r/duelyst•
iVariable

can someone explain to me how to play against magmar?

I just don't get it... It doesn't seem to have any clear weaknesses to me and always seems to have the answer to anything I play. For the most part I understand the other classes but I just can't figure out magmar...

I did a gauntlet run last night and had 4 fairly decisive victories against vanar, abyssian, lionar and vetruvian and got absolutely smashed by 3 different magmar players

Please help..

Posted Nov 26, 2015, 10:05 PM UTC

716
Ekkosangen•

Cards that are almost guaranteed to be in every Magmar deck:

  • Young Silithar, Veteran Silithar, Silithar Elder

Rebirth is somewhat straightforward: Kill the unit, it becomes a 0/1 egg that you have to kill to prevent it from hatching back into the unit it used to be. Generally, the Magmar player isn't going to attack into death, since you would then have your full turn to kill it. You can probably use this knowledge to your advantage. Also, Elders suck to fight against, pray you have some way of removing it and the egg it spawns. If you can keep up board control, you might not even see it get dropped.

  • Mana Burn

It's a dispel with 2 damage, not much else to say about it.

  • Makantor Warbeast

Probably the biggest frustration you'll have playing against Magmar, combines Diretide Frenzy and Elucidator without the downside and 2 less damage. Frenzy is just something you'll need to try to play around from 6 mana and out.

  • Natural Selection, Plasma Storm, Egg Morph

Basically, your bigger creatures will avoid removal better than little ones. Egg morph you can't do much about, but at least it soaks up an attack as well.

  • Spirit Harvester

Play something big or use removal. Might not see it in every deck.

  • Earth Sphere

Unless you have a way of comboing them out in one go, just pretend their health is about 8 points higher.

tl;dr Magmar is well suited to control style decks, AoE and removal combos. Try to keep your bigger threats separated so they don't get Makantor'd, and maintain board control without overdoing it or the AoE will get you. Bigger drops are usually better, but play anything that might soak up removal for more important things.

In gauntlet, silithars will get drafted almost every time so expect a lot of them (I draft 4-5 veterans sometimes).

In constructed, Songhai or Vetruvian combo can easily be one of the most difficult matchups.

5
AsuraCem•

Tbh I don't think there's an answer to Magmar in Gauntlet in general. Unless you have better luck during card selection. Seriously, Magmar's mechanic is just so stable and low-risked in Gauntlet.

4
bobly81•

You can hope the magmar is either bad or unlucky at picking cards.

2
Hereticalnerd•

I can tell you one thing I've struggled to learn. When you go to kill a rebirth unit, don't just queue up your attack on the egg. Wait until the egg has spawned and then hit it. Don't queue an attack on the unit and the egg quickly and end your turn, because then the egg lives and you look dumb and have to emote oops a bunch.

Edit:Seriously I've done this multiple times in the same game on the same unit.

3
august2014•

Magmar is OP in gauntlet. Game is not class balanced in gauntlet.

1
SippyCup090•

You don't. I'm done with this game until Magmar gets balanced. It's not even fun anymore. Been stuck at like rank 5 for ever because I enjoy playing Lyonar and everyone plays Magmar because they're broke and unbalanced.

-7
Arveene•

Pretty sure lyonar has one of the better matchups against magmar.

13
Kinowolf_•

Would you like some salt with your salt?

4
JayceMJ•

With Lyonar you should be rising easy. Magmar isn't a hard matchup for him. Stay aggressive and you'll roll over Magmar. What's the deck you're running?

1
R0ockS0lid•

I've been climbing past five well enough with Lyonar... I'll post my deck list if you'd like to take peak.

1
xenoph2•

I'd be interested in that but it probably has 4-5 more Legendaries and 3 more Epics than I can afford.

1
R0ockS0lid•

That might well be the case, depending on what you've got so far...

Either way, here you go.

1
xenoph2•

Thanks! How do you make these lists with the lineup atop, btw?

1
Shaz716•

I got to s rank on the back of two epics on holy immolation and one arclyte regalia that spent most if it's time getting replaced. This month. You guys need to look closely at your play instead of making assumptions that card power is what's keeping you down. A mecha Abyssian deck made it up to s-rank. My final climb to s was a stream of 5 grind out magmar games with a proper three elder control deck. You can do it, bit you never will if you count on epics and legendaries instead of solid play.

1
xenoph2•

Well I'm at Rank 5 with a Lyonar deck that doesn't have epics or legendaries. I think I'm doing just fine.

Didn't mean to complain, the grind for cards in this game is way milder than in other titles, was just an assumption.

1