r/survivor•
Aloj

Survivor, just a great epic story (a bit long, apologies)

This season and this episode showcase perfectly why i think Survivor is one of the greatest stories ever told, obviously from an editing standpoint, since it’s the editing that makes the story. In line with the Season’s theme, the editors deliberately chose to build this season, and this episode in particular, around a very simple but compelling dichotomy: capacity to change/stuck in the old ways. Which means no new watcher could ever understand what is truly going on here, and only someone who’s read/watched the first 30 chapters can understand why people made the choices they made, why they changed or not. Which is also why watching this episode i got a real impression i was watching the shocking conclusion/development to some compelling and long-lost storylines of the book of Survivor : even in depicting Wigglesworth or Varner, you got the feeling the story is picking up right where it left off, like a Song of Ice and Fire chapter . A real saga vibe. Maybe i’m too obsessed with good storytelling, but here are my ideas. Sorry about the length.

Capacity to change:

Terry Deitz. This is really the main element that left me in shock after last episode. Here is this man who hasn’t played in ten years. The first time around he was good at challenges but had major conflicts with many players in the game, he was never really able to connect, not just on a strategic level, but on a basic conversational level, let alone a social one. Terry knows this time he should pay more attention, yet it doesn’t seem like it’s happening. One night though, all of his tribe outcasts poor little Abi, and something inside Terry snaps. “I should talk to her”. And just like that, without even really realizing it, Terry Deitz stumbles into the social game for the first time in his Survivor history. And makes the difference by essentially bringing Abi to his side. Just go re-watch Panama and tell me this isn’t an incredible story. One of the players in Survivor history you could say never,ever understood how to make friends or allies since he was first introduced to us, manages to flip an erratic player on a more difficult season, by going against his inner instincts and just walking up to her and connecting with her. That’s all he did. He sat down, and talked to someone, changing his Survivor story. Incredible, like watching a baby making his first steps.

Woo Hwang. Breaking the curse of the follower. There are some people in life that follow. They don’t really know what decision to make, what to do when a dilemma or difficulty arises and ask for guidance or help, essentially letting someone else decide for them. And so it is in Survivor. For an entire season and until the very last and important moment, Woo suffered the consequences of letting another person choose his own destiny, and paid it with the price of failure. So just like Terry stands up, walks up to Abi and connects, Woo stands up, says no more and rejects a person that thought they could influence him just like Tony did. Looking at Shirin and Spencer, realizing and understanding for the first time that they don’t have his best interest at heart but only theirs, Woo says no. I won’t vote with you. No. This No is possibly the greatest achievement in Woo’s Survivor story. And the editors picked him up right where they left him off, only the Yes became a No.

Kass McQuillen. We haven’t seen a lot from Kass, especially from a strategic standpoint, granted. There has been no need for it yet. But Kass also had major social game issues the first time around. Not only did she backstab, she did it with very little class, showing a very abrasive personality, and made very few friends in the game. She also set herself to stand out of her tribe, made everyone point the finger at her, tried to be the center of attention. But this time Kass says no more. She decides to fade into the background, connect with all the working bees on day one, chitchat with the other women, accept Savage’s speeches and stories about how a tribe is a family, and how much he misses his wife. She chooses to never disrespect anyone or diss on them for no reason whatsoever. She knows that putting up a good face, making people think that you care or enjoy something they said or appreciating who they are, is just as important as actually caring and appreciating them. As long as they don’t know what you really think. And her Survivor story is forever changed.

Kelley Wentworth. This is one of those characters in the book that you don’t really see coming. They are in the background, they don’t seem to bring a lot to the story but slowly their part gets bigger and bigger, until the supporting actor becomes the lead. Without her father, after understanding that if she wants to make it far in the story she needs to be the leader and take control of her destiny, just like the winner of her season did, Kelley is so far the biggest hero of this chapter of Survivor. The moment where she decides if and when to go and grab the idol is the moment her Survivor destiny is forever changed. Had she not grabbed it, she would have gone back to letting bigger personalities make the decisions, take the shots and reach for idols. Instead she chose to be THE one that would do it. And we are now being showed what and how she thinks. The Survivor story has a new protagonist.

Jeff Varner. This is starting to be very long and i feel i’m doing it for myself more than anything, but i’ll keep going, especially since i really think this is one of the most outstanding character arcs in Survivor history. Here is this young, witty man, who’s snarky in confessionals, stuck on a tribe with a big personality that gets medevaced and a few feisty ones (Kimmi, Alicia), who never really gets a chance at really playing the game and fails at it because of a rule that doesn’t even exist anymore. He hasn’t had enough time to shine. And it looks like he will never get a chance to show what he was truly worth. He changes, he ages, 15 years (!) pass. He is now a middle-aged man, he is not as fit as he was, but he is more witty and eager to prove himself than he ever was. His obsession for this game can be heard in his voice, read on his face, grasped in the way he conducts himself. He has a scar from a deep wound that opened a long time ago. But the game has changed, just like he has. He knows it, all the other players know it. And yet Jeff is on a path to get what was taken away from him 15 years ago, even if it means playing like a young buck in the body of a 50 year old, and he will adapt and change his strategy according to what benefits him, and be damned everyone else. An old schooler playing like the most aggressive new schooler. I don’t know if this will be the right strategy, i think he might be playing too hard too soon. But from what we’ve seen so far Jeff Varner is stealing the show, he is having fun, he is in his element, you can feel that this is all he’s ever wanted. And after 15 years since we last heard from him, it is one hell of a story.

Stuck in their old ways.

Spencer Bledsoe. Faith is a strange thing sometimes. You think you can pull yourself out of your old habits, and yet like the Godfather once said: “Every time i try to get out, they pull me back in”. This is a young, fit, smart player that got dealt pretty bad cards on his first chapter, and yet miraculously made it through to almost win the game. Mostly, he saved himself on day 9, while he was on the bottom of his tribe, by giving a heartfelt speech at tribal, proving he was more useful than a woman that threw all the tribe’s rice in the fire. Which in itself is pretty ironic. But this time it’s different, this time he will get a solid alliance, lock it down, and sail through to the merge. This time all the pieces are in place. This time the numbers are on his side. Until, and for no fault of his own once again, everyone turns on his main ally and therefore him. From top to bottom in three days. And here is Spencer, in the exact same position he was in the previous chapter. Only a slight difference: the first time he had to prove he was worthy to stay and would stay loyal to the brains tribe. This time he has to promise he will make an effort to connect, and understand all of his tribes mates. It shouldn’t have worked then, it shouldn’t have worked now. But it did. Spencer never changes, Spencer will always be in trouble, on the wrong side of the numbers. But Spencer is the Master of the Hail Mary Speeches. When everything seems bleak, he pulls it off and touches the strategic/emotional chords of his tribes mates to let them send home the only other person they would target instead of him. This, along with Terry’s, was the most outstanding storyline this episode gave us. History repeating itself in the exact same way for the exact same player.

Shirin Oskooi. Sometimes history repeats itself in a stranger way, and the person who was once bit is now the biter, and viceversa. Another glorious chapter of this story is a short one: in chapter 30, a young successful businesswoman was treated poorly by most of her tribe, and eventually outcast and voted out because of it. In chapter 31, that same businesswoman outcasts one of her allies treating her poorly (though arguably not as poorly as she was treated the first time around), and yet still gets voted out because of it. It seems that no matter where Shirin stands in this story, downfall is her destiny. Compelling.

Joe Anglim. The golden boy wants to shine, be nice, be cool. Sometimes a character that is just positive in everything he does is very much needed, and we need it to be a stable character that never changes. The golden boy is just that. He will never change. And he will be voted out the exact same way, for the exact same reason.

Jeremy Collins. In the struggle for change, some people are better at stating their intentions than acting on them. Jeremy promised us more stability, less erratic behavior in trying to control his tribe, not letting his relationship with his wife affect his game. He then proceeded to build an alliance on day one the exact same way he did the first time, choosing to include the exact same liability he chose to include the first time (Keith), then called his tribes mates dumb in a confessional, and he already seems to worry more about what is happening to his wife than to his game (although this time it is more understandable). A natural leader will always try to lead. Whether he does it effectively, well only the Survivor story will tell.

Stephen Fischbach. There once was a young intellectual New Yorker who felt he didn’t belong in this story. So much so that he thought he had to prove to everyone in the game how deserving he was of success by not taking too much credit for the moves that caused everyone’s downfall, and made most people mad at him, thinking it would be enough to earn their vote. He met and oddly aligned with a smart, more relatable young farmer who threw him under the bus right at the end and caused his downfall. Stephen’s overthinking and over-strategizing nature, his tendency to want to control every aspect of his game and be logical shows in everything he does and says. So much so that sometimes he’s not aware of the personalities and emotions that surround him, and not taking those into account can be the end of you in this Story. If he’s not careful, he might, just like the first time, be betrayed by his closest ally right at the end or sooner. If he’s not too careful his gamebot attitude might make him fall at the hands of emotionally aware oldschool players. Talking about Survivor every week for the last 5 years certainly hasn’t helped with the overthinking and the over-strategizing, and i think Fischbach has slightly forgotten about the social, human part of this game. The problem with the Fish is that he spent too much time in the pond wondering and analyzing how the others were doing in the ocean, and when he got released into the ocean it overwhelmed him. What a story.

Abi Maria Gomes. Oh how glorious this story is. Some characters have a problem controlling the beast in them. These characters are in constant conflict against themselves. They try so hard to hold their tongues, they make a conscious effort to relate in a different way with other characters, and yet their true nature will eventually push them to blurt out what they really think about what’s being said and done, inexorably messing up their game. Abi made no effort in her first chapter. She was aggressive, abrasive, unmanageable. This time she came back and tried to control herself. But her true self is too strong. She needs to speak her mind, she needs conflict to express herself, she can’t walk away. And so just like the first time around Abi built herself up to be a player you don’t want to have around, but a player you need to manage and understand if you truly want to win this game, possibly by taking her with you to the end. By not changing, oddly enough, Abi put herself in the same almost powerful situation she was in last time. And so, to make it further this time, she will have to be less abrasive to people close to her when fewer people will be left. She will have to find a perfect balance between day one Abi and day 4 Abi. Control the beast, and let it out at more strategic moments. Will she succeed ? Probably not.

Edit: formatting and mistakes.

Posted Oct 2, 2015, 12:25 PM UTC · edited

13036
EvenSt3vensGarrett•

This has to be the best post - all-time on r/survivor... Sensational job! Thank you. I agree this was the most emotional survivor episode I've seen in years. Think it means more because we all "know" who these players are... But yeah. Superb descriptions. Loved reading this and agreed with most of it. Thanks!

27
AlojOP•

Thank you ! This episode had me thinking a lot more about how Survivor is just a metaphore for every day life. Other episodes/seasons were good examples of this in the past, but this one was so good i just had to write it down even just for myself.

7
urbanpixie2•

I loved this post too- this season of Survivor is amazing and what you wrote highlights why.

The premise of the season also makes you think: If I had a chance to re-try something where the original outcome didn't go my way, what would that be and what would I do differently? It's part of the reason why the cast is so relatable, even the ones who I didn't 'connect' with in their original season.

19
At_the_RoundhouseWentworth•

I agree with all of that... except that Shirin "outcasts one of her allies treating her poorly (though arguably not as poorly as she was treated the first time around)." There's a parallel of someone being upset and someone else not reaching out, but that's as far as the comparisons go, as far as I'm concerned. Totally different situations, and it's unfair to paint Shirin in the same light as Will. She made a mistake, but she certainly did not yell at Abi that she had no soul and that no one loved her.

14
otherestScottWoo•

It's less a comparison to Will, and more to someone like Sierra or Tyler who stood around and let it happen.

Obviously Abi brought everything on herself in a way Shirin probably did not, but if someone is that upset and in your alliance, you have to see opportunity to be the better person. And in this case, unlike with Sierra or Tyler, interfering would have actually helped her game.

21
At_the_RoundhouseWentworth•

From a game and alliance perspective, absolutely. Shirin messed up and it cost her.

From a humanity perspective... eh. I get it. I wouldn't go near an upset Abi either. Human patience can only go so far, and she is unbearably passive aggressive and exhausting to deal with. And frankly, the more she's coddled, the less chance of her actually self-reflecting and changing her behavior. I'm sure Shirin had had it at that point. But in the previous season, I like to think I would've reached out to Shirin after Will attacked her like that, because she did nothing to bring that on. (Assuming accounts that Jenn and Mike bringing up the food thing to him are accurate.) Totally different situations.

9
DamnThoseChickensVarner•

This so much. Shirin vilified the people who didn't come to her rescue. They all got grouped together as the Axis of Evil. They all became the antagonists of the previous story, whike Mike immediately became the hero for helping her.

Shirin just walked away from Abi, then joyfully talked about the ordeal in the shelter while Abi sat alone. She justified it because it became awkward. She later said in her interview that she was emotionally exhausted and couldn't be bothered to comfort Abi when she was emotionally drained herself. She never extended this level of empathy to the people who stood around, petrified, as Will raged on her. She immediately labelled them as awful human beings, or so did the story-telling, just because these people didn't know how to react or it simply didn't click to them that they should intervene. People who were otherwise decent like Carolyn, Sierra and Tyler suddenly were awful too.

The parallels are there for sure, and it is in how Shirin has a hard time putting herself in others' shoes. It all comes with her being much more logical than emotional. She understands her emotions but has trouble extending this to other people. This was her undoing this time around, and it's sad that in her interviews it seems she learned nothing about this and a lot about gameplay mistakes and keeps making excuses as to why she was justified in not doing anything about the Abi situation. She even said she wanted to chat up Peih-Gee because she was having a rough time herself after jumping straight from her season finale to the game and Peih-Gee just started gossiping about Abi instead. It's always somebody else's fault in Shirin's eyes. Whatever.

2†
JCivXVarner•

I think you're exactly right. Shirin always gives the benefit of the doubt to herself but never to others. And she doesn't undertand if someone else doesn't think or feel the exact same way she would in the same situation. I think she is still very much trying to figure herself out, sorting out some issues that she has emotionally, and this results in a lot of navel-gazing and not understanding the motivations and feelings of others.

And unfortunately it looks like she hasn't learned much at all. Maybe time will give her perspective. But it sure as hell doesn't look like she has learned what Survivor is really about. The numbers game is the shining object in Shirin's eyes and she is blinded by her need to view everything though the hyper-logical macro strategy point of view - she is competely missing the micro strategy, the social game, people skills, whatever you want to call it.

3†
Side_showSpencer•

"We judge ourselves by our intentions and others by their actions."

5
mandrilltigerSpencer•

Watching that scene with Peih-Gee and Abi it seemed to me that if anything Abi was the Will and Peih-Gee was the Shirin. But Peih-Gee defended herself really really well. So Abi got upset and wasn't there to comfort her.

IMO If Peih-Gee started yelling "Abi you have no soul!" or if Abi cried when Peih-Gee was yelling at her Shirin would have came to her defense.

The scale of the argument was no big enough that I think it warranted a step in between. Where at least Mike thought the Will thing did warrant a step in between.

Also Varner could have directed Abi on anyone after the fight so it was mostly a unmarked missile that could hit anyone Varner wanted.

2†
AlojOP•

Yes i agree with you, the two things have very little in common when it comes to the seriousness of the situation. I think Shirin was more of a bystander in this case than an actual "biter". But i think it hurt Abi Maria just the same (and one can argue if that is justified or not) and thus created this strange paradox where Shirin basically became, maybe not Will or Dan, but (in Abi's mind) more like a friend that betrayed a main ally.

3
TheNobullmanShirin•

Your love for this show in all the ways I love it makes me happy and reinforces why I love it. I wish I hadn't used up my "one gold a term" policy I set up for myself.

13
AlojOP•

Thank you very much !

3
sabatoaSpencer•

Beautiful post, this should be required reading for the season so that people can understand and appreciate what's happening.

13
alexlopez49411•

I kinda feel that with that explanation that Kelley Wentworth is the Neville Longbottom of the season, he too was in the background in the first few books, but slowly but surely, he became a real big part in the fight against Voldermort

9
TylerPerryComoMonica•

Abi's bracelet was one of her horcruxes.

8
spilltojillSavage•

LOL - hilarious!

4
ELlminatorSpy Shack•

Totally agree with your assessment. It's so much fun see if the castaways are able to change the way they play or if they fall in the same traps as there last season.

8
theabdiPeih-Gee•

Wow. What an amazing post, this is why Survivor remains my favourite show on television. This has been such a good season so far, already exceeding my expectations which were already damn high.

6
Slicer37Kimmi•

i think savage should go into the can't change section

5
ughalreadydoesn't like flair•

I have only one issue with this, besides it only being 6 days into the game and way too early to give concrete analysis on any player but Vytas and Shirin.

Breaking the curse of the follower

Woo said no to flipping on his alliance, he didn't say no to being a follower. He's still following Terry and Varner blindly, just like he did when he latched onto Tony.

3
PsyduckisnotaduckWiglesworth•

I don't know if he's following them blindly, we don't have evidence of that one way or the other. It's clear they've had meaningful conversations with him, while Shirin and Spencer just flat out didn't. That decides a lot on Survivor. In absence of other metrics, "Who's talking to me?" seems like a really good one for determining who to trust.

3
Pikamilk•

I don't know how you can say he's "following Terry and Varner blindly", it's obvious Shirin and Spencer only came to him because they're desperate, so should he just suddenly go along with the minority and team up with someone who hasn't talked to him for 6 days?

1
[deleted]•

I don't necessarily agree with your read on Spencer's speech here:

But Spencer is the Master of the Hail Mary Speeches. When everything seems bleak, he pulls it off and touches the strategic/emotional chords of his tribes mates to let them send home the only other person they would target instead of him.

First off, I didn't think it was a terribly compelling speech that he made at tribal.

Secondly, voting Shirin off would have been decided in advance, not as a spur of the moment reaction to Spencer's speech. My thinking was Shirin was annexed to further forge the relationship with Abi-Marie.

Of course, this is just my opinion! Thanks for your well thought out post.

3
Pikamilk•

Agreed. I really don't think that speech helped change anyone's vote. The votes were clearly decided and I don't think any amount of persuading could change that, it's 5-4 and it's only 5-4 because 1) Spencer is stronger in challenge, 2) Shirin targeted Jeff and Jeff knew it, so she had to go, 3) Jeff even complimented Shirin more than he did Spencer, 4) they just didn't want one of them to pull of an idol and idol out someone. They always wanted Shirin gone first, but if she had an idol, they would be equally happy with Spencer leaving.

2
ClinnyBabySavage•

An excellent read, and I do truly understand by what you mean with the comparisons to ASOIAF. 2 episodes in, the editors are already showing us a compelling story, and that's why, personally, why hopes are already so high for this season.

2
kyzedJeremy•

Great writing skills! kudos!

2
Turtle_and_ZoneStephen•

You just perfectly summed up exactly how I have felt about this season so far. Really an amazing write up. Walls of text usually don't interest me, but I read every last bit. Great stuff.

2
la_latinaFishbach•

This is an awesome read, thanks you. Totally agree with everything you wrote. After 30 seasons we still get moved by different aspects of the game, this is incredible! I hope we get to see everyone's chances to change and adapt, if they failed we know the consequences. Shirin failed and there are the consequences. I was a big fan of her but the way she is handling her exit is terrible.

2
PadishahEmperor•

I don't really think Woo is being that different at all. He was loyal in Cagayan and he's doing the exact same thing. Just this past episode he told the other side he was staying loyal. He's doing the exact same thing, just they showed if from a different perspective but that's not the same thing as changing.

2
LadyTemerity•

Bravo EXCELLENT post! You have captured what is so rewarding about this show. The situation is extreme, yet the same issues that we ourselves are plagued with throughout our lives play out before us. If only we were lucky enough to see ourselves in this way. To have someone observe habits and behaviors that we are blind to see but shape the direction of our lives.

This episode also clearly backs up the statement in the [New York Times] (http://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/01/business/media/survivor-defies-gravity-to-hang-on-as-cbs-ratings-stalwart.html?_r=0) about the show focuses on the loyal fans and not doing more than that. If they were worried that new viewers would not get or care about the arc, this show would be only familiar faces, doing familiar things and miss out on the best part of the story. We love good stories because we see someone learning, or in some cases, not learning and paying the price. I don't think there is a single reality television show that could tell a this story better than Survivor.

2
spilltojillSavage•

Love the post! Curious about your analysis on the other players (pee-gee, savage, etc). Perhaps we haven't seen enough of them! I wish we had feeds to see them 24/7 like Big Brother (even if they are not live)!

1
PsyduckisnotaduckWiglesworth•

Arguably we haven't seen enough of most of the others, but Savage not being there is an oversight given how much content we've got from him. I would say Wiglesworth needs one, but she had a quiet episode 2, after her opening confessional. We'll see if her story picks up in 3, but it makes sense she was in the background given she was about the least important player in the story of Shirin's boot.

it's kinda frustrating to me that all of the most underdeveloped characters of the season aside from maybe PG and Keith are Bayon women. Tasha has some, Ciera and Kimmi have random bits, and there's apparently someone on the cast named "Monica".

3
AlojOP•

I don't have enough to add another chapter to their stories yet, if i get inspired again i might do a weekly update of this !

2
NirvashWpg•

excellent post

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1