Finishing powder seems to remove half my concealor so I have to keep building until it's cakey. What am I doing wrong?

Disclaimer: This is a probably a super noob question.

I have some acne on my chin area and so I apply foundation with a sponge and blend it out (Vichy Dermablend), then go back in with a little brush with the some foundation and it looks perfect! Then I apply finishing powder (bareMinerals Mineral Veil) by dabbing it on as opposed to sweeping it all over my face (using a large Ecotools powderbrush) and it seems to remove most of the work I did with the brush. So then I pull out my Marajuca Creaseless concealor and get back to work but it still takes 2-3 cycles of having them completely covered and then half is removed by my powder. It's really frustrating because I end up looking cakey half the time. I've trying watching a variety of videos including Lisa Eldridge's video on covering spots, but they all seem to keep their concealor and foundation intact after applying powder. What am I doing wrong?

tl;dr When I apply finishing powder it seems to take off half my concealor underneath so I have to keep applying until I look cakey. What am I doing wrong?

Edit: Added product specifics above in bold.

Posted Sep 23, 2015, 12:29 PM UTC · edited

2021
Selenashines•

Are you letting the concealer sit for a bit or applying powder while it's still very wet?

If I'm doing spot coverage and not under my eyes where the concealer will crease. I like to wait until the conceal is a little tacky then apply powder.

12
HelloKimiOP•

I've been applying right away while it's still wet. I think I heard or read somewhere that if you don't apply powder right away it will crease, but that advice must only be for undereye circles then! Thank you, this is really great advice. I'll give it a try :)

Edit: Tried doing this the following day and it worked!! I just applied concealor like normal but I did my eyes before I went back and powdered and it all stayed on. I can't believe it was such a simple fix. Thank you so much!

4
saramace•

To add to that, be sure to let your foundation dry before putting concealer on. I'm not sure why but letting layers of foundation/concealer dry in between "coats" really cuts down on the cakey look. You can build it up so much more seamlessly if you let the layers dry as you build.

I have melasma and this is the only way I've found to prevent my coverage from getting moved around from one application to the next.

9
HelloKimiOP•

Thank you, this will be the first thing I try. I can't believe I didn't think of somthing so simple haha

2
marielaveaux83•

If you are using your finger to apply the finishing powder then the oils on your fingertips could be the culprit. That can remove the makeup below as well as create a weird consistency with the powder. Also, if you are using a brush, make sure your brush is cleaned often because when my powder brush gets too much product built up on it, it doesn't perform well at all. I wash mine about once every 1-2 weeks.

3
HelloKimiOP•

I'm using this powder brush from Ecotools: https://www.ecotools.com/brushes/face-tools/large-powder-brush

I clean my brush religiously every week, but I haven't really noticed a difference in coverage in the few days after it's been cleaned.

1
pinkiswink•

I had this problem way way back when I used a covergirl mineral finishing foundation.

Two things: the foundation might be too coarse and heavy combined with too stiff a brush. Try a super fluffy (synthetic) brush like a blusher that's not too dense... or a stippling blush. Lastly, consider a more finely-ground finishing powder.

Another thing that could work is applying makeup fixing spray before or after applying your concealer to help it adhere to your skin better.

3
HelloKimiOP•

Thanks for the advice! I'll definitely look into the setting spray. Do you have a favourite you use?

1
emmawhitmanNW15 | On a quest for THAT red•

Elf making a great setting spray.

2
pinkiswink•

I used a sample from MakeupForever and it's amazing. Definitely recommend that.

Other ones I've used include NYX and ELF. I personally think ELF is a little better than NYX. It's also cheap enough you won't feel bad if you don't like it.

2
ecle•

I would make sure your concealer has had time to try and set itself a bit before you add powder. Do the powder with a puff. That way you can gently press and roll the powder onto your chin without moving anything.

3
HelloKimiOP•

Thanks, I like the suggestion of using a puff instead! I'll give it a try :)

1
burbless•

What are you using to apply the finishing powder? Dabbing it on makes it sound like you're using your finger haha. I use a powder brush and just lightly brush it all over my face. That seems to work and doesn't take my other makeup off.

2
HelloKimiOP•

I'm using this powder brush from Ecotools: https://www.ecotools.com/brushes/face-tools/large-powder-brush

Sorry for the confusing use of words there. I just meant to imply that I'm using the brush to softly pat my face, rather than sweeping it across my chin which would I assumed would just wipe everything off. Do you do the same thing as me? Maybe my brush isn't soft enough or something then :S

2
satanhitl3r•

I know the struggle, as my problem area also happens to be my chin. I think that maybe the powder is just accentuating the bumps. Is there a way to get the desired coverage without having to use a powder?

Also, for the past two weeks or so, I've been applying a pressed powder before my foundation and it seems to make it all last longer and feel/look smoother. I have noticed though, that I may be using more foundation than the regular method [foundation, concealer, powder], since it seems to absorb more quickly into the powder. (i.e - it's harder to blend out.) But, it really is super flawless and prevents the concealer, powder, concealer, powder cycle I was previously experiencing.

2
HelloKimiOP•

I could definitely get it looking great without using powder, but I'm worried if I don't my oily skin will just cause it all to slide off and be ruined by lunch :( I supposed it's worth a try.

I'll also try changing the order of foundation and primer as well. Thanks for the advice!

0
felicia-sexopants•

Lately I've been applying my finishing powder with a barely damp beauty blender sponge (the real techniques one, actually). I gently dab it on and bounce/roll it a bit to blend. It seems to press it in well without being cakey or removing the product already on my face. I also agree with the suggestions to make sure each layer of product has set before moving to the next when spot concealing. I've never used mineral veil or dermablend, though, so they could behave differently.

2
pinkerbellprincess•

What exactly are you using as your finishing powder? Unless it's Mineral Veil, please note that all the BareMinerals powders are actually foundations, which may be the source of the cakeyness issue.

If you're willing to buy a new powder, I would recommend a loose powder over pressed. Pressed is great for on-the-go-touch ups, but loose powder is more finely milled and will be better for setting your foundation/concealer. I've used Vichy Dermablend and their setting power makes a good companion to the foundations.

1
HelloKimiOP•

Yep, I'm using Mineral Veil and it is a loose powder. Sorry should have probably specified that in the original post! I still have almost a full container but I'm definitely willing to check out Vichy's Dermablend powder since I'm so impressed with their foundation. Also Mineral Veil is a finishing powder whereas Dermablend is a setting powder, isn't it? I think that might make a difference as well.

1
midwest_is_best•

i always had this issue, too! i started using bareminerals foundation as a concealer (applying with a beautyblender), then go all over with the mineral veil. since they are both powders, it seems to do the trick just fine : )

1
Wolf_Craft•

I hate that concealor so much. Could not get it to stay on. MUFE and Urban Decay have been my saving grace.

1