r/shield•
Maping

How would you implement the Index/Superhuman Registration Act?

Let's ignore the morality of the issue. For whatever reason, you need to implement a listing/registration of every superhuman known to your organization.

How would you do it? How would you insure that it is fair, restricts the rights of the indexed as little as possible, while still protecting those without powers?

Posted Oct 11, 2015, 8:58 PM UTC

28
feor1300SHIELD•

Name, fingerprints, simple biography and list of powers, maybe a DNA swab. Then ask them politely to update you if they decide to relocate in the future, let some of the more unstable ones know you might check in on them from time to time, and cut them loose.

SHIELD is a mother-loving spy organization. If they can't covertly track the activities of a few hundred super-powered individuals, then they're doing their jobs wrong.

8
UmbrusNightshadeLanyard•

If they are "mother-loving" does that mean that SHIELD reveres Peggy Carter like the Catholic Church does the Virgin Mary?

2
feor1300SHIELD•

Fury's not in charge any more, Coulson toned things down a tad for prime time. ;)

1
UmbrusNightshadeLanyard•

Yeah I know. It was just a joke because technically speaking Peggy was the founding woman of SHIELD so she would be the "mother" of the group (with Howard Stark being the father).

1
Conspicor•

The enhanced/powered/Inhuman individuals answer to the government and they are not allowed to act on their own without obtaining permission beforehand (by this I mean taking on other super-powered threats or taking risky action). They keep their basic human rights, free to do anything else they want, but they are obligated to do 'check-ups' so it is ensured that their abilities are still under control or that their mental health hasn't declined.

They are indexed, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. Not all powered individuals are good people so it helps to have crucial information on them. It's basically like a private, undisclosed record on them. It also makes everything more organized.

3
Duamerthrax•

Only for convicted felons, clinically insane or those that volunteer themselves for protection. And they can't be declared insane when it's convenient for the authorities, it has to be related to an incident.

3
Elcactus•

Just treat it like gun registration; name, power, and location. That is the whole point of it after all, to keep tabs on people who ARE weapons. Do not release the information to the public at large, do not require them to come into some government building and poke and prod at them. Anyone with a 3rd of a brain could tell you that Joe on the street is going to react to discovering that his neighbor has powers the same way he would if he was a pedophile. Ostracism. Threats. The pitchfork emporium guy making bank. Treating them like felons (required DNA/fingerprint test and constant overt monitoring) is going to do what exactly? Help ID them when they commit a crime? The fact that there's 2 guys on the index with a given power and one of them is in Beirut isn't enough of a giveaway?

All these more stringent measures do is create paranoia. You wanna convince people they aren't going to be rounded up and shipped to camps? Don't act like you're preparing a criminal investigtion on them.

Noncompliance could likewise be taken in a "soft" manner. Throw fines at them. Give them tickets. Dont allow them to renew licenses, etc. Dragging the noncompliants out of their houses into black vans will just make martyrs for the rabble rousers (and as we saw with Jiyang, they exist, and are the biggest threat to a smooth transition). These kinds of punishments are coercive, but indirect, and its hard to take a moving photograph of someone paying a fine.

Ultimately the end goal is not only to get everyone on a list. It is to maintain an orderly society where people feel and are safe. If you go too hard on this, you will end up creating a situation where you sacrifice your goal to expedite your means by driving the very people to extremism you were hoping to keep contained.

2
nullkazeSHIELD•

If the Inhumans have some kind of ruling government, then they have to enforce the Index, punishment of Inhumans and take responsibility for all Inhumans.

Otherwise, that government can't be truly recognised by the world, and Inhumans everywhere will need to be self-registered with their own governments and potentially face harsher/crueller and more stringent rules. Any Inhuman who tried to escape Indexing would be punished like any other person who tried to avoid paying taxes.

Any Inhuman government must recognise sanctions by the rest of the world (established diplomatically, of course) and the rest of the world must accept Inhumans and enforce laws to discourage (and outlaw) speciesism.

Of course, this is all assuming any superior race would ever seek peace with a relatively inferior race.

1