What would happen in the US if it made lobbying illegal?

Posted Dec 3, 2015, 11:32 PM UTC

18
fire-paul-johnson•

Redditors would be appalled in the name of free speech, because while they may not agree with what you have to say, they will fight to their death for your right to say it.

oh wait

oh fucking wait

2
englishichistnicht•

Catch 22

1
nschirmer•

Well now, there's a difference between companies being able to tell politicians what they'd like to see happen, versus bribing and giving them large sums of money to do exactly what they want, sometimes going against the politician's own beliefs because he knows if he doesn't take their offer, they'll support another politician instead and he could lose his position.

I don't really see this as a Catch 22 at all because it goes well beyond the idea of free speech.

1
fire-paul-johnson•

Sometimes I shitpost and then someone responds with an actual real argument. This is one of those times.

I was just saying it's funny how reddit obsesses over how speech can never be harmful ever and you should always be able to say whatever the fuck you want to whomever the fuck you want on whatever the fuck private platform you want or else it's evil censorship and no one will be there when they come for you, but here is an example where some laws would actually be helpful.

1
nschirmer•

I understand, reddit does act like that... my point though, which maybe you're admitting your post was irrelevant, was that buying politicians with money, paying to have laws pass, is different than being able to say whatever you want. It's like paying for sex, but with laws that affect everyone else.

Maybe some people argue that prostitution should fall under free speech though, I don't know. But I don't even think that's considered "speech."

1
fire-paul-johnson•

which maybe you're admitting your post was irrelevant

yes.

2
MrLoLMan•

Nothing? There might be a temporary change but I'm positive that it'll either be carried out quietly or another loopehole would be found.

1