A deck for any commander?

tl;dr: Help me build a deck of 99 where I can go to edhrec, get a random commander, and play the deck with it.

Inspired by decks made to be played with different commanders depending on the situation, I started thinking about the possibility of decks where the designated generals don't share all their colors. I began picturing a deck made for Zendruu/Nekusar, where all the group hug card draw in one deck is turned into a full on win-con.

But then the next logical step: A deck designed to be playable (not amazing, not optimal, but playable) with any commander. Clearly a bunch of 'any color' lands, some mana rocks. But what's next? Equipment? Big golems/eldrazi?

What do you all think?

I'm going to try to put together a decklist, but I want to make sure I'm not missing anything big.

Posted Nov 26, 2015, 6:24 PM UTC

45
MatsuzoSF•

Honestly, this is a pretty bad idea. You would have to build for a colorless commander, but throw in any color lands/rocks to cast any commander you decide to use (except for Command Tower and the like, which don't produce mana in a colorless deck, they would just tap for colorless if the commander is colorless). It would be like running a commander just for its colors, except you don't get to use colors.

EDIT: Wording.

7
squabzilla•

You hit the nail on the head. Tbh the best idea I have is some colorless artifact deck designed to search out darksteel forge and mycosynth lattice. Then you have all the colors!

1
Banuken•

Pretty sure we came across the same question last week..., didn't we?

The only answer is a colorless deck (wait a bit and you'll have new toys and colorless interaction coming with the next set)... because only 99 cards that would be legal in a colorless deck will be legal in a "any commander goes" deck. This limitation means NO COLORED MANA can appear on those 99 cards, AT ALL.

I guess you figured it out when you say "a bunch of 'any color' lands": yes, those will be the only possible venue for you to cast your commander. Tricky!

I recommend you build the manabase first, show us it is doable, and then some of us will probably come up with suggestions for the core of the deck. As it is... it seems like a half impossible / half unfun challenge.

4
Rasalom72All the Mana! •

Can't happen. You can't play colored mana in a colorless deck (colorless commander)

1
sharpavery•

But you can have cards that produce any kind of mana but if the commander doesn't use colors it just defaults to colorless mana

1