r/dndnext•
Skybrush

Does Draconic majesty and Draconic resilience stack?

So, our party is playing through HotDQ and managed to kill Rezmir last session, which was pretty awesome.

We managed to retrieve the Black Dragon Mask from her which our Draconic sorcerer eagerly grabbed for himself.

After the session a discussion arose about the Draconic Majesty in combination with the Draconic resilience and if they stack.

Draconic resilience sets your AC to 13+ your Dex modifier while unarmored (which gives our sorcerer a solid 16) and Draconic resilience allows you to add your charisma modifier to your AC while unarmored.

This leaves our sorcerer at a stunning 20 AC and both me and the DM felt this was extremely strong as he now has more AC than our fighter.

We do realize it might be needed as the next part of the adventure may very well be much more difficult. It just feels quite ridiculous to have that item turn our already quite tanky sorcerer (shield reactions all over the place) into something even tankier.

We don't see anything wrong with it in the rules but it just feels extremely strong. Are we wrong?

Posted Oct 2, 2015, 1:05 PM UTC

313
IronforgedAnti-Paladin•

It does work.

Draconic Majesty. While you are wearing no armor, you can add your Charisma bonus to your Armor Class.

It is a legendary item and is very powerful.

9
SkybrushOPNyx Nightshade•

That's what we got from reading the definitions as well, but something in me just screams "broken", but that just might be the bard in me not wanting to be left alone down at 14 AC.

But yeah, unless there's anything specific to indicate that it doesn't work, I guess we have no choice ^^

3
jmartkdrWarlock•

If it's a legendary item, it's sort of supposed to be broken.

If you want to (and the player sees the problem the same way you do), you could possibly have the benefit "phase in" as you gain levels. So it might have a maximum bonus from charisma equal to 1/4 your level, or something.

4
FGJustice•

First off, Draconic Resilience isn't functionally armor. If it was, it would shut itself off. It's just your AC, in the same way monks, barbarians, and people walking around in nice clothes set their AC.

Now, by the rules as they stand they would stack. Resilience sets the formula for your AC, and Majesty adds to AC. These are different effects, and since Resilience doesn't include your Charisma already I see no problem.

How is this any different than what would happen if a Monk or Barbarian wore the mask? It's not unreasonable that either class could have a 17 or 18 AC from their unarmored features - a barbarian with a shield might even have a 20. A 14 Charisma for either class also gets them above non-shield plate wearers.

The thing to keep in mind is that a high AC is not the end-all of being a tank. Sure the sorcerer is harder to hit with weapon attacks, but his Dex save is still weaker and he doesn't have the HP to keep standing when the enemy caster is hitting him back.

7
SkybrushOPNyx Nightshade•

I agree with that. I think of draconic resilience as more of a scaly type of skin or something, just makes you a bit tougher naturally essentially.

Agree on the second paragraph as well. As I've said, unless there's something or someone stating that it doesn't work, then I see no problem with it from a rule standpoint.

It isn't. Title and post might've been a bit unclear since I focused on my party, but the question went for unarmored defenses as well, not only sorcs!

Oh definitely, sorcs don't at all have the utility that our fighter does, it just seems a bit crazy that more of a striker type character becomes so resilient. Then again, this is the first time we've encountered a legendary item, which does change things up quite a bit!

2
IntuentisDungeon Master•

Did you grab Hazirawn from Rezmir too? If so, hand that to your fighter and any concerns about the fighter's inferior AC become irrelevant thanks to the terrifying damage your fighter will be able to dish out.

2
SkybrushOPNyx Nightshade•

Can confirm, Hazirawn went ham all over the place, it was indeed quite terrifying when our fighter pushed out something like 60+ dmg in one go!

1
leglesslegolegolasWizard (mostly)•

Yep. Even better, if your sorcerer has Shield as a 1st level spell, he can bump his AC up to 25.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3†
SkybrushOPNyx Nightshade•

Is there any source to this or is it in the whole "Sets your AC to" bit? Essentially making your armor unchangeable?

2
The_WinglessGM•

Edit: Moonshadowkati is correct. I retract my statement!

1
SkybrushOPNyx Nightshade•

I know that Mike Mearls tweeted that you have to pick one way to calculate your armor. However, it was argued that BDH doesn't change that but simply adds to your current armor.

I thought the "set" might have significance but haven't seen anything to add credibility to that in this case..

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
LKDlk•

It works just fine. It's not terribly difficult to be "unhittable" in 5E. LMAO bounded accuracy, got a bridge to sell you if you were dumb enough to believe WotC on that one. Just be glad he isn't a warforged with a protection item and a mariner or using a shield.

-4
Level9ZubatMagical Goat Man•

Warforged and Mariner's are homebrews (unearched arcana isn't official, just playtest/alpha material) and thus many DM's don't allow it.

Not to mention, even with 20+ AC it's still easy to hit you when creatures start to get into the +10 or more hit bonus.

1