Pieces of the Theory...

Speculation

Hello hello! Hi! I'm a fairly new member of the FNAF community; I mainly joined because of the lore, and less so of the gameplay (my inner child still hasn't let me beat FNAF 1...). I've been following FNAF theories on and off for a little while now, and I've beeen trying to complete a few things in my head. One thing that stuck out to me was the suits and the victims they hold.

We know that Purple Guy's first victim was killed outside Fredbear Diner, and thus becomes the Puppet. That means that the FNAF 4 kid has to be Golden Freddy.

But then, we see the Puppet stuffing all of the dead kids into suits during the "Give Gifts, Give Life" minigame. And then immediately after that, we see the fifth child and Golden Freddy.

How can that be? To me at least, it might imply that the puppet created Golden Freddy and the original four animatronics all on the same day. And this slightly fits with FNAF 4, as we see the four bullies with masks of each animatronic stuffing the kid into the mouth of the Golden Fredbear animatronic.

So, maybe after the loss of the kid (his son, maybe?), Purple Guy killed all the kids and left the restaurant in rage/pain, leaving the Puppet to clean up after him? And assuming that Purple Guy is Phone Guy, and could manipulate the cameras, he might even make it appear like everything was fine on camera while he murdered the kids.

But at the same time, where is the puppet this entire time?

I think he might be Psychic Friend Fredbear. Only the FNAF 4 kid can hear him, and if he does manifest through a literal stuffed bear, it mirrors how he possesses the Puppet later on.

Also, the stripes on the FNAF4 kid's shirt could indicate that he has a connection to the Puppet, while not actually being the Puppet.

Sorry if this seems disjointed...I'm just throwing ideas out and hoping to find something that helps. I'd appreciate any and all feedback on my ideas: by all means rip them to shreds if I'm wrong. I just wanna help solve this mystery. :)

Posted Dec 2, 2015, 10:29 PM UTC

110
Loading comments…