New to collecting is this acceptable?
Posted Dec 3, 2015, 7:21 AM UTC
77
Posted Dec 3, 2015, 7:21 AM UTC
There was no mention of any fading.
No. Anything with that elitist, war mongering, Nazi bride is not acceptable.
Not acceptable at all. Stop wasting your money on graded numismatic crap and buy more silver not 'better' silver.
Stop wasting your money on graded bullion
Fixed it for you
Graded coins don't change grade on account of tarnish. The strike and surface features remain the same. Thus any graded coins really only have to be advertised as an MSxx/PFxx coin and if its slabbed it has been guaranteed. There are a variety of reasons a grade could fall a notch or two, so explanations for why it isn't a 70 aren't required. Even if it is a 70, it can still tarnish or milkspot, and this doesn't technically change the grade though it certainly ought make the coin less desirable and warrants a price differential. Toning like this may have been before/after grading. I generally think it is the decent thing to do to mention anything unusual with the coin. Sometimes these are bonuses, sometimes negative. I have a graded coin displaying some pitting which annoys the fuck out of me. Would have appreciated the heads up, but its likely why the coin is MS63 and thus maybe the rest of the surface details are even better and I picked up an otherwise MS65 coin. Depends on who you are and how distracting you find the fault, too, if it matters. Others are bonuses which will always be advertised because who wants to gloss over those? ie rainbow toning, etc.
They certainly can, but for somebody new to collecting, this is quite the rabbit hole to go down.
Essentially, coins with stunning eye appeal may get bumped a grade or so as a result. Coins with fugly toning might lose a point or so. Toning certainly can affect grade.
On a 70, I wouldn't want the toning in the OP, personally, but I'm not a modern guy at all, outside of my type two Ikes, I don't own a single coin graded after 1945.
[removed]