Has there ever been a sale on Steam and other questions...

Has Stonehearth ever been on sale on Steam? I've recently been watching the Let's Play of some people, and it seems decently fun, but then I read the bug/complaints and I'm hesitant about spending the $25 dollars on a severely unfinished/buggy game.

I've played Cities: Skylines, Prison Architect and Banished and they've each net me about 50 hours of play time. Will I get the same "value" out of Stonehearth?

Posted Sep 22, 2015, 4:51 PM UTC

16
jonzoid•

This question get asked a lot and the answers always boil down to "it depends". You will lose hours of work to a bug at some point. Not every part of the game has a lot of depth right now. World generation is pretty basic. Combat is basic and somewhat frustrating. Some of the character classes aren't that useful except for an item or two. There's no real difficulty from the enemies.

On the other hand, building custom buildings can be a ton of fun and has a lot of options. Alpha 12 looks like it should have a lot of really neat updates to farming/cooking that, in my opinion, really give you a reason to want to have variation in your food.

The developers also have one or two live streams every week. They communicate with and listen to their fans. The community is small but really passionate (check out discourse.stonehearth.net). Modding is fun if you're into that.

If you're just looking to chill out and play a game for a while then you should probably wait a while. If you like to play around, experiment, build, mod, etc, then you can sink plenty of hours into it.

3
hypocriticalfoolOP•

Thanks for the reply. I'm still leaning towards buying the game just to mess around with it.

I'm not much of a modder. My main interest in city building games is the planning aspect and efficiency of the city/town. I've sat down at games and had them on pause for hours while I mapped out locations for buildings and what not, then scrapped the plans completely because I forgot some minor detail in the planning. And I'm having fun, so I'm not worried about losing hours of work if the game crashes.

If you have time, I have a couple of additional questions that I hope you'll be able to answer.

  1. Can you build ladders indoors? I've see multistory buildings in the play throughs, but I've only seen ladders outdoors.

  2. Can you have a tribute box/storage pile for the invaders? I'm just thinking if I can place a storage box/tiny storage pile on the outskirts of town by a berry bush and set it to food only, then harvest the berries. When the goblins and other enemies come to invade, will they just raid the storage box of food and be happy? Or will they still aim for the bigger storage site?

  3. How many Hearthlings do you manage to have before the game starts lagging? I tried out Clockwork Empires and the game started lagging at around 25 citizens, which is kind of disappointing.

  4. Do all animals stay in the same animal pen/enclosure? Or do they require different ones? Is there a limit to animals that you can keep in the enclosure? I'm curious because I'm thinking if I need to plan out how many animal pens/spacing vs packing 300 animals in a 10x10 enclosure.

Sorry if some of my questions were answered on discourse.stonehearth.net already, but I can't access the site while at work. Thanks again.

1
CHARGER007•

ill try to answer those for you.

  1. Yes you can.

  2. Maybe, they will take stuff from the crate but they always end up coming back.

  3. I can get around 20-25 before it start getting really bad.

  4. Actually i dont know because when i use the shepperd, he never manage to find any sheep but i think thats on my end though.

1
hypocriticalfoolOP•

Thanks. For 3, I was wondering if I could play a sort of pacifist town because I imagined the monsters were merely "hangry" and therefore would be appeased and go away with food.

1
CHARGER007•

well, once in a while a goblin cheif will ask for specific ressources and if you meet them, he will become more friendly and attack less often. he will eventually comeback and ask again after a certain period has passed.

you can also refuse and just attack them to get rid of him and you can get some sweet loot but they comeback after a while.

1
CHARGER007•

yeah im at around 40-50 hours of play time for the game but i can still see 150 more because of the updates that makes me comeback every once in a while.

the game is fun but still a bit buggy and lack luster in depth.

1