Minekaze vs High Tiers

I'm very curious what it would be like to play my minekaze against high tier ships. Since the MM doesn't do this, I'm thinking a division would be the only way to accomplish this.

Has anyone tried this and how was it?

Edit: if anyone with a tier 9 or 10 ship is willing to try this let me know.

Posted Nov 25, 2015, 11:09 PM UTC · edited

414
bagdigger_actualDD Master Race•

Before they took away the 10 km torps from the Precious, I would fail-toon my way to higher tier battles regularly, and would have unbelievable games back to back. Sadly, since it's been nerfed and lost the 10k torps, it's really not as devastating above her own MM range.

Yes. I refer to my Minekaze as The Precious. It was that good. Pre-nerf.

4
BillOneBadApple•

I called mine the Murderkaze. I never took the 10km torps even before the nerf because the 7km torps were faster and harder to dodge.

I had over 150k xp when I finally dumped it for the port slot.

1
bagdigger_actualDD Master Race•

I've had wildly different experiences with the 7k torps, sometimes it's great, sometimes it's lackluster.

2
infinitepaulOP•

I had played over 1200 battles before i realized there were two torpedo modes. Once i figured that out my kd ratio soared.

1
infinitepaulOP•

The 10k torps must have been removed before I was playing the game.

1
moondanceMI NE KA ZE (Destroyer_Minekaze@US)•

It can be pretty good. Back in beta I had 200k dmg games with it and once sunk a Montana all by myself (it takes two full salvos).

Pros

  • low detection range makes you spot every tier 10 DD before they spot you, even if they run the concealment module, but assuming you either both have the captain perk or both don't. Only the kagero gets to the same range as you.
  • more torps per minute than a shima...
  • cheap but can make tons of money
  • longer games usually means the entire team doesn't die before you get in range
  • your torps are low tier so their detection is tiny, people at high tier often neglect that so you can hit cruisers more easily than any other DD

Cons

  • teammates may bitch about you not knowing the power of the minekaze
  • CVs brutalize you. Other DDs can either gun or stealth torp from a safe distance. You need to be right up close to the enemy. Getting spotted by planes at 8km out of the enemy fleet is disastrous. And high tier CVs have 5-8 squads at up to 180 knots, so they're likely to spot you without even trying to.
  • you can dodge enemy DDs but they make you useless. They're hard to hit with torps and you don't have the fallback of gunning them with fleet support like higher tier IJN DDs do

Overall, if there are no CVs and 3 or less DDs the minekaze can be better than any IJN DD but shima. But if there are 2 CVs you are worthless.

2
Ascend3rImperial Japanese Navy•

While skeptical, mostly because of just how hard and immediate the punishment of being spotted would be, I still think this would be more effective than my trollmatches in WoT with the KV-2 on tier 10 :D

Honestly at 7km you're right up there in the killzone and any mistake is going to result in your immediate and swift death. There will be a lot more aviation about and people will be more likely to respond correctly and dodge torps, at least proportionately to the lower tiers.

1
DrOwnz•

Be careful, a proper equipped Benson with a captain that has the t5 skill has better concealment than the minekaze

1
Pegguins•

If you run into a t5 captain usDD? Painful. If you don't (and you probably won't) it's basically just a fubuki with worse guns and hp but better torps.

1
audigexWooden Ships and Iron Men•

Yes you'd have to use a division with another player.

I can't say I've tried it - although I was considering trying a Umikaze in a higher tier game to see what would happen - torps every 20 seconds and a 5.5km detection range could be entertaining around islands

0
ShuggieHamsterBANZAI!•

aerroon did it in a tier 8 match I think. hes got a vid of it on his utube channel. sailed about the map spamming torps at everything and nearly pulled out a win for his team. looks like the Umikaze can hang with any tier

1
audigexWooden Ships and Iron Men•

Good guy Umikaze

0
ALRidgeRunner•

I once took my Umikaze (with a 12 point Captain) into a T6 match with a friend just for giggles and a teammate promptly TK'd me for being a fail division. :(

They didn't understand the power of the Umikaze. :(

0
ShuggieHamsterBANZAI!•

some folk cant see past their own stupidity. umikaze is a stealthy death bringer

0