+ New dyes and costumes

+ Hopefully there will be more people

- Raiding old content for class runes

-- Fusion runes unobtainable from tokens. Crafting a divine rune on day 1: 1536 live runic modules or 154 live runic flux => 1 crafted divine rune. If the market price of a runic module is 10g, you need to have 614 plat worth of them to be able to craft the 4 fusion runes for ONE spec.

3
eldrinanisterTCO•

-- Fusion runes unobtainable from tokens. Crafting a divine rune on day 1: 1536 live runic modules or 154 live runic flux => 1 crafted divine rune. If the market price of a runic module is 10g, you need to have 614 plat worth of them to be able to craft the 4 fusion runes for ONE spec.

How come no devs have express something about this. I see many post on the forums still not response. This is really bad design in my opinion.

1
Sarahdragoness•

I feel like one of the few people excited about the gear changes. As a casual player I find myself struggling with the stat and stat names. Even though I do appreciate them trying to do something different with the stat names. For new players I can see how the gear would be super confusing. Even after playing for a year I still find myself shrugging and saying "Well...I guess that sounds good..." when equipping new gear. The only thing that I am not super excited about is some of the gear from shops disappearing as I really like costumes. I also really like not grinding out a particular dungeon for pieces just for a costume. Overall I am also hoping that the population takes a big jump upwards. I find it depressing sitting in dungeon ques for 2+ hours when I usually only have an hour or two at a time to dedicate to the game. Sometimes that is all the time I have in a week to play. +Streamlining leveling and dungeons is exciting to me. But I also have a bad problem with jumping around toons.

3
somebears•

++ Progression spacing (dungeons/ilevel) ++ new stat system (focus pool <3 ) ++ rune system (makes a lot more sense now. It is 100% clear what stat you get for what rune.) ++ veteran protostar academy!

+ 2 more amp points **+**faster dungeons

- dungeon chests (not really relevant, but getting gear for paying money is p2w for me, no matter what ilevel)

- overcharge bonus for subscribers (p2w)

- - crafted items being BiS

2
zaery•

but getting gear for paying money is p2w for me

It's really just getting gear for money instead of more time. You still have to run the dungeon to get the box, so you could just run more dungeons instead of paying for the boxes.

2
somebears•

the problem is: where is the line?

Putting a chest at the end of eg DS is also "just" saving time. I have cleared it, so I can do it again. Most people would agree that this is p2w. I see that this is a bit unfair, because you can run dungeons more often than raids.

I think this is a similar thing to the crafting discussion going on atm. If you could buy an item that would allow you to choose every stat and rune slot on your gear. And remove the fail chance.

A person with that item could just craft a very good item, someone else would need to farm the mats over and over again, to get what he wants. Obviously it is still a time-saver, but again, where is the line?

The line for me is items. If you can pay and get more/better items (even if it is just faster) is too much in my opinion.

1
TiminielOPI craft, therefore I am.•

the problem is: where is the line?

The line is drawn on the level of gear. If it is the best gear possible: it crosses the line. If it is not, it doesn't...

A person with that item could just craft a very good item, someone else would need to farm the mats over and over again, to get what he wants. Obviously it is still a time-saver, but again, where is the line?

Same place as last time. Is it BiS? It crosses the line. It isn't? Then it doesn't...

The line for me is items. If you can pay and get more/better items (even if it is just faster) is too much in my opinion.

Then you'll have problems with every single F2P MMO, mostly...

1
somebears•

there is no set definition on p2w. It is purely personal opinion.

Then you'll have problems with every single F2P MMO, mostly...

That's why I don't play them, mostly...

-1
Sarahdragoness•

Not sure I understand your concerns about bonuses for subscribers. If people are willing to pay for a game that is F2P, they should get some type of incentive to do so. Otherwise, everybody would be F2P and the game would die off from lack of income. I have played a couple of games that were F2P (Rift being a prime example) and did eventually start subbing partially because I was okay with supporting a game that I really enjoyed, and partially because of the incentives to do.

1
somebears•

My favorite f2p models are where you cannot buy anything that gives you any ingame benefits (eg dota). However, I understand that a model like this might be hard to sustain with a small playerbase, so I am 100% okay with the addition of convenience stuff such as extra bank slots (Path of exile did this).

Then there is stuff that worries me, but I can accept. Extra XP, money drops and stuff like that.

The overcharge thing is: when you craft an item, you apply charge to it. There is a cap, but you can overcharge the item to go above the cap. The more you go over that cap, the higher the chance that the crafting fails and you loose all items involved. If you are subscribed, the chance that this craft fails is reduced.

Although as a subscriber you cannot craft better items, you can craft them with a lower risk. This is what I don't like.

I have no problem with incentives to pay for a sub

1
Sarahdragoness•

Extra XP, money drops, etc are what usually drive people to sub though. It was one of the deciding factors behind me subbing to Rift, and is what will likely drive me to stay subbed to Wildstar as I am an alt-aholic. A cash shop alone is not going to sustain a game, sadly. Even though I will totally fork over some cash at some point if they have cool mounts in the cash shop. I guess I don't see the problem with crafting being a little less risky to people that sub as one of their benefits. shrug

1
somebears•

There are games that only have a cash shop and no subscription.

But I agree, extra Drops are driving people to subscribe and I think it is the right decision for wildstar at the moment.

There is nothing wrong with not seeing the problem. If this is a problem solely depends on each individual player. Every opinion is valid.

1