Is GCI throttling our internet?

I'm currently using GCI's '50mb/s download and 3mb/s upload' plan that includes 150gb of data. I have 3 days left in my cycle and well over 50gb left according to MyGCI.com

I'm having trouble streaming videos in 720p 1k~ bitrate even though I have plenty of data left. My speedtest.net test showed that my download speed was fine and I'm able to download files at a fast speed, but when it comes to video streaming, it's going incredibly slow. It feels like they're throttling certain domains like YouTube, Netflix, and Twitch.

I'll also point out that I'm using a fresh install of Windows 7 that's fully up to date, and my browsers are also up to date. I'm using a high end PC with an i7-4790K and 16gb of RAM. I just got a new router from GCI last month when I re opened my account, so I don't see how there could be possibly be a problem on my side.

Is anyone else having this problem? What's the point in throttling certain websites if we already have a data cap??

Posted Sep 18, 2015, 2:58 AM UTC

1839
allthe_gundamsArctic Tough!•

I've already reported them to the FCC. Keep reporting them.

7
VorpalEskimo•

Nonsense like this is why Net Neutrality laws are important.

You've checked for spyware and stuff right?

5
AnonymouselolOP•

I just reinstalled windows 7 a few days ago. I'm good at avoiding spyware and malware, but formatted for space. I know that I can't possible have spyware or malware on my PC, and I'm using Avast and Malwarebytes for the extra protection.

3
akthrowaway159753•

Nonsense like what? You can't prove that GCI is doing anything. They may just have a true Network Congestion issue somewhere in their network. On top of that, they may be actively trying to resolve it, but things take time.

-1
hobobandy•

I have the 250mbps/10mbps up and do have streaming issues sometimes and especially with Twitch.tv live streaming. Apparently (based on Twitch support traceroutes and such) .. it's either GCI or a link to lower 48.

Let's just say I'm keeping the plan for the 10mb/sec downloads, but streaming sucks sometimes.

4
redditor21•

Try a vpn?

1
AnonymouselolOP•

Do VPNs really solve throttling? I haven't thought of that. I'll look into it, thanks.

1
redditor21•

yeah! thwy work great- try Privateinternetaccess.com

3
hobobandy•

yeah I have PIA, been kinda shitty for streaming/gaming.. I know it's partially Twitch's fault as well since their stupid main server is like in Texas or something, then it goes back to west coast server

1
AnonymouselolOP•

I just tried watching a Twitch stream. It's lagging on low quality (360p and 400 bitrate). Ridiculous...

1
madcowbomber•

Are you going straight from the modem to your computer? Is it possible your wifi router could be bottlenecking it?

4
AnonymouselolOP•

Yes it's going straight to my PC from my modem. Using ethernet cable, not wifi.

4
madcowbomber•

You might try swapping the modem out.

2
methodical713•

I see a lot of people complaining about twitch problems - I've had them too. My work internet is provided by GCI but it's fiber based and their highest tier of service, so I seriously doubt that GCI is throttling.

Youtube and Netflix are actually hosted in GCI's anchorage datacenter now. twitch is the only one that truly streams from the lower 48.

This sounds like packet loss, I'll check it out tomorrow.

3

Good ole GCI, bottom of the barrel service at top of the line prices. Their company slogan should be "Oh yeah?what are you gonna do about it?"

3
AKPhenom•

......then Verizon comes to town..

1

I'm not sure they could be any worse than GCI.

1
rms_is_god•

pop pop

"ohhh we're the only high speed internet available in your areeeaaa?"

[nipple rubbing intensifies]

1
The_Alaskan•

I've kept a speedtest.net account, deliberately checking weekly for several months, but haven't found any throttling even though I changed plans during that process.

2
AnonymouselolOP•

I think throttling usually means that the ISP slows your internet down at certain times of the day, or slows down certain sites.

2
The_Alaskan•

Oh. OK.

1
akjax•

Adding to that, if GCI is throttling intentionally, they are going to specifically make sure your speedtest.net results still come back showing you are getting your full speed.

1
The_Alaskan•

Even going to different speedtest stations?

1
_chris-•

When you call support to discuss why the internet is especially slow the technician will have you run a test at http://speedtest.gci.com/

More often than not, the simple act of making the call about slow internet seems to fix the issue!

1
_chris-•

I have 50Mbps down too, and was buffering on Twitch MEDIUM earlier tonight. GCI is the worst.

2
ak_hepcatAnchorage•

(IP) Network Engineer with 20 years experience, here.

It's probably not you, and it's probably not your provider.

It's probably the remote server.

In fact, if you do a search for Twitch issues, you'll see that you're not alone.

http://lmgtfy.com/?q=twitch+streaming+issues

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Arkiekins•

I've been having issues with Twitch the last couple of day as well, on r/twitch there were others in the lower 48 that had issues as well. So may be a data center. but i wouldnt put it past GCI.

1
Impede•

Or maybe just call their tech support and have them check it out?

1
unclebottom•

It's likely just a slowdown.

Meanwhile, at GCI headquarters

1
ak_hepcatAnchorage•

That is exactly how those 100Gb/s undersea fibers pass the bits.

2
Leavesdoorsopen•

Why would you rent a router from GCI? They only cost ~$50-70.

1
AnonymouselolOP•

Does GCI charge you for using their modems?

1
akjax•

I don't think so, that or it's a "normal fee". Modems aren't nearly as normal for consumers to buy, you're not going to find them at best buy. Routers on the other hand, people normally get their own.

2
thehuston•

Most people here have some logical answer here but as a side note. You can download up to 50mb/s but if the server you're downloading from isn't uploading at 50mb/s then you get what they can give.

1
victoriiFairbanks•

I experienced a period of almost 24 hours this week where my internet was so slow I couldn't even watch a youtube video on my phone. Keep reporting them to the FCC.

1
EpicSoren•

I have noticed incidents like this too. Ill be trying to watch a video or upload maybe and suddenly everything slows down. Though when I go check speedtest, it actually shows my speed being dropped significantly. I believe I'm on the same plan as you.

1
ak_kitaqeskimo. no, really.•

A small sliver of your problem could probably be explained by content delivery networks. Since Twitch is live, there's no way for a content delivery network to cache videos on a server in GCI's local datacenter. And since a server isn't infinitely large, it's not like it can cache every YouTube or Netflix video. They can cache lots, but not everything.

Like I said, the CDN problem is likely one component of the problem, rather than the full explanation.

1
arcticlynx_ak☆•

This seems relevant to post here. ;)

GCI slowdown

0