r/horror•
tpiddles121

Suggestions for *really* terrifying films?

Hey everyone, not a frequenter of this sub, but I do love horror films.

The problem is, I don't scare very easily anymore. There are still a few movies that do it for me, like The Shining, The Exorcist, the original Texas Chainsaw Massacre, but I'm looking for some new blood to add to the rotation.

I'm a big fan of more artistic works that focus greatly on cinematography, which is partially why I always come back to The Shining. I just watched Suspiria last night, and while it's an amazing film that I will watch many more times, it just didn't really scare me.

I'm not looking for jump scares, moreso psychological dread, but I'll check out anything with a good recommendation.

Thanks in advance!

Posted Sep 17, 2015, 5:15 PM UTC

61128
arsonist_in_flames•

Oh man, It Follows sounds perfect for you. Don't watch a trailer. Go in blind.

29
bachus2015•

It Follows is a great film for lots of reasons but I wouldn't say it was scary. Definitely original and very well made. Love that soundtrack and Maika Monroe.

21
BasketeerOverHere•

Different stuff scares different people though. I don't scare easily, but this movie actually kept me up at night. And I can't remember the last time a movie has made me lose sleep.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
sp00kyscaryGroovy•

I dunno, that movie got to me. I was looking over my shoulder constantly after I left the theatre. It gets under your skin.

1
bornagainredditor•

That movie was so incredibly boring.

0†

Original? It's a supernatural being that follows you around because you had sex with someone who had it first. I think it was well acted but the premise itself is really fucking lame.

-6†
TheFullMonty1394We all float down here•

Think deeper, you're missing the point of the movie

0
tpiddles121OP•

Sounds mysterious, I'll definitely watch. Is it on US Netflix?

8
PatShatner•

It's on Amazon Prime and Google Play. Don't think it's hit Netflix yet. Definitely worth the few bucks it'll cost to rent!

5
vincentxanthony•

Oh hell yeah amazon prime!

1
EHendrix•

It's not on prime, only for rent or purchase on Amazon Video.

3
arsonist_in_flames•

I don't have Netflix! :(

1
over-the-rainbow•

I just use a friend's Netflix. I'm sure someone you know would be willing to share.

1
HuwThePoo•

Seconding this. It Follows is absolutely brilliant.

6
cashhorror•

oldie but Goodie...The Changeling with George C. Scott. Probably one of the best ghost stories ever put to film.

29
alimaemia•

I am hardly ever frightened by films, but after this one I found it difficult to walk up a dark staircase.

3
tpiddles121OP•

I remember putting that on my horror list last Halloween season, but never getting around to watching. Thanks for the reminder!

2
JonTuna•

for a second I thought you were talking about the anjelina Jolie movie

3
poland626•

That movie turned out much more disturbing by the end than I was expecting. Also has a really well acted execution scene near the end imo

1
JonTuna•

ah yes, cowardice, fear, maybe guilt? not sure if there was guilt.

1
MikeKulick•

This is one that I thought "Oh, it's definitely not going to be as scary as when I watched it at age 12." Rewatched. "Nope. Still terrifying."

And it does it all without any major gore or jump scares. Really a gem.

1
bachus2015•

Martyrs...?

24
tpiddles121OP•

Never heard of it.

6
bachus2015•

Go watch it. Right now, guaranteed horror pleasure.

5
tpiddles121OP•

Just watched the trailer, it looks awesome! Thanks!

4
owarwolfoh they float, and when you're down here, you'll float too•

It's worth seeing at least once.

3
Johnnius_Maximus•

Definitely the most fucked up film I have ever seen... enjoy.

Edit: Be sure to pick up the unrated version.

2
azur08•

Careful with Martyrs. Based on what you've said, I'm not convinced you know what you're getting into.

2
badbluemoonHorrorNerd•

It's...meh. I wasn't as thrilled about it as other people seem to be.

2†
woizard•

Nope, don't bother. It's actually pretty weak and I guarantee you've seen something more fucked up on TV.

1
xBananaCatsxI don't go up there...•

I wish they had it on Netflix or Shudder...

2
666kat666•

Seconding this. Be prepared for an emotionally draining experience though.

2
chitibang•

My personal favorite horror film

1
over-the-rainbow•

YESSS! Still one of my most favorite movies of all time!

1
PatShatner•

Jacob's Ladder always unnerves the hell out of me when I watch it. Definitely more of a psychological terror.

21
tpiddles121OP•

Hmmm, that sounds familiar. I'll check it out. Any synopsis that doesn't ruin the reveal (if there is one)? The best part of a horror movie for me lies in being as clueless as the protagonist, wondering what the hell is going on.

3
PatShatner•

Tim Robbins plays a Vietnam veteran who begins experiencing some weird things after returning to civilian life. That's as vague as I can be without spoilers.

4
engelthefallen•

Go in blind after that. Jacob's Ladder is a true horror gem that too many overlook.

5
MrRezister•

Seconded. 'Jacob's Ladder' and 'Serpent and the Rainbow' are a couple of creepy films that Dad let me watch when I was 'probably' too young and they still get me today.

1
engelthefallen•

I will add in Event Horizon and Jack Ketchum's Girl Next Door.

Event Horizon is a ghost story in a starship basically. Very atmospheric.

Girl Next Door is terrifying in that for one, it is based on a true story and two it deals with sadistic side of human nature. It is the story of a girl being abused by her family, told from the perspective of a neighborhood boy.

18
bachus2015•

Event Horizon is great, one of the scariest films ever imo.

6
tpiddles121OP•

I saw Event Horizon, it was great, but I'm not too big into Sci-Fi so I had a hard time feeling the characters' fear, if that makes sense. Still a great film and worth the recommendation.

2
bravesaint•

The GND is absolutely worth watching. The only movie I've ever seen that makes ME feel like a complete piece of shit because I finished it.

You feel so fucking helpless...

4
AndrewEpidemic•

Isn't Girl Next Door based off of the same story as An American Crime? If anyone has seen both I'd like to know if one is better than the other. I've read a handful of Ketchum and liked The Woman, just wanted to know if I was missing out having seen American Crime but not GND.

2
bravesaint•

Yep, same story. An American Crime is nowhere fucking close to as brutal as GND. Watch it.

2
AndrewEpidemic•

Will do, probably regretfully. I found American Crime to be disturbing enough.

1
engelthefallen•

Read Girl Next Door if you liked Ketchum. Ketchum recreate the story from the view of one of the neighborhood boys. The movie is adapted from this approach, but the book, as usual, is better. A lot more emotional than the film. The film focused on the shocking parts IMO, the book expands into the emotional side of the story.

2
jerkstache•

And Catherine Mary Stewart is in it, so that is a plus.

1
jerkstache•

And Catherine Mary Stewart is in it, so that's a plus :)

0
redefine19•

The Strangers (2008)

13
gratefulfloyd67•

I think of this as one of the best horror movies in the past couple of decades. Really freaked me out. Mainly because it seems like its in the realm of possibility.

4
redefine19•

I agree. The same reason The Last House On The Left scared me.

2
kenpachi-rabbit•

i would say that this is outside of what you are looking for, but i highly enjoyed Willow Creek by Director Bobcat Goldthwait. i camp a lot, so maybe that made it ring home a bit more for me. a notable mention for the babadook as well.

9
TobiasQParanormal Activity 8 will revolutionize horror•

I found willow creek to be so boring.

9
wildmanofwongo•

Agreed. I was really looking forward to it, but sadly it's almost like a really shitty student film. There's a scene that's at least 20 minutes long that's nothing but a tight shot of two assholes sitting in a tent and listening to noises, for fuck's sake. Excruciatingly dull. And the bit at the end was just stupid.

3
AgressivelyZen•

I was disappointed in Willow Creek too but there is a movie called Exists, not sure if it's on Netflix but definitely Amazon that gets that storyline right.

1
Cumonkids•

I cringed through out willow creek entirely.

1
tpiddles121OP•

Ok, I'll check out Willow Creek. I've seen some trailers for the Babadook, but it seemed more like a jump scare-oriented movie. Plus I think the trailers may have spoiled the reveal a bit, and I'm looking for something that forces my mind to race wondering what the hell is going on.

Is Willow Creek on US Netflix? I think the "out in the wilderness, all alone" angle is really gripping. Blair Witch was great, although I tend to prefer something a bit more bloody. Cabin Fever was pretty good too, although it could have been better.

3
arsonist_in_flames•

Babadook definitely isn't jump scare-oriented. It lets your mind fill in the blanks. Worth your time.

9
tpiddles121OP•

Ok, I'll check it out. Thanks!

2
666kat666•

Babadook sucks sorry. Everyone jerks off the movie as if its the Citizen Kane of horror. It's very weak as even a psychological thriller.

Off the top of my head first Silent Hill, Triangle (especially if you're looking for psychological horror), It Follows. Goodnight Mommy is also decent.

-3†
douglas_p•

You can watch Willow Creek on Shudder. It's only 5 bucks a month, or you can check the free live channel often to see if it's on.

1
over-the-rainbow•

Babadook got me in a "my mom was psychologically abusive" way. I think that if I could of disconnected the ptsd then it wouldn't have been as scary.

1
lizzievicarious•

Willow Creek was great. I think I rented it on Amazon for a couple of bucks, and it was worth the money. I, too, camp a lot and have always been a but jumpy about being in my tent at night surrounded by god only knows what.

1
douglas_p•

Willow Creek is my favorite found footage movie ever. That long, single-shot tent scene is soooo intense.

1
The_Dead_See•

Session 9

Lovely Molly

Saint Ange

Starry Eyes

The Silent House

The Return

A tale of two sisters

Mothman Prophecies

Burnt Offerings

The Innocents

The Devil's Backbone

As above, so below

Skjult

Below

The Burrowers

The Descent

The Changeling

Frailty

Stir of Echoes

The Pact

The Shrine

Noroi

Ils

The Sentinel

Carnival of Souls

9
Frito_feet•

Frailty is quite good. Identity is another one that came out in the early 2000's and has a similar quality about it.

2
MikeKulick•

Lovely Molly is one of the most unsettling films I've ever seen. Definitely worth watching once. I think it fits what the OP is looking for.

1
666kat666•

Lovely Molly bored me out of my senses. As Above So Below was laughably bad.

-1
gratefulfloyd67•

I've said it here before and I'll say it again: Rosemary's Baby.

Did not know anything about the film other than the premise and there were so many times I clutched the arm of the chair and said "what the fuck". Real slow burner that makes you suffer.

Generally I think of it as one of the scariest (I know its subjective but this is what scares me) films I've ever seen. And I place it in my "Unholy Trinity": The Exorcist, The Shining, and Rosemary's Baby.

9
tpiddles121OP•

Yes, Rosemary's baby is amazing! Another good one is the original Omen, although I haven't seen it for a few years.

Any more obscure movies that are classics? I'm looking for something I haven't seen before, but you hit the nail on the head as far as taste goes.

3
marcomc2•

That is my primary, top-shelf trinity of horror, as well.

1
imspooky•

Did you coin them "The Unholy Trinity?" Can I steal that? It's perfect.

1
gratefulfloyd67•

ahaha I'm not sure if I coined it. But I came up with it independently. And yeah of course you can haha

2
Steffenwolflikeme•

The movies you mentioned are classics...it's rare to find movies that are truly scary anymore. Alien is a great horror movie that hasn't been mentioned. The Thing (1982) is also probably one of the scarier movies that you'll likely see. Martyrs is worth watching and more of a newer release. Hausu isn't scary but if you're into horror you should check that out...It's an experience. I always try to recommend Cemetery Man in horror subs as often as possible. It's not very scary but it's my a great movie.

8
Frito_feet•

Gnaghi!

2
bachus2015•

Not often chosen, and not strictly a horror (more thriller) but please watch Dead Calm. Pretty damn terrifying movie with characters you'll give a shit about.

7

No offense to OP, but... can... can we have a megapost for these type of questions? Like, a stickied post at the top saying 'Looking for a scary film that is really gory / really scary / an introduction to horror for people who don't like horror? Post your requests here!' People could ask for suggestions there and people reply to give suggestions rather than the same old posts.

Serious suggestion. It seems like these kind of questions get asked all the time here, and far be it to suggest people don't ask questions, but these questions are asked so often that it's getting a bit annoying and same-y now.

OP, I'm not bashing you at all. You've given info about films that scare you, so people know what you're looking for when you ask for terrifying films, which is better than 80% of similar posts here. I just think some kind of request thread might be better than the same questions getting posted over and over.

In retrospect, I should have picked one of the really shitty 'suggest me a film' posts, like 'I love horror. I want to watch a really scary film that will scar me for life. Suggest.' (I hate those so much), but yours was the newest request therefore you got the brunt of my rant.

Seriously, it's nothing personal, and not really critical at all... Not at all. I’ve got nothing against you, OP, and as I said, your request was both reasonable and provided enough detail for people to suggest films. It’s just that there are so many posts like this and I'm just a bit sick of endless 'suggest me a scary film' post when they could all be condensed into a single megapost. Plus, if they were all condensed together, you could scroll through them and see if anyone else has a similar taste in films and made a similar request and get even more ideas of films to watch!

That said, I have this sinking feeling that I'm about to be downvoted into oblivion.

5†
tpiddles121OP•

No worries, I'm not a frequenter of r/horror, but I see a lot of the same old tired requests in the subs that I do visit often. I understand why you feel that way, it's completely valid.

Again, I don't come here often, so I'm not very familiar with the community, but a lot of subs post megathreads that many of the insightful users never check, so people don't really get answers.

I'm an outsider, so I have nowhere near the final say, but megathreads for those topics don't seem to work very often in my experience. I'm not sure if there is a sub specifically for horror requests, but I would gladly go there if it existed.

I took a glance at the Dreadit movie guide and it was a bit daunting. The only reason I posted was because I wanted a bit more input on personal suggestions.

Anyway, your post is completely warranted, I see the same thread over and over on other subs. I'm not sure if a megathread would be the right idea though, as once they've been up for a while, no one really checks them, so new commenters don't get any suggestions.

A horror film suggestion sub might be a good idea if this happens often in this sub. Anyway, thanks for the civil reply, there were many more combative responses you could have possibly given.

5
MusicFoMe•

I think the sense of exploration and discovery is what can make a horror movie really good and scary. If you get a list of recommended "truly scary" movies, you're going to sit down and prepare yourself, thinking "Oh boy, time to get freaked the fuck out" and invariably it won't live up to your expectations.

I've found the best way to find those really scary movies is to just watch a lot of horror movies, different genres, and eventually you'll find some incredible ones. To a degree, you can get desensitized watching so many, but that's really just being lulled into a false sense of security. One night you'll decide to sit down to watch another horror movie, expecting to have a fun time watching it like you have with the past movies, but this time you're caught off guard and scared to shit.

5

Thank you for your awesome reply! I was worried that I might offend you, or you might have taken it the wrong way, but it's nice to see you understand where I'm coming from, and I can see your points too! :)

Yeah, I think every large sub suffers from the same problems, it's in no way unique to /horror, and if you're new to a community I think it's natural to ask the same kind of questions and look for recommendations. It's just that it's done so often that it gets a bit like...deja-vu? And I think a megathread would allay some of that - yeah, people looking for ultra-niche things might not find it useful, but people like you looking for a scary or scarring film and with quite a broad idea of what you want can look through suggestions to other questions as well as your own, which could be useful?

I dunno, you might be right in that megathreads fail more often than not, but I frequent quite a few beauty subs and forums (I’m very girly, so sue me, haha. I like to clutter my bathroom with an infestation of bottles of bizarre skin products and make-up) and since they have a high amount of new people asking similar or the same questions and a high amount of people willing to give advice, they have set up what turns out to be very successful megathreads and Q and As. At the same time, it seems like posting questions there gets a better feedback and more answers than starting an independent thread/post. It depends on the community, I guess, but I think it could work in horror as it’s pretty much the same - there’s a lot of new and curious people asking similar questions, and a lot of seasoned horror geeks willing (or even eager) to give recommendations – simply move all the questions and suggestions over to the megathread and it could work just the same, if not better.

Anyway, sorry, it was just a bit of vent/suggestion hybrid. And for it’s worth, I too find the lists of films kind of intimidating and I’ve seen a good chunk of the Dreadit one! It's hard to find what you want in lists, I must admit.

And sorry I’m not really bringing anything to your question – I just kind of moaned like a spoilt brat, haha. I’m not great at suggestions, but if it’s slow-burn dread and creepy atmosphere you want, I recommend Noroi (The Curse). Two caveats are is that it’s found footage (so it’s not the most artistically interesting film, although it has some interesting imagery if my memory serves right), and it’s Japanese so you may need subtitles. If neither of those are a deal-breaker, it’s pretty interesting, heavy on the dread/doom feeling, well developed characters and creepy atmosphere and good for a one-time watch at least. I’m biased, I love the film, but even I can’t say it’s perfect, and I can’t promise you’ll enjoy it, but it might be worth a watch.

Edit: I write too much. TL;DR: Thanks for your cool reply, and I'm glad you're not offended. I completely understand, but I think a megathread/megapost could still work, here at least. Noroi is a good dread-filled slow-burn creepy film.

1
willreignsomnipotentMeet me at the waterfront after the social•

1- I do like the sticky idea. I'd also like to see that. Or hell, even a weekly / bi-weekly / whatever "Suggest awesome scary movies" thread. Not because i don't like these threads-- but rather, because I LOVE them.

2- You're right, that they do show up a lot. But I honestly don't mind seeing them, and I've been coming here pretty regularly for a couple years now. Sometimes daily. And I still never tire of the "Recommend a movie" threads, just like I never tire of the weekly watch reports, or the "What's Streaming..." threads. I think they're a great way to discover new movies.

You occasionally get some really obscure out-of-left-field recommendations... but you also get to see which movies are recommended again, and again, and again. Which might sound tedious, but it also tells you that they're widely loved films.

3- This is not the busiest subreddit. If there was a lot of good content getting pushed off page 1, because of all these recommendation threads... I'd probably agree that there should be less of them. But I don't typically see that as the case. We get too few interesting posts here. And many of the interesting posts that aren't "What have you watched" / "What should I watch" / "Movie XYZ is Awesome / Sucked Ass" threads, they're often reposts from bloody disgusting, dread central, etc.

And even then, those posts can sit on page 1 for a day or two with few replies.

But some of these recommendation threads can collect tons of responses. It is obvious that some people hate them-- and just as obvious that some of us love them. And aside from the "XYZ Movie Was Awesome / Sucked Ass" threads, these also spark some of the best discussion about individual films that I've seen here.

We seem to become even more passionate about these films when we're trying to explain to others why they were terrible, or amazing-- and therefore worth (or not) their time.

Long Live The Recommendation Threads!

4
kats_on_ice•

I always read the posts for these types of questions and I love seeing them come up often! I often feel like "hmmmm I really want to watch something particularly scary today," and am always open to suggestions. Sure you get a lot of the same suggestions here over and over but nice to see what people are saying that day in case something new comes up. I say, keep these posts coming!

3

I'm not saying people asking for ideas and suggestions is a bad thing, of course not. What I'm saying is that there's been an awful lot of them as of late, and maybe a stickied megapost where people can ask for suggestions and browse other suggestions may be a neater way of doing it. Also, since you like browsing suggestion posts (and a lot of people do), all the questions and answers would be in one place, making it easier.

1
azur08•

What about something like this? r/horrorsuggestions

1
ehhlis•

The Taking of Deborah Logan is a newish horror on Netflix that's fantastic. A woman is doing her thesis on Alzheimer's & as her time with Deborah, an old woman with Alzheimer's, goes on, she wonders if there's something more sinister at play. Couldn't recommend this one enough. Scared me more than It Follows (which is also great) & that waste of time The Babadook

5
j0hn1313•

Deborah Logan was decent but got boring at parts, it follows was incredible, the soundtrack made it even more intense. I'm with you on babadook...so much potential, but stock monster noises? I felt like I was playing Turok whenever the monster did some shit

2
batasg•

Coming Soon. The thai one

3
666kat666•

Seconding this!

0
jason-funk•

Cannibal Holocaust makes pretty much anyone uncomfortable

3
over-the-rainbow•

I loved The Banshee Chapter. I'm also desensitized but that one kept me up for a few days. I've learned that when the jump scares and gore don't do it for you anymore, psychological and creepy will do it.

3
FionnaAndCake•

I thought this one was really sloppy.

2
over-the-rainbow•

I think that's why I liked it.

1
Broken_chairs•

lake mungo

noroi

shudders

3
[deleted]•

I'm a huge fan of horror but there are very few actually scary horror movies...most good horror movies are generally disturbing, emotionally powerful films (Martyrs, Snowtown, The Vanishing, etc), or atmospheric/suspenseful (Halloween, The Shining).

The only horror movies that have actually scared me in the sense of real fear and terror are The Descent, Insidious, Grave Encounters, and [REC].

P.S. Just watched Perfect Sense with Eva Green and Ewan McGregor on Netflix last night and it is one of the most horrific films I've ever seen. It's actually a Romance/Drama but trust me...its nightmarish. Absolutely blew me away with how good it was.

2
thatcambridgebird•

Eden Lake isn't a bad choice to pick up on your psychological dread requirement. It's UK based, but the themes should still play out well enough if you're not from the UK.

2
SpaceCat87 Ma'am, we didn't find any boy.•

Nosferatu

2