JonWood007~$12k/$4k UBI•

I dont know enough about canadian finances to do the math, but it seems interesting.

5
GodspiralOP•

The only part that may not move well to the US is the "keeping of the existing old age system". But just like Canada's old age system there is probably 3 components: A pension (what you paid in) amount, A flat amount, and a topup amount.

For Canada, I'm proposing eliminating the payroll tax that pays for their pension amount. Equivalent to SS taxes in the US. Unlike Canada though, the US uses SS taxes to fund the small flat and topup component of SS payments. Canada's pension component (CPP) is self funded with a 10% tax on income up to $50k. The other 5% of its payroll taxes is for Employment insurance.

The US also has 15.3% payroll taxes paid on income up to $120k!. Like Canada about 7.5% is hidden as an employer tax. But its all a huge penalty to employment income. For most people, their tax rates are 15% points higher than the "advertised" rate.

The investor class not only gets special lower tax rates on their income for no valid reason whatsover, they also don't pay this 15% surtax on their income. Even worse, unlike Canada, they may be entitled to some of the benefits of that tax funding such as medicare, disability or perhaps an SS amount.

Canada's "medicare (universal healthcare)" amount is not a payroll tax but usually a provincial (state) tax. In Ontario, its a 6% tax in Cliff form that only applys if income is over $20k (kicks in all at one) and doesn't apply to income over $200k. Its also regressive in that the 6% drops to 1.5% on income over $48k.

Ironically, Canadians (who make over $48k) may pay less in taxes targetted to healthcare than Americans. (3% medicare tax + 1.8% surtax on income over $200k) at federal level + whatever states collect.

At any rate, Canada's old age system doesn't have many complainers who are seniors. My plan for Canadians is to lock in accrued payments Canadians have earned for themselves through past contributions. That same philosophy can apply to a US system. For future recipients, SS can be structured as Canadian $7000 UBI + $9000 GMI (clawed back by income including the SS Pension amount), and may require some not that big extra funding to achieve. There is no "first year" impact though, and can rely on future surpluses to pay for the change.

The big revenue boost from the tax plan is turning 15% payroll taxes into explicit 15% income tax, and applying it to investment income and without any caps.

That is something that is part of most of our flat tax plans as well, but the payroll and investment income transforming allows tracing the individual impacts of the tax changes, and focusing on the large innequalities rather than seeking to raise low income taxes while lowering high income ones.

My Canadian plan using these 2 changes gets to a surplus with this $16k UBI/GMI package, it does so without changing tax rates on employment income under $50k. The US math would not change tax rates for employment income under $118k, but its probably still enough for a $15k package, and there's actually more generous direct Federal programs that can be cancelled, and which are better itemized than Canada's programs. Also, a 1 or 2% tax that kicks in above an income threshold would provide significant enough revenue to get to $16k.

1
smegko•

I think tax and spend is an old idea based on an assumption, which is regularly violated both in the public and private sectors, that revenue must equal expenses. We must educate ourselves about how the financial world really functions, and use the tool of money creation to fund a basic income.

Counterexamples such as the Weimar and Zimbabwe hyperinflations are invalidated by the extreme external shocks imposed on those economies.

1
GodspiralOP•

There is a good argument for funding a portion of government with debt. QE was a form of indirectly funding past spending through printing. The spending could apply to UBI.

But whether the spending is UBI or war related, there is a bounds of reasonableness to the deficit, and reasonableness to the size of QE purchases. US's success with past and current deficit/debt levels is completely dependent on its close subservient allies and control over global financial industry.

Just as the assumption that Rome could guarantee that permanence of alliances and control was wrong, its not a valid eternal assumption for the US either. To some extent, the weakening of international support is what sunk Greece.

Still, I'd agree that printing can offset some of the funding for UBI. Especially if "dynamic scoring" math is used to imply that the deficit funding is a temporary "priming" and that future surpluses will avoid it.

2
smegko•

To me, the "reasonableness" involves too much business-as-usual thinking. The focus should be on innovation and the advance of knowledge, not funding. But I think economic simulations could be valuable (and they involve innovative programming techniques). It would be great if we can devise a simulation that tries your funding scheme, and mine, and others.

There are so many theories about the decline of Rome. My favorite is, they weren't innovative enough. They had slaves, thus did not need to develop the toy steam engines they knew about. They focused on restricting immigration (remind you of anyone today?), and eventually the would-be immigrants invaded.

We can avoid Rome's fate by encouraging innovation and the advance of knowledge. We can create as much money as we want, as long as we keep innovating. A basic income and challenges, my simulation would attempt to show, increases the pace of innovation because market forces alone tend to throttle and delay disruptive innovation. AT&T turned down engineers asking for funding to build out the internet for a decade maybe. What if the engineers had a non-market source of funding? Might we be more advanced today?

1
GodspiralOP•

The more debt there is the less taxes need to be. I think you read the piece: http://www.naturalfinance.net/2015/10/the-hamster-wheel-economy.html , and the last section (another central bank option) that discusses QE as an indirect way of printing for UBI (generic debt)

We can create as much money as we want, as long as we keep innovating.

the "as much as we want" point is the part I disagree with. The guarantee of sufficient innovation also cannot be made.

Some printing can replace some taxes in funding. But how much printing is a separate discussion.

1