r/htgawm•
Colbert54

Bonnie Theory (spoiler)

Discussion

iv'e always wondered how Bonnie and Analise met. I think that Annalise was Bonnie's fathers defense attorney when he was caught for molesting Bonnie as a small child. I believe that Analise purposely lost the case so her father would go to prison. Bonnie now feels like she has to re pay Analise by working for her.

Note: I believe this cause why else would Analise have the video tapes of Bonnie as a small child

Posted Oct 23, 2015, 9:00 AM UTC

4125
Fylax•

Or she defended Bonnie for killing her father..

109
dramione14•

I think you are on to something here and maybe the story that she told Asher about how she killed Sam was actually how she killed her father which is why it was so believable

104
Fylax•

Yeah, i think so too!

14
letsmakeart•

Ouuu excellent theory!

6
justchillmax•

And the reason Annalise had the tape was she used it in court against him.

5
cmc8290Annalise Keating•

ooooooooooooooooooo yes. i like this.

12
chucky523Connor Walsh•

I agree it's this. Annalise doesn't lose cases. No matter what.

11
Christoaster•

Besides that one time that teen threatened to kill again in court...

7
chucky523Connor Walsh•

Well yes.. That's true. But in her defense she probably could've won that won had the teen not had the outburst.

3
Christoaster•

True, it doesn't look so bad on Annalise because the loss was because of a unrecoverable threat made in court and not hers. But I did like how that loss shows the beginning of AK starting to lose confidence of everything being under control like we saw in the last episode.

4
bigfish1992Frank Delfino•

I really like this theory.

3
Jessxx22•

Omg! This is a great theory!

1
Zarathustran•

I wouldn't be surprised if that's not actually Bonnie in the video. Do we ever hear her name in the video? I wouldn't put it past Analise to steal evidence for her own gain.

33
nselma•

My first thought was that, while the actual story might ring true, the video footage is most probably NOT of Bonnie. It seems a lot like Annalise to pull on Asher's heartstrings in any way she possibly can to keep them all safe.

10
dillow•

I felt that way at first too, but we were told that this season would have more back story, especially Bonnie and Frank. So that leads me to believe that the video was real and was possibly used as evidence in a case that was a) against Bonnie's father or b) a defense case for Bonnie killing her father. There are some sick fucks that record themselves doing awful things on home videos and it wouldn't surprise me if that's what her father did, kept it at home and hidden away, and Bonnie brought it out as evidence to support her reasoning for finally killing him. Then the story she told about Sam is actually about how she killed her father, and that to me explains why her "performance" was so convincing, because she was actually distraught.

13
ezreads•

makes sense also it would explain what happened between Bonnie and that guy at the bar, they were hooking up then bonnie cut it off (maybe before she lost control of the situation) and then went to see Asher (were she had control of the situation.)

6
Kellivision•

Yeah what ever happened with that dude? She asked him about his profession (and for the life of me, I can't remember what it was) and then we never see how their date/hookup ends. She just goes running to Asher...

1
icatn•

This was my first thought. I don't believe there was any mention of Bonnie specifically.

2
bretoncat•

Wasn't Annaliese also abused? By her mother's boyfriend or uncle or something? (Am I making this up?) So that makes sense for why Annaliese may have felt a connection to Bonnie.

I do like the theory of Annaliese defending Bonnie for killing her father too, though! Because I can't really see Annaliese purposefully losing a case (if she was defending Bonnie's father), and I can see her being especially emotional/purposeful in defending an abuse victim if it was something she herself had experienced and probably considered.

23
Elvis_Presley42•

No you're not making it up, I believe they said that in the episode when Annalise's mother came to visit.

7
salt_and_burn•

Annalise and her mother had that huge fight about how her mother knew and never did anything about it.

13
Pokegirl0811•

Then the mom has that heart to heart with her and says that back then you handled your problems yourself. Even if the only way to do it leaves you with only the chance for a new start. Basically insinuating that yes, she knew the uncle was molesting Annalise and that instead of turning him into the law, she killed him by setting her own house on fire while he was asleep because he was known to fall asleep with a lit cigarette so it would not be suspected as murder.

10
Colbert54OP•

I honestly like this theory much better.

1
Zarathustran•

Bonnie couldn't possibly that much younger than Analise, right?

4
letsmakeart•

I assumed Analise is like late 40s and Bonnie is mid-thirties. If Annalise had been the lawyer for Bonnie, having this video of Bonnie at age whatever (10?) doesn't necessarily mean the abuse ended around that age, therefore Annalise wouldn't necessarily have to be of lawyer-y age at Bonnie's age 10. The video was clearly shot by Bonnie's dad, maybe he got caught years later but this tape was used as evidence that the abuse had been going on for awhile.

13
jetsayscentral•

I'm sure someone has already shared this theory, but I'm almost positive the video is fake. In the credits, there is no mention of "young Bonnie" or "Bonnie's dad." Add to this the fact that "dad" sounded exactly like Frank, and we have another juicy Annalise lie on our hands.

1
Kellivision•

Woah...

1