r/history•
CER7

Did we always fear to become obsolete or did we start recently ?

Discussion/Question

With the advance of AI and robotics an increasing number of people voice their fear that humans may become obsolete. Artificial systems can do everything we do just better and faster.

Was this kind of existential fear always present or is it a genuinely new phenomenon ?

Posted Oct 19, 2015, 3:21 PM UTC

110
tanstaafl90•

Our impending doom has been an ongoing theme among the religious and weak for centuries. The nature of that doom doesn't change that much, really. It's usually some variation of people's misbehavior.

3
CER7OP•

Correct me if I´m wrong but usually those kinds of people see our annihillation or something equally dramatic. It isnt something mundane as being useless.

1
tanstaafl90•

Fear of the unknown and fear of the future? It still just seems like a variation on a basic theme.

2
f1junkie•

I'm not sure that many people fear that now.

1
CER7OP•

Certainly other things are more feared. Even in terms of AI it isnt the biggest fear. But I wonder if we accept the premise are we confronted with sth. new or just a variation of sth. old ?

1
RLS0812•

The same arguments were made about factorization during the industrial revolution. In the 'old days' machinery created more jobs than it replaced. Modern technology, unfortunately, replaces more jobs than it creates.

The Lego factory in Denmark is a good example. It's the most automated factory in the world, only employing a hand full of people, were in the past it required hundreds of workers.

1
CER7OP•

But at the time you at least could say humans are better in solving complex problems or doing creative work. If the dawn of AI we seem to lose that edge. We that and fear that one day there is nothing valuable only we can do. In a way this argument is the adult form of the one from the industrial revolution

1
RLS0812•

Please answer this question realistically: How are you going to employ 7,000,000,000+ people as 'artists and engineers' ? Scratch that. Just 'artists' - since AI exists now that designs new machines & software without human intervention.

1
CER7OP•

Why cant we all be artists ? If other things like food production and so on are taken care by artificial systems it would be possible.

But my point is if we have to scratch 'artists' what are we doing next ?

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1