Rules, changing the me vs you mentality

We have been open for 18 months. My husband leans toward mono but is gradually embracing poly. I am full poly trying to move at the pace he feels comfortable with.

We have a list of rules which are ever changing as we go along. Tonight, I clarified what I'm allowed to do in an upcoming physical encounter with a partner I acquired through unusual circumstances. I wanted to clarify our rules for the event. When I was clarifying, he became angry because in the past I had said that I wanted to keep some BDSM activities between us and that shouldn't be asking because it was clear where we stood on the activity. I said that it was never written down so I didn't remember I had said that.

Then he got mad at me because I said feel like the rules are put upon me and restrictive. He says that we agree on the rules together and it makes him really angry that I feel they are a necessary evil put upon me because it makes him look like an ogre. I feel that I'm not given credit for always following them. I feel I was doing the correct thing clarifying my intent before my encounter and I didn't deserve his harsh reaction. For those of you living within compromise, how do you do it?

Edit: He sees my using language about our agreement (rules are restrictive, punishing, holding me back) as negative and not helpful. He views it as me trying to get him to a place I want so that I can be happy. At the time we were discussing things we were actively tying to identify issues of contention within our relationship so I thought since my encounter was coming up and w were discussing relationship stuff that it was a good time to discuss it. In hindsight he apologized but asked if why I didn't understand his reaction. I feel like things get so specific that I literally do write them down but when I don't, like this case, I shouldn't blamed for having a different understanding also me engaging in PIV Sex with my partners is new and I have only done it once last week.

Posted Nov 15, 2015, 7:25 AM UTC · edited

07
illuminspiration•

What is the third person's perspective? It sounds like the rules apply to them but they don't get a lot of say in the matter.

3
whatnointroduction•

I imagine that it's not too different from hooking up with anyone else in some ways. Everyone has varying demands on their time, resources and ability to commit emotionally. Everyone has a different list of physical activities that they enjoy and feel comfortable with, and that list may vary from partner to partner for any reason or for no reason at all. Treating polyamory with someone who's already partnered as if you're being cheated when you're not presented with a completely blank check is kind of shitty; I think it's respectful to approach every person according to what they can give you, not what you think you're entitled to.

6
Polypseudonym•

Thank you for that perspective. As a solo poly person it is one I haven't really considered. I bristle at someome else limiting my relationship. After reading your post though I think my main issue has been how it is presented to me. It's never I am uncomfortable with doing X or even I can't do X it's always I would do X but my wife won't let me.

4
SwitchingLadyOP•

In this case third person's perspective doesn't matter and has agreed to follow what has been put forth. He isn't someone I'm dating, more of a casual hook up thing.

2
HappyRamenMan•

Negotiation and compromise is part of poly for sure, especially if you are kinky. You did do the right thing by clarifying. I don't know how you did it exactly and there always is a better way to approach these things in hindsight. Rules in my experience lead to expectations and expectations lead to disappointments. We can sit here and talk about rules vs. agreements all we want too but that doesn't really help you.

You need to be you. Nobody else ever has the ability to choose for you or to make decisions on how you feel. That is solely your responsibility and right. At the end of the day your partner is where he is and is making the decisions he feels are best for him. You need to decide if that is okay for you or not and if not what you will be willing to do about it. If it means delaying your new relationship then that's what you decide. He is being possessive and jealous/envious, it happens, and that sucks for you. You need to figure out if you are willing to accept that (you can and should of course discuss it with him) or not accept it (again communicate) and find a way forward one way or another. I hope this helps and internet hugs, that sucks.

2
619flapoly newbie•

I don't know what to say because I am of the opinion that if you are ok with your partner being intimate with someone else, it's kind of controlling to nitpick and dictate who can put what where and when. Ad long as it's safer sex, what difference does it make which body part goes where or who ties who up or whatever it is. I guess it's different if he's your dom maybe? That's a different situation. But still, I'm of the opinion that intimacy is intimacy and I don't get making lists of rules. Either you are secure in your sexuality or you arent. I haven't been in that situation yet but I can't think of anything less sexy than being told I have to keep a list of rules sexually. Just my two cents. I know lots of people feel like they need rules to feel secure.

2
SwitchingLadyOP•

The thing is his usual response is "Maybe in the future, I just don't feel comfortable with that yet." I think that he just had a bad day.

I agree with you. That is why I don't do that with him. However, he is the one I need to get on board with poly not the other way around. It has been hard for him to get to this point but as long as things keep moving forward I guess I'm happy enough. Relationships are about compromise in the end. I feel like he needs to be in control of the rate of change to feel secure.

1