My view on the relation between the streamer and his own stream

Introduction

 

As most people already know I have been unmodded by my own request. I know what you think: “Is this a thread where you whine about being actually unmodded because you were bluffing?”. No.

 

I don’t intend to ever return to playing in this stream and my request was serious, but I feel like I didn’t communicate the reasons why I left well enough. The reasons are diverse, but they mostly boil down to the same essence, the behaviour of the streamer. The next part of this text will explain all these reasons in full length so in case you don’t want to read all of it just jump ahead to the summary and conclusion.

 

Before I jump to my reasoning please let me emphasize that this is about the way the streamer acted and does not change the fact that I think he did an incredible job making TPDS possible in the first place.

 

Reasons

 

You decided to read the long version? Thank you for your time, but let’s get right to it.

 

Reason 1: The streamer and his mods

 

The first problem I have regards the relation between the streamer and his mods or more specifically the process of modding. Most streamers choose their mods among the most active, reasonable and helpful people and the process of making them a mod usually involves talking to them before or even after modding them. So how does it work here? Let me start with my case. I was here because I accepted the challenge of beating the game on twitch after mostly lurking during the Dark Souls playthrough. I did my best to help with knowledge, votes and even some leadership during bossfights. Just a couple of days later I was modded, but for what reason? Today I know I was recommended by a few of the other mods, but I will never know the exact reasoning. Do you want to know why? Because the streamer never talked to me, he never asked if I want to be a mod, he just assumed that I am fine with all the extra responsibility and the target on my back for all the hate. You know what? I was fine with it, I was ready to commit to this project even more and voluntarily do the extra work. So, why did he never talk to me about it? I wasn’t at home for the weekend and thus not around when he modded me, was that it? No, I wasn’t the only person modded during that time and casual_Bear wasn’t talked to either. We were just thrown into the cold water without a warning. We weren’t worth the little work it takes to send a private message. It was Rogueain in fact who contacted me and offered me to answer any question I might have.

 

Soon after all this happened the stream faced his first big threat: bots. This is where my second problem comes from, not from the bots themselves, but from the way they were dealt with. So we started to get attacked by bots, but despite permabanning every single one of them we couldn’t do much to prevent the damage they did, we lost npc’s, items and some of us even hope. Since we didn’t have a proper solution we had to use subonly-mode to prevent the worst. It was the streamers job to find a solution, but it wasn’t he who got the hate for the use of the subonly-mode it was the mods who had to take it. Did we ever get a thank you or any kind of appreciation for that? Yes, but not from the streamer. Instead we got nice words even from non-subs who were severely restricted, but understood our course of action.

 

We were obviously still in need of a good solution and many suggestions were made, but what was the solution the streamer decided to implement? A veto-system, a system that relies on the mods to be a 100% focused on each turn in order to veto in case bots show up. So the solution was essentially asking the mods to do even more work. Don’t get me wrong the system worked, but that’s not the streamer’s doing. It was the work of the mod team. Again, no thank you or anything.

 

Instead of appreciation for our hard work we got distrust. Some trolls started crying and the streamer immediately jumped to the conclusion that it’s the mods’ fault for being too strict or abusing their powers. This resulted in the creation of the new rules we had to follow, the rules that didn’t allow us to protect the work other viewers do, the rules that ultimately resulted in our character being deleted. But we don’t have to worry because and I quote “If things are deleted I can always restore them how they were.” - thebagmaster on reddit, but i won’t go into details about that statement just yet so bare with me. I do know these rules have been changed and the mods are now allowed to do their job again, but was there an apology for the bad rules and the cut of power? No, instead of an apology for the distrust we got jokes and a streamer talking about salt.

 

Why would anyone be salty about being distrusted and removed all the means to do their job they have been doing for hundreds of hours voluntarily. Why would anyone be salty about such a display of disrespect?

 

Reason 2: The streamer and his viewers

 

I sure talked a lot about the mod problems and this may seem very egocentric, but let’s talk about the viewers in general.

 

Obviously the whole point of any TwitchPlays is to present the viewers with the means to beat a game as a group of people with very different goals. There is no point in Twitchplays without any viewers so they should be the most precious thing for the streamer and his mods. It’s the work and passion of the viewers that makes the Twitchplays experience. It should be in the best interest of the streamer to keep his viewers happy and their work safe. That does not mean that trolling should be banned, quite the opposite, trolls are one of the challenges for any Twitchplays, but there should be limitations to the extent of trolling that is allowed. The stream is for everyone and letting trolls do what they want will not make the majority of the viewers happy.

 

This is where Twitchplaysdark failed, instead of being concerned about the happiness of all viewers, the biggest concern was the liberty to do everything. There is nothing wrong with some limitations to liberty for the sake of safety. There is a reason why the USA which so heavily celebrates freedom still needs laws and a police. That’s not to say that the “police” doesn’t need rules, but just because they might break rules does not mean that rules are suddenly not needed anymore.

 

The viewers, may it be the tryhards making progress, the trolls fighting them or even just the people populating chat without playing, are the meat of this stream. They make this project successful and you should be thankful, you should thank every last one of them for taking part in your stream.

 

Reason 3: The streamer and his mistakes

 

This section is definitely the hardest for me. Nobody likes to make or admit mistakes and it’s even harder if other people talk about your mistakes, but I think it’s even worse to just ignore the mistakes from the past without learning from them. So I am gonna point out what I think are the 3 biggest mistakes the streamer made.

 

The first mistake that ultimately led to the deletion of the character was a lack of communication with the mods and thus a lack of trust. The mods are the face of this stream they are around, they take the heat, you need to talk to them.

 

The second mistake was to trust trolls not to do everything they can do to ruin all progress and trusting their word blindly.

 

The third mistake and maybe the easiest to avoid mistake was the lack of a proper backup. This is where the quote I already mentioned in the part about the mods comes into play. I quote: “If things are deleted I can always restore them how they were.” - thebagmaster on reddit. Apparently this was a lie as we all know he wasn’t able to restore the save-file. I don’t want to imply that he intended to lie, but this shows the lack of foresight. Making a backup is quickly done and takes very little work, but yet none have been made for over a month.

 

These mistakes can all be forgiven, but that leads to one of my biggest problems with all of this: How can one expect to be forgiven for ones mistakes if one doesn’t admit said mistakes. During all of this there has never been a post from the streamer admitting that he fucked up or apologizing for it, his mistakes are apparently not even worth a thread.

 

The reaction to the deleted files was a thread without any text asking the viewers what to do. The viewers who should be able to rely on the streamer to fix problems he himself caused.

 

The Conclusion of the incident with the deleted files was yet another post without any text thanking casual_Bear. Don’t get me wrong what Bear did was great, but what ash said sums up the situation perfectly: “I helped a tiny bit too... But no love. What's a scrub to do?” -EvilDeadAsh34 on Reddit. Casual was thanked for fixing the streamers mistakes for him, but not all the other people who tried to help the streamer get through the game he never really played. People were immediately ready to forgive the streamer for what he did and tried to help him fix his shit, but they didn’t even get a thank you let alone an apology.

 

Reason 4: The streamer and my umodding

 

This Section is by far the shortest. As you all should know, since you’re apparently reading this Reddit, I made a post on here requesting to be umodded after the things that happened and I additionally sent a private message to the streamer that essentially summed up the reasons given under Reason 1. It’s written in a a bit more aggressive way since my anger about the situation hadn’t cooled off, but the points made are the same.

 

The problem I have with this is not that I was really unmodded, I expected that. It’s the fact how I was unmodded that makes this problematic. I was unmodded silently, apparently all I voluntarily did for this stream wasn’t worth a single word nor was he willing to say anything about the accusations I made.

 

Summary

 

As I said in the Introduction the reasons for my decision to leave are diverse, but let me try to sum them up in case you weren’t in the mood to read everything.

 

Reasons to leave the stream:

  • disrespect for the work mods do
  • distrust in the mods
  • no real attempt to communicate with mods or with viewers on reddit
  • lack of appreciation for the patience and work of everyone
  • lack of protection for the viewers (bad rules, no recent backups)
  • streamer not willing to admit mistakes or apologize
  • the way I was unmodded (details above)

 

Conclusion and Suggestions

 

So what now? Should everyone just leave? No, I am glad many people are ready to forgive and forget, but you should never take your viewers or mods for granted. If you make a mistake just admit it and apologize. Everyone makes mistakes it’s normal, but don’t ignore them, learn from them. Start to communicate at least a little with all your mods, if you have a problem hear them out. I understand they aren’t all around at once and your time is limited, but with a smart use of the messaging system it’s not that hard to keep communication going without much effort.

Posted Dec 1, 2015, 6:48 AM UTC

47
Zerosyko•

Good points, for much of this. I do believe you're being a bit over dramatic in some of these cases.

At the point you were made a mod, silently, we had average viewership of like 20-30. It'd pretty much become a club filled with regulars, both subs and non.

I said this in stream chat and I'll say it here. Streamer probably has quite a bit going on, and if one day he checks the reddit and there are MULTIPLE threads about mod abuse, but none in support of mods, what else is he going to think? Nobody was speaking up in regards to keeping players banned. Should tpds have contacted you guys first, probably. But guy made a panic decision, underestimated how much of asshole the trolls can be, and we know what happened next.

This compounded with the backup mistake. I'm certain the streamer was left with his metaphorical foot in his mouth, now that everyone was looking to him for action and he couldn't get what was promised. He even played for hours trying to fix everything on his own. We are lucky to have had the problem resolved in the meantime.

Those are my opinions on the main event. As for some other things, I don't believe you should get a special send off for freaking out the first time shit hits the fan and asking to be unmodded. Being a mod, or having any form of responsibility over others, requires you to be prepared for bad things happening and having the head to deal with it. You bowed out, and streamer respected that and let you do so. Sorry, that last part is just really unnecessary and sounds a bit entitled.

You're a cool guy, Golforce. Not trying to say that you're not. But if I'm captaining a ship, I want a crew that will still have my back if I fuck up even in a major way, especially if I put in my own time to try and fix it.

4
golforceOP•

I appreciate your answer, but I strongly disagree with you.

First of all, if i recall correctly i was modded almost 2 months ago on the day we beat Last Giant and at that time we had an average viewership of over a 100.

I know streamer has a lot going on, but that just makes it even more important to communicate with the mods to have an idea of what's going on. A quick uninformed decision is not the way to go.

I didn't mean to say he wasn't trying to fix his mistakes he really was, my point is that he never apologized for his fuck ups and while he certainly tried to fix it he wouldn't have been able to do anything without the help of all the people in chat.

I didn't expect a special send off and while the deletion of our character was the worst thing that happened so far it wasn't the first time "shit hit the fan". What I expected was a comment on all the accusations i made. My PM was mostly about respect and his missing answer showed that i was on point.

Of course a crew should stand behind it's captain, but only if the captain is a good captain who shows leadership and communicates with his crew. A captain that only leaves his room once a month and expects his crew to do everything on their own without talking to them at all is certainly not that. Most crews of ships are also not voluntarily working on the ship.

2
seannyb•

Though I can't speak for TPD, I will infer that he wants to be as hands-off as possible with the game, refusing to dictate the culture of it beyond christening some TPDS enthusiasts as moderators. Shaping the culture of the game is implicitly the chat's job. In TPDS1, Zyzex for example was "the troll mod", a paradox reflecting that ideology. Once again, that's just my inference, but I've always respected that view as a mere player of the game.

I know that moderators get a lot of hate and have to deal with bot mobs, whisper spam, dupe accounts, and other malicious things, so as a player, it falls to me to say what the streamer does not: thanks for being a moderator. Same goes to all the moderators in chat. You all are doing Lord Gwyn's work, keeping this run alive in the face of its detractors.

Thanks to the streamer for providing this platform to play Dark Souls in a web browser :D

Thanks casual_bear for custom-restoring w olaire's adventure.

3
rrr00fs•

#GG

No re.

2
EvilDeadAsh34•

Love ya, brother. Sad you're gone for real, but i understand.

LORDE CLUB FOREVER!

1
Pensacola_Fred•

One question, u mad brah?

1
emjay101•

why do you write so much text for a dead project

1