[Discussion] Meaningful Fox Tweaks
Tipped-Off 11 brought the hype, the tears, and the cheers. Hyperflame's Lucas was a thing of beauty, IPK vs ESAM very nearly brought me to the threshold for a seizure, Junebug proved once again that fundamentals are as stylish as ever, and Prof. Pro's mastery of character intricacies was refreshing to watch. Also GnW only came in 5th so that unquestionably proves that GnW is balanced and suffers no design flaws whatsoever ^^^^^^(stillsalty).
But deep in the bowels of pools wave 2, a horrid abomination was brewing.
A fox player made it to losers semi's.
Hide your kids, hide your wife. Obviously we cannot let such an atrocity fester among our ranks, so I call upon you, the people, to strike down this monster before he multishines us to an early grave.
End satirical flavor text. I'm GomerUSMC, a resident Wolf/Fox player from South Carolina. I don't post often, but I thoroughly enjoy design and balance discussions and theorycrafting solutions to common problems and issues people cite with characters. Recently, two talking points have become rather prominent; the designs of Fox and Mr. Game and Watch.
While GnW fosters at least some healthy debate with arguments from both sides based on his design, Fox has had a much more overwhelming quantity of backlash in recent patches, even with nerfs and sidegrades crafted to combat just that. As such, this post will focus solely on Fox.
Fox is a difficult pimple to pop. Many people argue that percentage nerfs across the board won't adequately reign him in because of the power inherent in his toolkit, but change him too much and you risk alienating current players, as well as partially closing an entry avenue from our sister game, Melee.
Much of Fox's hate came from early kill opportunities via shine (this was changed already) and an oppressive neutral/pressure game coupled with a low risk-medium reward option via blaster. Removing either of these things could severely change who Fox is as a character, so I decided to merely change one of these instead.
Presenting The Taser
What if, instead of Fox's blaster innately tacking on damage from a distance, it increased the percentage/knockback/percentage & knockback of Fox's next attack to connect with the tased opponent within the next Y seconds. Instead of removing interaction via blaster camping, the Fox player is still required to approach his opponent at some point, changing the form and timing of the interaction rather than removing it outright. A fox player is still incentivized to use the blaster, and the opponent is still incentivized to avoid it, while removing Fox's option to ONLY laser camp in order to accrue percentage while avoiding or minimizing neutral interactions.
Furthermore, a maximum percentage/knockback increase based on the taser would allow for some proportional decreases in other areas of Fox's kit. Say..... upsmash/upair?
Fox's vertical killing potential relative to the rest of the cast has also been a point of contention for a long time. I feel this retooling of Blaster opens up some room for further tweaks to some of fox's more devastating moves. Drillshine linking into upsmash on the cast would be far less annoying if the upsmash after the link killed a bit later. However, tasing the opponent up to the cap would allow for kills off of raw neutral punishes through the use of upsmash.
The same can be said of upthrow upair. A corresponding percentage nerf to upair could potentially reduce the ease of the punish linking into a kill. Upthrow naturally launches taser rounds, but the first hit of upair would consume these stacks, increasing its static knockback and making it slightly easier to smash DI out of the second hit. This, of course, makes it much more meaningful to fox players that they connect with ONLY the second hit, and if they can they would be adequately rewarded for it.
So, there's my, admittedly barebones, idea for a Fox retooling. Please, let me know what you think of it(i.e. give me the reasons for why it's stupid), and by all means post your own tweaks to his design. I do love me some meaty discussion. I'd like to think of this less as a suggestion thread and more as a stepping stone to discussion and theory crafting.
Posted Nov 9, 2015, 9:01 PM UTC · edited