Need advice about my 2000 Tacoma
I have a 2000 Toyota Tacoma with 198k miles that runs great, but is starting to require some costly repairs. I just paid $300 for a new starter two weeks ago, and now it is leaking coolant. I got quotes from two shops for replacing the water pump and the timing belt. Both quoted between $700 and $1000 depending on what they find when they open it up. One of the shops told me that I'd also need to get the head gaskets changed soon because oil is leaking out (not a lot, but I can definitely see the oil on the engine. The air conditioner also needs work, it runs cold for about 30 minutes and then just blows warm air. I can wait a while to fix that, but I live in the south and don't think I can bare another summer of that. I also need two front tires that will cost @ $250.
I am debating weather it is worth it to sink all that money into a 15 year old truck and then something else go out on it and then I'd really be screwed.
Another option is a 2003 Tacoma with 200k miles I saw for sale for $6000. The guy selling it is a mechanic and I asked him if he would be interested in letting me trade my truck in and paying the difference. The one he is selling has no leaks of any kind and is a four door model which I'd prefer since we just had a baby and it would be safer to put the car seat in the back instead of the front (which I do rarely, but sometimes its necessary).
Basically, should I bite the bullet and put $2-$3000 into it or trade the guy with the newer one or find something else all together. If I trade it to the guy, what would be a reasonable amount should I ask for in the trade?
Thanks in advance for your input.
Posted Oct 12, 2015, 9:15 PM UTC
Your personal choice here but here's some things to think about.
They both have around the same mileage.
I don't know how long you've owned your truck but are you willing to trade it in for a truck of which you have no history about?
If you need the room for the baby and your current truck isn't cutting it then a bigger vehicle is your only option.
Look at the value of your truck on kbb and nada. Ask for that price as trade in. See what the difference is between your trucks value and the newer truck.
Consider wether that price is worth the upgrade and compare it to the cost of repairing your vehicle.
Some other advice.. There are people who flip cars. All they care about is making money and selling you a running vehicle at the time of sale.
I would go under the assumption (based on mileage) that both trucks are equally worn out. Don't go hoping that the newer truck might not need the same repairs shortly.
Thanks for the reply. I agree with your thoughts on the unknown about the newer truck. It is probably my biggest concern.
Although the bigger truck would be more convenient, it isn't a necessity. This is my work truck which I am usually riding in alone. We use the wife's when we do things together. It would be nice though to be able to fit all three of us in case something happens to her car.
I guess I'll just see what the guy is offering to give me on the trade and go from there.