r/hackintosh•
lameron

is "El Capitan" worth to update?

hi, i have my laptop lenovo u310 running mavericks right now for like a year now! it runs smooth, no major problem. its been a while and i wanna update to el capitan. i was wondering is el capitan is stable enough as os and worth to update?. thank you yall

Posted Nov 22, 2015, 1:40 PM UTC

412
KamikazeRusher•

As a long-term OS X loyalist, skip it. It's not worth it.

I have yet to ever make a Hackintosh but that doesn't matter. El Capitan offers little to nothing, unless Hand-off is absolutely necessary for you. u/ma_pet_joelacanth pretty much nailed it by saying the UI has changed -- for the worst I might add -- and the "Rootless" feature does nothing to help.

Stick with Mavericks. I really miss that OS, and I'd take the opportunity to downgrade to it if some of my software at work wasn't El Capitan-only. Memory compression worked well for users with less than 8GM RAM, the UI and touchpad enhancements were solid, but most importantly it didn't have the biggest crock-'o-shit bug that Yosemite introduced: WiFi.

Yosemite's biggest flaw is broken 802.11h support. 802.11h is a sub-protocol that deals with something called Dynamic Frequency Selection: an algorithm pushed for by governments that use the 5GHz (802.11a/n/ac) to prevent home user equipment from creating interference with government activity, such as communications with satellites or Doppler radar. When this algorithm, which has been used for 8 or so years, was broken by developers it created a nightmare for Mac owners, and what's worse is it's not something that many or any user would know nor have control over! Home routers that implemented this (hidden away in firmware as a non-negotiable option depending on your country of residence) couldn't work with Yosemite. You'd connect for two seconds before your connection was dropped and you found the little WiFi icon scanning again. The only solutions were to use a wired connection ("Wait, what's 'wired ethernet?'" - MacBook Air, rMBP), buy a router that allows disabling 802.11h (actually illegal in the UK), or downgrade. There are still some traces of this in El Capitan, depending on the vendor router/access point.

"Rootless" is designed for idiots. Idiots who have no idea what they're doing (remember sudo rf -r /?) and install software from porn sites after clicking "Allow apps from anywhere" because they think it makes it "country-independent." (Yes, these people exist.) While you can boot into recovery mode, you run into the issue of El Cap not properly installing it. My laptop, a late '14 15" rMBP, still had the Mavericks recovery disk throughout Yosemite and El Capitan and I never knew. When I installed El Cap it, for whatever stupid reason, erased the Yosemite recovery and didn't install El Cap. I wasn't the only person who experienced this bullshit, and it took two days to finally install it properly. You cannot disable Rootless without El Cap recovery; Mavericks and Yosemite recovery disks won't recognize the command.

So many little things can go wrong that would force you to start from scratch. It just isn't worth the trouble.

4
lameronOP•

There are still some traces of this in El Capitan, depending on the vendor router/access point.

this does it! thank you for the reply, im gonna stay in mavericks..

1
ma_pet_joelacanth•

I put it on my MacBook and haven't noticed a single thing different except disk utility is now foreign to me and that SIP rootless bullshit got in the way of things even on a legit Mac. I'm not putting it on my hack. There aren't any changes that would improve my workflow so it's not worth breaking things for.

3
throwawayylmao777•

It breaks support for a lot of USB wifi chips, so not for me personally

2
MoleStrangler•

I'm sticking with Yosemite. It works for me and still a happy user.

The update it still shown I my AppStore and I get the notification to upgrade.

The worry is one day it may hit the wrong button in the notification and screw my install up.

Would be nice to remove it.

2
ThomKane•

If you can, pick up a cheap hard drive to clone your hackintosh drive to. I managed to get a 5400 RPM 320GB drive to use solely as a backup. It is bootable so I can mess around with my main install. If I break anything I boot in to the 320GB backup, wipe my main install and then copy from my backup to my main drive. It has been a life saver recently.

2
friskevision•

I did exactly that after having a functional hackintosh for two years.

1
methamp•

Yes.

1
atka•

Stable enough yes the only issue that I can see causing you a problem is the USB ports feature.

1
chictyler•

Features:

All animations are now much smoother on anything with an HD 4000 or better. While I used to see stutters on my rMBP power only its display, on El Capitan it never drops below 60fps powering an additional 1440p and 1080p monitor. Fastest, most reliable release since Snow Leopard (though still chugs on computers with 2GB of RAM or a HDD that Snow Leopard runs well on). My computer needs fewer reboots and runs cooler than ever before.

Split screen full screen apps. It hasn't replaced BetterTouchTool Windows-style split screen entirely for me, but it's much better for specific purposes, like focusing on typing notes to a webpage or book. You can adjust both window sizes simultaneously with the median between them. Very nice.

Spotlight can now be moved as a window anywhere. Great for using it as a calculator when it'd usually get in the way. Also now has a few more pieces of data to pull from, like weather, and all search fields on OS X can now accept "natural language" like "photos from may last year in Vienna".

Safari now has pinned tabs and audio muting by tab or for whole browser.

System font is now San Fransisco, much more readable from distances than Helvetica.

Things to note:

It breaks some SIMBL-dependent software that hasn't been updated by the developer to allow it to work after you disable SIP. Flashlight is the biggest thing I've run into, developer gave up on it and the GitHub forum is active but full of useless posters like myself with no ability to actually fix it.

1
extremekc•

Avoid it if you are doing any video production work. Premiere Pro is a mess with nvidia cards and other scenarios. Adobe and Apple are pointing fingers at each other - for almost a year now.

1
torokunai•

I'd only do it if you have apps that need it.

0