Doomed Harper government made 49 “future” patronage appointments
ipolitics.ca/2015/11/23/doomed-harper-governm...Posted Nov 23, 2015, 2:29 PM UTC
Posted Nov 23, 2015, 2:29 PM UTC
The thing I hate about this is that the Liberals would be setting a bad precedent to undo an action that was the Tories setting a bad precedent. Either way, it feels like democracy takes yet another little hit; and all those hits add up over time.
Stephen Harper the early reformer really strongly disliked these kinds of moves. Unfortunately, Stephen Harper the Prime Minister apparently disliked the Liberals even more. It's so tempting for any government to behave differently in government than they advocated in opposition. I really hope Justin Trudeau does his best to govern by the principles he campaigned on.
Trudeau should hammer Harper on this the first day he is back in the House of Commons. For irony's sake it would be best if he could quote pre 2005 Harper railing against appointments. "If I could quote the leader of the opposition in 2004..."
[deleted]
Not welcome by me.
I hope he hammers those fucking shit bags.
No need for bipartisanship in a majority. Fuck'em. Run roughshod.
No need for bipartisanship in a majority. Fuck'em. Run roughshod.
No, there actually is GREAT need for bipartisanship. Your image depends on it. That is the lesson Harper failed to learn, the Liberals would act the same way at their own peril.
Question period is not for the Prime Minister to hammer an opposition MP...
Last I checked, Justin Trudeau is no longer campaigning against a Harper-led CPC.
The thing I hate about this is that the Liberals would be setting a bad precedent to undo an action that was the Tories setting a bad precedent.
Why?
With a few exceptions, in the Canadian system (based on the British Westminster system), we don't turf civil servants when the administration changes.
If the Liberals cancel those contracts, it makes it easier for for future governments to do so even when the appointments were made fairly.
There are certain of the most senior ranks that serve at the pleasure of cabinet, meaning they can be let go at any time, for any reason. Ambassadors and trade representatives, heads of agencies and deputy ministers, for example.
About half of these are such "at pleasure" appointments. Trudeau could dismiss all of these with no issues, or breaks of tradition. A bunch are not however, and so could sue if fired. Harper seems to have locked-in a number appointments well before they were due too, which Trudeau may be able to un-offer without opening the government up to being sued.
But changing the most senior admins and agency heads is something that happens with most changes of government.
Yepper and I referenced that below, but I try to avoid repeating myself too much. As the article says, 20 of the 49 appointments are 'at the pleasure of'.
These appointees are not necessarily "civil servants" in the true sense of the word. They are political appointees selected in part due to their partisan views.
to do so even when the appointments were made fairly.
The simple solution there is to not make any appointments for a reasonable period before an election, or make only ones that were coming due at the right time. A spike like 49, especially when some were a year early is pretty clear.
The former principle is easy to defend, and hard to attack. The latter is just the reverse.
[deleted]
"the 1984 election campaign, former Conservative Leader Brian Mulroney politically eviscerated former Liberal Prime Minister John Turner for making dozens of appointments that went into effect just before he called the election. The controversy over the appointments contributed to Mulroney winning the election in a landslide."
Back then it could lose you parliament if you made appointments that went in to effect while you were still in power. now it barely rates as a controversy when you make the appointments for almost a year after the other guys take over parliament.
It's strange the creeping loss of ethics accountability in Canadian government...
John Turner was in office for a month and made the appointments the day before the election. Harper made those appointments three months before the election began and five months before it ended.
yah, but renewing appointments that doesn't expire until 2017, and renewing them for more than 4 years, which mean these appointees will maintain Harper's influence beyond the life of the current Liberal government.
See.. some of the listed re-appointments don't start until after the next elections. That is well beyond what should be reasonable. The November/December appointments would of been somewhat reasonable. (on a timeline base.)
which mean these appointees will maintain Harper's influence beyond the life of the current Liberal government.
What makes you think that?
If you don't do what the boss says, he has grounds to fire you.
You really thing the curator of the Canadian History Museum is going to use his evil Conservative Party influence to effect policy in Canada in a negative manner? Half of the guy's museum is toys for kids to play with. How much effect is he going to cause?
Considering we once had a Museum of Civilization which was changed to the Canadian History Museum for no good reason beyond ideology and the institutional entrenchment and reflection of that ideology in culture, this individual will be in charge of doing so further.
Evil? Not really. Misguided, arrogant and cynical, for sure. Besides, the NEB appointments seem way more egregious.
How does that actually change anything?
Harper was just renewing contracts. Had he not they would have expired before parliament opened and we would be missing a lot of key civil servants. John Turner was hiring brand new people to the job, all of which were key members of the Liberal Party. Appointing a supreme Court judge and the curator of a museum doesn't have the same level of potency.
Had he not they would have expired before parliament opened and we would be missing a lot of key civil servants.
That could be an excuse for the contracts that ended in this month or December. Not for the contracts that end in 2016 and especially not June 2016.
Keep in mind the appointments were made long before Harper realized he was 'doomed'. He was probably handing out positions and making promises to try and build loyalty for his re-election. Didn't work out so well. Now most of the appointments can be cancelled / undone. It's not like Harper was expecting a huge Liberal majority.
[deleted]
Yet he left over 20 Senate seats vacant, if he was a devious as you seem to paint him he would have stacked it with CPC loyalists.
[deleted]
Senate appointments get a lot more media attention than the premature renewal of bureaucrats' contracts.
As I said above, cancelling contracts that are not 'at the pleasure of' appointments would set a bad precedent. In the United States, pretty much all of the senior civil service changes with a new administration. That's not the way it is supposed to work in our Westminster system.
Cancelling the ones that are renewed more than some reasonable time in the future would be a decent compromise.
Problem is there isn't a definition of reasonable time in the future. While we can probably agree that renewing an appointment that doesn't expire more than a year from now is crazy, it would probably still result in a court case that would drain money from the government. And depending on how the judge rule, that post would probably have to stay empty during the life of the court case in case the appointee wins.
[deleted]
If the CPC thought they were gonna win the election, then there was no reason to renew these people ahead of schedule (especially when the designated dates fell after the election). Glossing over the blatant nepotism, these people should have been loyal and expected job stability no matter what if they believed in the CPC.
This was a straight up undemocratic power play no matter how you slice it.
ScumbagSteve.jpg
Just pass a law that appointments made by the previous governement that have not hit the enactment date can be changed by the new government. Thats the way it should be anyway. Why trust these guys to do the right thing when clearly they can't be. Might as well fix the problem instead of leaving the loophole for every PM to abuse from now on.
For example, Mark O’Neill’s term as director of the Canadian Museum of History wasn’t scheduled to expire until June 2016. Last June, Harper’s cabinet renewed his $212,700 to $250,200 a year job for five years, effective June 2016.
That actually doesn't sound that bad. He entered the last year of a long term contract and was renewed for another five year term. Sounds sensible to me, compared to waiting until his contact expired and then trying to sign him to a new contact or finding a replacement at the last minute.
There would still have been more than 8 months left on his contract had they waited until after the election. The earliest end date was November 1st, every other one was mid-December or later. That's hardly 'last minute'.
As a human, I can say with full comfort that those examples are super-last-minute to start talking contract.
Renewing the November ones makes sense, but the ones from December or afterwards don't. Two months is more than enough time to sign the papers.
Had they been completely replacing these people, the argument could be made that the time was necessary to find the replacements. But in these cases they just kept the same people.
These are people you're talking about. It takes them 6-12 months to find a job, at a minimum, and that involves major geographic mobility at their level. If they and their family want to continue living in the same city, it can take even longer.
Would you wait around and get <1 month notice that you have to completely upheave your life and family - plus meaning you might be out of work for at least a year, and could have to move to another country? I wouldn't, and nor would any reasonable person with options: they would start exploring other opportunities well in-advance... Inaction means you run a huge risk of losing these people.
Two months is more than enough time to sign the papers.
We're talking about the government here.
I'd have less problem with this if Harper hadn't felt the need to change the mandate of the Museum of Civilization.
I'd have less problem with this if Harper hadn't felt the need to change the mandate of the Museum of CANADA IS THE BEST ALL THE TIME ALWAYS.
FTFY
I understand why this sounds sensible, but in the business world you avoid doing this if there was about to be a change of leadership at the top. You let the new guy (or gal) choose his team. You don't tie hands. As the article says, there has been the same tradition in government. This doesn't mean all contracts end at election time, but, by tradition, you don't renew contracts that have months left on them.
The article refers to the incident of Pierre Trudeau doing this just before John Turner took over as leader of the Liberals and Prime Minister. Brian Mulroney blasted Turner for letting those appointments stand, and yet, this was without a change in government.
I think you've misread some of the article.
Pierre Trudeau was not even mentioned in the article. John Turner, while PM, appointed many people for long terms right before calling an election that Brian Mulroney won. Mulroney blasted Turner for making the appointments and nothing about him letting previous appointments stand.
Well the actual history is that Pierre Trudeau made the appointments before stepping down as Prime Minister. In a debate, Brian Mulroney blasted John Turner for going along with the appointments and not reversing them. The article didn't mention Trudeau Sr., but that's what happened.
Thanks for the expanded information!
This is very true. Especially if you are anticipating the economy coming back to life, then you are going to have to compete with other companies that may try to take them. Its even more true since the liberals are promising much better growth that the conservatives have. So this would save even more money over the long term if we use the liberal projections.
You can argue that renewing the contract for another 2-3 years might be prudent, but a five year renewal means that appointee would survive the past the next election. This means the Liberal government would be constrained from putting their own influence on these posts. That is not "responsible government"
Yet another end run around democracy - if Harper's record in this doesn't already disgust you you're either a supporter or insufficiently well-informed, IMO it's impossible to look upon these partisan appointments with any more respect than Mac Harb being made senator.
This is what I expect from an election cheater.
Pay the money to legally cancel the contracts and get the rats out of the head positions. They would block Liberal agendas as best they could.
If they did..... we would have a serious problem with our civil service.
They are not part of the civil service.
What are they then?
Because they aren't partisan positions either.
They are board posts for various Crown corporation and Trade Boards. And they are often stacked with partisans by the government of the day. What is unusual, in this case, is allowing a previous defeated government to constraint the choice of the new government completely, since these appointments last beyond the life of the new government.
"Downe said he believes the government can cancel the appointments, if it desires" I hope Trudeau sacks up and dumps Harper's clowns then
This is also a feature of our democratic system of government. All incoming governments complain the books were cooked and all outgoing governments do as much to pay back their loyal servants as they can before their time is up. This has been going on for decades.
Absolutely, patronage appointments have long been a thing. Although, people like PM John Turner have been really hurt by being a part of it https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/You_had_an_option,_sir
What's new is the renewing contracts months in advance.
Pretty normal for the CPC. Complain bitterly about how it is morally indefensible to take a certain course of action, then go and do it themselves anyway.
Sickening. I can understand renewing 2-3 months before the end of the contract which would be around the time that those holding the positions would start looking for a new job. But anything beyond that is just dirty tricks.
But let's hope that Trudeau takes the high road and doesn't sack the whole lot of them.
[deleted]
Just fire the appointed persons. Their jobs are not etched in stone.
And any severance that they require will come out of the bugdet for Steve's security detail.
Ok that's it!!!!
This prick is no longer allowed to fly on the PM's jet.
I don't care if he finds it humiliating. He SHOULD be humiliated.
Take the bus you bastard.
They should rescind across the board as a matter of principle. And if Trudeau is as committed to doing the right thing as he says, set up an independent nomination process that finds the best people for the job, not just party hacks.
LOL. Harper will still be bouncing his dick off all our collective foreheads for years and years.
[removed]
Rescind away. Having the fist pay raise being 4k above the median Canadian salary and about 18% his own is quite bad.
And the terms renewal timeliness. Tsk
This guy's pay raise is more than I make in a year :(
Unless I misread this, the gap between the two salaries is what he is eligible to make in any given year and not a single pay raise. For instance, in his first year, he may earn 212k. Next year it would be 219k. Then 229k, 238k, 250k.
It is the same as public service positions in which you earn more as you gain experience as it is assumed that you will be more efficient at completing your job
P.S. The dollar values above are arbitrary. I have no idea what the scale would actually look like.
yea making 250 at the end of your term is no biggie considering there are many (relatively) trade jobs where you can break 200 with OT in a year.
Funny how politicians always get fat pay raises but tell us we shouldn't worry about inflation.
funny that i'm a hospital worker and I and all the doctors and nurses are on a pay freeze cause "there's just no money" but there's money for all the politician's bullshit.
If you're not getting at least 3% then your purchasing power is going down. You guys should strike for raises.
Fiat currency is a scam that only benefits politicians and the rich.
hell i would have been happy with my cost of living increase matching inflation. we got 1.5% for the next 4....
everyone appointed by harper should be brought up for review, how is it even legal to do shit like this.
Fire them all, take the hit, unless they can truly show they are or have been nonpartisan. Then black list them from any government or Crown Corp job. Besides 49 is about how many of Harpers appointees so far have been duds from Mp's to Senators during his tenure, and with that record, how many of these guys are white as snow.
Because that's not a lawsuit waiting to happen.
I don't think that's a pay raise. The government doesn't release specific salaries but the pay grade for the position will have a specific range. The salary is somewhere between those two numbers.
Which is still obscene of course.
his raise is a lot more than most canadians make...
the expected growth (actually even more so considering what the liberals have promised in terms of growth) in the economy would make these wages a good proactive approach to lock in salaries. Reducing future burden on the government.
SURE...THAT was the reason....
Standard practice. The review process would have been started at the end of 2014.
This is how US conservative administrations intentionally sabatage voter intention for a change.
They actually think no will notice or care enough to shovel up their spillage.
So many financial costs don't start appearing until many years down the road.