r/canada•
Strayarc

Somebody asked for an ELI5 about the election. Before I was done replying he deleted the post. I didn't type 3600 characters for nothing so here's my reply.

We have a Westminsterial system (same as England who whelped us). In the States, your President is both head of government and head of state. Our Prime Minister (PM)is head of government but our head of state is Queen Elizabeth II. Since she lives in Britain, she is represented by a Governor General (GG). His role is mostly ceremonial except when things like elections happen. Back in August, the PM asked the GG to dissolve parliament (which has to happen every 5 years max according to our Constitution). This triggers an election a minimum of 37 days later. This time it is 78 days which is very rare and benefits the Conservative Party of Canada (which the PM is the head of currently) because they have a bigger war chest than the other parties (kinda skeevy but legal). After this campaign period we have an election (today). We don't directly elect our PM, but only our local Member of Parliament (MP). The next PM will be the head of the party who controls the most seats in the next parliament (sort of, I'll explain below.)

We have three main parties in this country, with two more minor parties and some fringe parties:

Conservative Party of Canada. (CPC, currently in power, right wing ideology)

New Democratic Party (NDP, currently Her Majesty's Loyal Opposition, left wing ideology)

Liberal Party of Canada (LPC, currently holding the third most seats, but expected to win tonite, centrist agenda but are running to the left of the NDP this election)

Bloc Quebecois (BQ, 4 seats, they only run candidates in Quebec and exist primarily to have Quebec separate from Canada)

Green Party of Canada (Currently have one MP and have an environmentalist agenda)

Here's where it gets fun:

If a party wins a majority of seats (the present situation when the election was called), they rule as if they have all the seats. Basically a five year elected dictatorship (unless the judiciary rules the laws they enact are in violation of the constitution)

If no party wins a majority a bunch of things can happen.

The current PM remains PM, until such time as he loses a confidence vote in the House of Commons. The throne speech which opens the next parliament and all budget bills are automatically confidence votes. As well as any vote the PM declares a confidence vote. The constitution says that Parliament has to be called yearly, so he doesn't have to open Parliament until next August. This would be extraordinary and legal experts say the GG would likely force the situation sooner.

If the current PM loses significantly, he will almost certainly ask the GG to ask the winner of the most seats to form the next government. Both the LPC and NDP have stated that neither will work with the CPC to help them stay in power. If it is close, the NDP and LPC will likely agree to work with each other, or formally form a coalition to oust the CPC because the current PM is a polarizing figure.

The Green Party may win a few more seats tonight and be in a position of kingmaker to push either the LPC or the NDP over the top to majority status in exchange for getting some of their agenda enacted. The BQ is not likely to work with a non separatist party because it would be hypocritical to their position but politics makes for strange bedfellows.

The GG becomes signifcant in a minority position to facilitate these things. He is supposed to pick the most stable option, but he was appointed by the current PM. (Technically by Her Majesty on the advice of the PM). We would like to believe he will discharge his duties impartially but you never know until he does.

Thanks for taking an interest.

Edit: Thanks for the gold kind internet stranger.

Edit2: Spelling mistake. I feel shame.

Edit 3: Final edit: So this is what RIP Inbox feels like. Thanks so much all of you who participated in this incredibly fun discussion. I will continue to answer any questions that come in. My cat is pissed off that this is my new top voted post displacing her unbelieveably sweet kitten pic. In hindsight I wish I titled this, "I am a welder and governance nerd AMA"

Final Final Edit: First off the community on this sub is amazing. Comments that came in after Oct 20 in the morning I won't be replying to. I'm a little burned out, on two hours sleep after the election, and have a day job. A number of you have requested I do an elaboration on certain points. That sounds fun. I will, unless the mods object, type up a discussion series focused on some of what I find the most interesting or unusual aspects of Canadian governance, law and subjects constitutional. I AM NOT A LAWYER, POLITICAL SCIENTIST OR SCHOLAR. It will be a non scholarly, hopefully unbiased, civics lesson about the mechanics our our system and comparison to others that I know about. I will try to keep it non-dry. How we got to here is a very cool multifaceted story that I know a little about and I love to talk about it. I love to be questioned, challenged and exposed to points of view I haven't previously considered. I can't believe I hadn't visited r/Canada until yesterday. Again, thanks to all of you for keeping me from enjoying election night in peace. Your desire to be engaged in the process leaves me optimistic and inspired. Look for installment one this Saturday. I don't know the title yet but I think we should start with an overview and what I hope to achieve.

Posted Oct 19, 2015, 10:25 PM UTC · edited

2.6K350
Loading comments…