On Card Efficiency
The problem with the current Paladin deck is not that it has overwhelming tempo. The problem with the current Paladin deck is not that has overwhelming card advantage. The problem is that it's too efficient.
Often, tempo and card advantage are discussed separately in Tradeable Card Games. You get tempo with Sap or Leper Gnome; you get card advantage with Arcane Intellect or Gnomish Inventor. Rush decks try to win with tempo, sacrificing card advantage in the process. Control decks sacrifice tempo for card advantage and eventually try to win off that.
However, tempo and card advantage are really two aspects of the underlying theory of Card efficiency. Card efficiency simply measures how much a card costs vs how much it's actually worth. The key to doing this calculation is realizing that drawing a card is worth about +1.5 mana.
So let's try it out. Gnomish Inventor? Well a 2/4 is worth about 2.5 mana (it would be awesome at two and awful at three mana), drawing a card is about 1.5 mana, so Gnomish Inventor costs 4 and is worth 4 mana. So it's decently efficient.
You can also use the "+1.5 mana per card" trick in reverse. How efficient is Innervate? Well, it costs 0 mana and a card, so it effectively costs 1.5 mana. You get two mana from it. That's a pretty sweet deal, you're up +0.5 mana. Sap costs two mana plus a card, so it effectively costs 3.5 mana. If you can target a minion that costs four or more mana, then it's efficient.
Anyway, Gnomish Inventor cost 4 and was worth 4. How much is Piloted Shredder worth? Make a guess before reading on.
A 4/3 is worth about 3 mana (see Scarlet Purifier). If it dies, then you get another card, which is worth 1.5 mana. And then that card is immediately put into play, which is worth let's 1.5 mana. But having to deathrattle before you get the second part of the card is a drawback worth let's say -1 mana. So Piloted Shredder costs 4 and is worth 5 mana, and you could easily argue that it's more like 5.5 mana. That's incredibly efficient.
Let's do another one. Muster for Battle gives you two cards in one, which is worth 1.5 mana. The 1/4 weapon is worth say 0.5 mana, and the three minions are worth about two mana. So Muster for Battle costs three mana and is worth about four mana.
If you keep doing these calculations, then you'll find that Secret Paladin is simply currently the most efficient deck. At three mana they're doing something that's worth four mana, and at four mana they're doing something worth five mana. It's better to mindlessly play a card that's worth four mana for three mana, than it is to skillfully play a card that's worth three mana for three mana.
If you try to beat Secret Paladin "fairly" then they'll simply out-efficiency you. You have to fight dirty with something like Freeze Mage or Face Hunter to consistently win, because those decks don't care how efficiently Paladin is able to develop its board.
Posted Nov 1, 2015, 11:02 AM UTC · edited
I'd also add that Dragon Priest does this. It's not quite Secret Paladin - but the gist of the deck is just throwing overstatted minions out on every turn. Turn 1 2/3 Turn 2 2/4 Taunt Turn 3 3/5 Turn 4 3/6 Taunt etc.
Or alternatively, Turn 1 1/3, turn 2 2/4, turn 3 buff the 1/3 into a 3/7, etc.