Discussion: Regarding EA's recent moves, and pre-ordering in general
Sorry for the wall of text. To those who take the time to read: I appreciate it as I need to get this off my chest.
I was reading through an gaming thread about EA's recent dickwad move. I can't help but be surprised by how many apologies there are for Battlefront Premium, and season passes/preorders in general. The most common argument is that EA are budgeting for the creation of DLC. Now in some situations, in some industries that might be acceptable.
Except this is the entertainment industry.
It's significantly more often the case that whatever the content producers (who already have your money) finally shit out is an unusable heap of horse manure (e.g. a lot of Ubisoft's releases over recent years), or enjoyable, but not worth the money (e.g. GTA V, DLCs of Batman/Evolve/etc). This is as opposed to something like construction- where certain standards are expected to be adhered to before the plans are even drafted- where if those standards aren't met, the parties that took money are likely to get sued for misrepresentation. The best that happens for people upset about a game they pre-paid for is that Valve might refund them, and/or the publisher makes a hand-washing apology of it.
This why people reject pre-paid game development. Games are making huge money, yet big developers are ever trying to shed more and more of their financial burdens onto their customers. I don't want to take the easy route and think "Well, you brought it upon yourself." I don't want to feel that kind of animosity for my fellow gamers.
But even if you get exactly what you expected, or more, you're still getting fucked. Gamers have less influence than ever over the quality of AAA games because publishers are constantly trying to tempt them into trading their buying power for exclusive content (in ever and ever more dastardly ways). People vastly underestimate what a tremendous loss it is to the consumers when they lose that power. Without it we're not buying, but being told what to buy. I understand some smaller developers need help getting off the ground, and I'm okay with that, but big-money game developers have no excuse to ask for pre-orders. They're making themselves into a caricature; Is EA run by Mr Charles Montgomery Burns? I'm glad Steam revised their refunds policy earlier this year. It's not enough to stop the tide though.
And this is not just a 'gaming' problem. It's a digital market problem: I'm calling it now - this 'exclusive content' and 'paying for shit that hasn't been made' trend will thoroughly infect the movie industry once the internet beats old-media's death-grip loose (or before that if they wake up to how much more money they could be making). Now that we have Amazon and Netflix originals it'll well work its way into series as well. How about that? How about movies and series where relevant plot developments are withheld from the viewer if he doesn't have a 'Premium Pass'?
We've already got a form of it in BD/DVD extras, but producing extra content to reward collectors isn't a pernicious example the way producing content with the sole intention of ransoming it to squeeze money out of your regular consumers. Big devs are trying to fuck their paying customers as hard as they can, whilst indirectly incentivising pirates to pirate rather than pay. Then they turn around and wail about piracy cutting into their already-inflated profits. Hypocrisy.
So to those of you who pre-order games, I implore you: exercise the most delicate discrimination in considering who needs your money before they should be fairly expected to show something for it.
Thank you for reading.
tl;dr: EA and other big companies have no right to ask for preorder payment, and pre-payment schemes will get keep worse. Guess we already knew that, huh?
Posted Oct 13, 2015, 1:42 PM UTC
As far as I see it there's NEVER any reason to pre-order a digital item. Even for small developers. Imagine if you start a small business, would you ask random people to give you money cos you need it? No, you'd invest your money or loan from a bank. Why would the gaming industry be different? The developer should takes the risk of failure when they start, just like in every other business.
As far as asking for more money after release for content is also insane. Did you make enough money from the game launch? Yes? Wanna make your customers happy and get them to come back? Make more content free. Did you not make enough money for that? Go make a new game.
In any business the people providing the service always try to go out of their way to make you happy so you come back to them. Even if it costs them a little. Amazon gives refunds sometimes with no proof or legal reason to keep you happy and come back. This seems to be lost in the gaming industry where it's perfectly fine to ask for more and more after the game's out.
What it will always come back to, for me, is Minecraft. I paid 10$ for it in Alpha and never another cent and it's still being updated and makes more than enough money. With 1 game. Now imagine just how much bloody money EA is sitting on.
I get where you coming from, where reasonable demands and expectations are concerned, but I wouldn't completely disregard the (flawed, I'll admit) crowdsourcing model, where instead of trying to find otherwise impartial and uninvolved investors, you appeal for start-up capital directly to the potential end users of your product, who want the project to succeed more than anyone but you.
A kickstarter campaign or similar? I'd only ever consider those to be good when someone has a great idea, makes all the plans for it, but lacks the means to produce it. Like the beach cooler box thing someone did with a battery bank, lights, USB hubs and speakers in it. You're not gonna make a bank loan to start a business on that, so you crowdfund it. If you're a single indie developer working on a game in spare time, ask for straight up donations, not a kickstarter. And no way in hell anyone with more then 5 people should ever ask for one. Ask for a bank loan and start a business like everyone else has to. At most, ask for donations.
It's very much in the eye of the beholder. I don't see a problem with it in so much as it's a venue for people to put forward money at their own risk and expense. Too often that money is given with poor consideration though.
Yea I suppose it is, but how does that change anything. If you think you did something people would be willing to buy, but can't mass produce it, and you won't start a business around a silly 1 time thing, go on kickstarter, see what happens.
Asking for full on funding for a team of developers is insane.
Should I go make a kickstarter to start my own Crane manufacturing plant? No, I'd go to a bank for a loan.
That's what donations are for. The problem is with kickstarter people see something neat, and if they fund it they get some small thing or promise and impulse-buy/fund it.
If star citizen was asking for 3000$ donations with no benefit to it, instead of offering cool ship designs you get to test in your hanger, would people still do it? I doubt it.