Preventing company devices from joining guest wireless?
Here's the context: we have two wireless networks, one internal and one guest. Internal is only for company-provided devices and is protected by certs. Guest is protected by a password that we change every so often and has no access to any internal resources.
Our infosec group would like a way to prevent users from joining their company-provided devices to the guest network, as a data loss prevention measure. The best solutions we can think of are black-holing the MAC addresses either in DHCP (trivially bypassed) or on the switch (still bypass-able, but not as trivial). Black-holing MAC addresses on the switch at this level (hundreds of MAC addresses) will also cause a pretty severe performance hit.
Ignoring the obvious flaw here (users can just load up their company laptop with data, then take it him and unload), is there some clever solution that someone can recommend?
Posted Sep 18, 2015, 12:54 AM UTC
If they're allowed to connect their company-provided devices to home, airport, and other networks then this isn't really achieving anything.
You:
Me:
Yes... I know, as should be obvious by the fact that I actually said that.
But my infosec department doesn't answer to me. And right now they have our CTO's ear because of the Sony break-in last year, so this is the direction we're moving whether I like it or not. I don't have the luxury of sitting at my desk with my hands in my ears going "lalala" when I'm given a directive as apparently some people do.
So if you can't be helpful, at least read what I'm asking for and don't give a non-answer.
Helpful answer: NAC
But seriously your infosec team is beyond retarded and I question their effectiveness if theyre chasing shit like this.. Coming from someone who works in infosec.
Guess what? I question their effectiveness too. But that doesn't change anything... does it?
Cool your jets sunshine.
I made the statement more to confirm if that was the case, which would give more context to the situation.
With it now clear that users can take the devices home, or connect to them to any network anywhere, it would make for a case to engage with the information security team and explain that this is a significant technical challenge, possibly not achievable in any kind of scalable way, and that perhaps the stance needs a rethink.
In this case he said it's a policy decision, but there could be technical reasons too. Our Guest wifi doesn't touch our routers/DNS/DHCP, it uses a dedicated firewall at each site which can only hand out a /24 for DHCP. Letting all the coporate devices on it instead of our enterprise network (which has AD/DNS/DHCP and the whole 9 yards) would exhaust the local DHCP scope quickly.
Just pointing out that there are other reasons for a request like this.
Exactly, your infosec team may be retarded unless the expectation is to only be able to use the Corp wifi and no other wifi just cellular maybe