Am I Shield Pushing Too Much?

I'm still learning this game, and recently I've been playing as Empire Soldier a lot, using the mace and shield combo. I was under the impression that my job is basically just to disrupt the rats, and so I've been shield-pushing (block + click, not the charged attack) like a mofo.

Reading threads around here suggests this is actually detrimental, because it means the rest of the team has a harder time killing the skaven since they're getting knocked all over the place. If this is true, then what am I supposed to do? Just block and soak attacks or what?

Posted Oct 30, 2015, 11:59 PM UTC

410
ejmcelfresh•

If your team has a harder time killing them while you're making them stumble, they need to get gud. I run sword/board on the soldier for my team of friends and they love it because they can shoot ranged and swing 2 handers without worry about being pushed against.

9
Urban_Viking•

When you shield bash though you spread them out so they wrap around your crew and backstabs deal shitloads more damage on harder difficulties.

1
iBirdFIRE AND PAIN•

Shield bash them away so you don't lose too much stamina from blocking. Otherwise it is dependent on the situation. Using the charge attack that slaps everything around is a very good ability to use as a follow up after slamming them all down on the ground.

You pretty much never want your shield to "break" where you lose it for a few seconds and cannot block and are staggered. So keep that in mind if you feel like you're using too much of your stamina pushing things away.

As for anyone complaining about you playing defensively like that, they are more than likely wrong. Only a couple of situations would warrant it being actually detrimental to the team. The lass damage everyone takes, the better your odds to win in my book.

3
JustiniZHereLoli Sex Machine•

My general strategy on my shield axe dorf is push once to push them back and stagger them followed up by copious amounts of power attack shield bashes. I find it works very well, the push stuns em long enough for me to stagger lock them with shield bashes.

1
gynzer•

You should mostly be using your charged M1 attack. It has pretty much the same effect, except that you also do damage to them. Push should be saved for stormvermin and such, or if one rat managed to get through and is about to hit someone. If anyone complains about that, they're not worth listening to.

Also set your FOV to ~110'ish.

1
FimconteSorry, Not Sorry for taking all the kills.•

#120masterrace
See everything.

2
GreatGreen286•

Hold down left mouse button and use ur charge attack it has a pretty good knockback with shields

1
peachypoots•

Just shield bash whenever something is taking a swing at you and attack normally otherwise. Most of the time you can usually just shield bash then run forward and kill most of them and rinse repeat. Also shield bashing without attacking can be good if you see a storm vermin or a special somewhere because you can shield bash, switch to rifle and headshot the special then go back to fighting. If your teammates are having troubles from you knocking rats back then they're probably shit.

The only time you're shield pushing too much, honestly, is if you're running out of charges. If you sprinkle some slashes/charge attacks after the bashes (you get plenty of time to do them) then you'll be fine to keep on shield bashing.

1
Urechi•

If you're just blocking, you're wrong.

If you're just swinging, you're wrong.

If you're only using charge attacks, you're wrong.

If you're just bashing/pushing, you're wrong.

Everything together buddy. Its a balance.

1
norax_d2•

Swinging is kind of expendable. You only need to mix the other 3.

2
norax_d2•

Reading threads around here suggests this is actually detrimental, because it means the rest of the team has a harder time killing the skaven since they're getting knocked all over the place. If this is true, then what am I supposed to do?

Bullshit. The knockbacked rats don't deal damage while they are in the ground. The shield bash doesn't deal damage and it should be use to bash black rats only. On the other hand, the shield charged attack do the same as the bash but it also deals damage. So charged attack on everything and shield bash on black rats that are going to attack.

1