r/startups•
wall8

Am I being taken advantage of?

I have the opportunity to work with a startup in the creation of their product. All they have at this point is the idea. I would be the fourth person recruited to work on the project alongside three other co-founders. I was brought in because I have some technical and design experience. I have some concerns however:

There is no capital, I will be helping build the prototype to be sold to investors for equity in the company. I have been offered 5%. This number seems fairly set in stone right now.

The other co-founders have +-20% each and have allocated a certain percent to offer investors.

I am not very business savvy, but I feel like 5% is low when there is no product at this point and my skills are needed to build it.

I like the idea, and I would like to be a part of it, but at the same time I don't think the equity is fair given the point that the project is at and the work I would be putting into it. I wouldn't say Im a co-founder, but I'm more than just an employee at this point

Am I being unreasonable?

Posted Dec 1, 2015, 11:53 PM UTC

224
Pingrapp•

Yeah 5% does seem pretty low

4
askoruli•

A lot of this depends on how much work you're expected to put in. If it's just 1 month and then there will be investment and you'll transition to a paid employee then maybe 5% is ok. On the other hand if you're expected to work indefinitely for free then 5% seems like a terrible deal.

The way I look at it is that you're essentially the first real investor except you're investing your time instead of money. Especially if the other founders are all going to sit and wait until your done before they can start work. It's awful being in a position where you deliver a solid product only to find out that the people you're working with can't deliver on the promises they made.

4
GaryARefuge•

Yeah, look at the time requirement and the value you place on your time per hour.

Since this is for bullshit equity that has no value currently and requires you to take a huge risk I would multiply your hourly rate to a degree that makes you feel like the risk is worth the reward.

After you have an understanding of what you feel your time is worth ask the next important question Is the leadership team capable of pulling this off?

  • are they all on the same page?
  • do they all understand the value of the company and product?
  • are they clear on how to convey their vision to you and others?
  • do they understand how to raise investor funding? Have they done this before?
  • do their skill sets align properly to work in a cohesive and coherent group towards their goals?
  • is it clear what, how, why you are to build the product for them ?

Then you might want to ask, "what they each are doing to warrant their equity percentage and why they have structured it in the way they have?" It might shed some light on their business acumen or give you a sense of their personal character.

It might make sense to structure your equity based upon the amount of work you do at your given rate and have that equity granted to you upon the time of the company raising its initial seed investment. The equity given to you would be based upon that valuation and equal to the amount of work done by you.

Maybe it is less than 5% or maybe it is a lot more. Something to think about and could be a rather fair set of terms to think about.

3
wall8OP•

That's an interesting idea, I also considered asking for a position in the new company in addition to equity.

Im just sort of lost with this kind of negotiating, it's very new to me. I don't want to get boned especially since I feel like I'll be doing just as much work as the 3 founders.

1
GaryARefuge•

There isn't really a standard. It's just like negotiating anything else.

What you think your value is VS what they think your value is. You reach a compromise and move forward. Or you don't reach a compromise and you peace out of there to find something worth your time.

There are certain legalities that have to be properly dealt with but, other than that it's just like anything else. Just be sure to use your own lawyer to go over the contract. Don't use theirs.

2
wall8OP•

The timeline is open ended. I don't foresee it being short term either based on the experience of the group(myself included).

2
askoruli•

So it seems like the majority of the risk is being dumped on your shoulders then. It's up to you to build something which is going to get investors on board while everyone else does a smaller amount of work.

The other founders may claim that while they're not doing much now they have skills that will come out when there's a prototype to show investors. This is a hard call to judge. It's easy to say these things but raising money is such a fickle activity that you can't really judge until it's done. Also many investors may look at the prototype and ask for xyz to be implemented before they'll jump in which can put the work back on your shoulders.

3
wall8OP•

I'm definitely ignorant to the business side which is why I'm hesitant to overestimate my value. But at this stage where there is no product, only plans, I think I'm putting more than 5% of the work in.

1
oalbrecht•

Are they paying you on top of the equity? If it's supposed to be a full-time position and they're not paying you then that sounds like a pretty terrible deal to me.

Also, how much work have they put into it already? You need to be very sure they're willing to put in the work to get it off the ground and not get bored and move onto something else.

4
wall8OP•

Its essentially a part time job with no pay right now. There has been very little actual work put into building the actual product.

1
depleteduraniumftw•

Think of equity as having roughly the same value as a jar of farts. Still motivated?

3
wall8OP•

Like 1 jar of fart per percentage equity?

3
hotroute•

As the first non co-founder employee in, 5% is a great deal. Most non co-founders won't see more than 2%. That's just a standard in most VC (valley style) startups.

However, if all they have is the idea...why are there three of them? Each co-founder needs to bring something to the table. If they have literally no capital, then something is off.

Someone usually should be the lead on getting some kind of capital to pay initial salaries to early employees along with a chunk of equity.

The founding team should NOT be homogenous in terms of skills and what they can bring to the table. If they are, then the company is screwed.

3
wall8OP•

They have no capital because it is just an idea and everyone has a full time job. I'm responsible for building the prototype that is going to be used to pitch to investors.

3
hotroute•

Yikes.

4
wall8OP•

Not single handedly of course. There are varying levels of technical ability between the four of us, however I have the most experience/ability.

I've been told that everyone will be chipping in equally, but with the skill sets that are being brought to the table i'm not sure how true that will end up being.

1
sleepicat•

Ask for a higher salary, even if it means giving up equity (which may never materialize).

3
wall8OP•

There is no salary at this point. Not until there is funding secured.

1
oalbrecht•

If it were me, I would expect at least 80% of my current salary plus equity (though I would be willing to reduce it to 2%).

3
mspStu•

you can look at it two ways. 5% of $0 is 0.. so you have nothing...

If it takes off 5% is pretty good for just putting up your skill set and time. I think I've seen people taking 1%.

2
sleepicat•

One tip: If you can afford $500 or so for a lawyer to look over your employment contract, do it. It will save you a lot of sweat and tears not to mention money in the long run. If you think you can't afford a lawyer now, consider that lawyer fees will be a lot more expensive to undo a bad contract than to avoid signing a bad one in the first place.

2
wall8OP•

I will definitely be doing this.

1
akvarelka•

5% is good for early stage employees, if they are paying you salary too and giving some good title (VP or so). If they don't you should be co-founder with equal share, voting rights, etc. If you're not just developer, but designing the who product too, hah, you should take more than 1/4 as three of them will bring value of one :)

From my personal experience, having few people who can't code and have full time job leads to nothing - in best case scenario one of them is actually doing something for business. So you'll end up doing everything yourself. Our setup like that failed a year ago after few months of development work. Guess who's the most upset?

2
Slidejoy•

Here is a link to Angelist's database. You can play with it to find salary/equity. Keep in mind that these are funded startups, so you should be getting more. Also, even though it's for employees, the stage is earlier so you should be getting more also. It can at least set the baseline.

Even if they say you're not a cofounder, you're a crucial piece of the puzzle. I think it will be hard for 3 non-technical cofounder to attract a technical person to work on something when they have full time jobs. That's a joke. And this is coming from a non-technical cofounder.

https://angel.co/salaries

Also, are these people you want to get in bed with? That's the most important question. Any issues you have now will be amplified in the future.

Hope this helps.

1