jielingOP•

Sorry for the long wait, but something came up at the office, here is my R1:


The majority of those ships were built on the Clyde, with a handful built in Belfast or Bristol.

That is, until the US took over by 1950. The SS United States was built in Newport News.

It's extremely frustrating that Britain killed its Steel and Shipbuilding industries. The UK Made some of the best in the world, and from a quality perspective, was the main competitor for the US in terms of shipbuilding.

While shipbuilding is traditionally one of those industries which is often protected by subsidies and tariffs due to concerns about national security and other political aims, I don't really think you can make the case that Britain actively killed it's shipbuilding industry in any way shape or form. Like other countries it underwent tertiarization which despite resistance led to a relative decline of the industrial sector towards the service sector. This doesn't mean that there is no industrial base, just that productivity improvements lead to a reduction of employment in those sectors (for example).

Now who's America's biggest competitor for ship construction? Maersk. Denmark. The Odense Shipyard.

I'm pretty sure China, Japan and South Korea are the leading shipbuilders according to this. Notice that Japan is an extremely resource poor island nation with relatively high labor costs and a high GDP per capita

Now, Britain is buying steel manufactured on the other side of the ocean to build its own bridges, even though it has all the iron and coal it could possibly ask for. The massive, super-efficient, and clean steelworks have all been demolished and replaced with black-carbon filth houses in Asia that make really substandard steel. Prime among the old British Steelworks was Ravenscraig, which is still nothing more than a patch of wasteland.

Germany also tried to keep its dieing mining industry afloat with gigantic subsidies which are fortuantely now gone for the most part. Already in 1865 did William Stanley Jevons point out that the limiting factor is always the economically available resource, not the physically available one. Just because there is ore and coal doesn't make importing steel bad. I can't really speak to the quality of steel, but I assume that when a certain quality is required it can still be found and imported. Exporting factories to other countries is better than having to scrap them for being unprofitable, isn't it? Also selling your factories to asia reduces the carbon intensity there.

Britain destroyed its industrial infrastructure starting in 1979, with Thatcher's government. Look at what happened in 1980! Total stagnation with the assault on British heavy industry!

If you'd grown your industrial sector like the US did, instead of totally gutting it, your GDP would be 5 tn right now. Not 3. Look at our growth rate in that period compared to yours. It wasn't until Blair got into power that the British economy really started kicking again.

I have no idea how the industrial sector could have increased british GDP by 66% compared to today. If it were so profitable wouldn't it continued to exist and expand regardless? You can think of Thatcher what you will, but I find it hard to stomach that she is solely to blame for this shift.

If you put all your economic eggs in the financial services basket, you're at the mercy of the stock market when the economy falls apart.

If you put all of your economic eggs into the heavy industry basket, it falls apart when the economy falls apart, what does that even mean? The UK had a huge comparative advantage in the financial service sector that is due to a mix of existing companies, know-how and human capital, regulation, and market integration. In fact the expansion of the financial service sector is a return to the role the british economy had before the two world wars and the subsequent destruction of capital and relocation of financial services to NYC.

And what pisses me off is that we work so well together, the US and the UK, that the collapse of your industry hurt us. We used to compete for who made the best aircraft and aircraft engines in the world. It was national pride. Now it's British Aerospace, and they stand alone. The old names are gone. De Haviland. Vickers. Fairey.

And our companies have merged, but they still exist. Lockheed Martin. Boeing. McDonnell Douglas. Northrop Grumman. General Electric.

We're making stupid decisions about a lot of things over here, because hello, 'Murica, but whenever we did that in the past, we could count on British manufacturers who speak the same language we do moving in instantly and keeping us sharp through competition. You're 65 million who kicked us in the shins whenever we made the stupid decisions in the past. And we're making similar decisions now with worrying frequency.

Britain also doesn't build a lot of cars anymore because other countries became better. Competition can foster innovation, but it's not protection against "stupid decisions" whatever nebulous concept he is alluding to here. Again, what is the point in subsidizing dieing companies. And how would these subsidized and protected companies be a worthy competitor to keep others on their toes? When it is the case that they could not compete against other firms and are now out of business.

Except because you guys don't manufacture much anymore, it's not British companies moving in on the action. It's Russian and Chinese firms. And they're not nearly as reasonable when it comes to obeying American laws as you guys were.

American laws are enforced in america. And European laws are enforced in the EU. If a company wants to do business in a different company it has to comply with those laws or risk fines. This doesn't always work, depending on the monitoring and severity of enforcement, but Russian and Chinese companies also comply with laws if they want to have access to american markets. Most companies do not act like the manufacturer of Jin Ling cigarettes (read it, a very curious company and business model about russian made cigarettes with a chinese name. They are made to be smuggled into EU countries).

You've got one of the best educated workforces on the planet, you've got scientists, engineers, and a ton of money, you've got so many decent schools that you can't hardly walk through a British city without tripping over one of them, you've got plenty of natural resources and yet you don't build anything anymore. Nothing's built on the Clyde. The shipyards are almost entirely done. Greenock, the great warmwater port that made Glasgow the second city of the British Empire is a stopover for cruise ships now. The drydocks are all filled in.

These people are employed in other sectors where their qualifications are put to better use?

I know it's not your responsibility to keep us on top of our game, but I really don't understand why you guys just decided to stop having an industrial sector that kept up with ours.

As if the US is on top of their game industrially speaking. And as if it's the responsibility of other countries to keep up with other countries in every sector and not as whole economies. This whole comment is basically just one big fallacy of composition.

I don't understand why no one wants to breathe life into the dessicated husk that is British industry.

Because what's the point?

You guys kicked off the industrial revolution, and you've spent the last forty years refusing to fight to protect everything you've gained. You've shut everything, and let your market share get bought out by others.

And what is the thing that should be protected? Shouldn't it be the welfare of the economy and nation? How is massive protectionism and subsidies for a derelict industry achieving that, when all it does is burn capital that could be more effectively be spend on other endeavours. Not all industry has to look like giant shipyards and massive steel mills.

Industry can also be the production of high-tech medical tools. Or precision machined parts. Or all sorts of high value items in smaller companies that are able to leverage the comparative advantage to the fullest.

I really don't get it.

That much is clear

If someone could explain this to me, I'd be incredibly grateful.

I'd try but that whole thread is so full of badecon I feel like this barely scratched the surface.

15
ChornWork2•

I was fond of his cherry-picking of charting...

If you'd grown your industrial sector like the US did, instead of totally gutting it, your GDP would be 5 tn right now. Not 3. Look at our growth rate in that period compared to yours. It wasn't until Blair got into power that the British economy really started kicking again.

Alternative could compare US/UK GDP per capita with constant currency -- chart doesn't look so scary

8
jielingOP•

oh definitely! I copied the text of his comment into notepad to write my reply and the links got lost. But I had to facepalm pretty hard when I read those again. It's not like the US grew way way more in terms of population in the time referenced, right? Why do we use capital and output in labor indexed form again?

6
hughk•

And the Baltic Dry is what at the moment? The shipping industry has a massive over supply of cargo tonnage and that problem will remain for the intermediate future. Some specialised ships continue to be built (super efficient, etc) but that market is small.

4
vomitingVermin•

Like other countries it underwent tertiarization which despite resistance led to a relative decline of the industrial sector towards the service sector.

This is so true. In the US in the eighties, most young people wanted to go into white collar fields like finance and tech. Who the hell would want to work in an auto plant with such great alternatives? Even a Tom Cruise movie character got a scholarship to Cal Poly, out of the rust belt factory town he was trapped in. Also, Volcker's hard dollar policies did a lot to kill the rust belt along with inflation. I imagine the UK was going through similar changes.

4
124876720•

You could also mention that Maersk closed Odense Staalskibsværft four years ago and replaced it with an industrial park which produces more specialized components.

Also, IIRC, the EU has been doing some pretty extensive research into revitalizing manufacturing using new technologies. We'll see what fruit that bears.

Finally, Ferguson Shipbuilders at the Port launched the hybrid ferry Catriona last Friday, have secured a £12m contract, and are planning to expand the yard to 400 employees in the future. Scottish shipbuilding is slowly getting back on its feet, but that doesn't mean it could have competed when it went bust.

3
ucstruct•

Now who's America's biggest competitor for ship construction? Maersk. Denmark.

This is incredibly wrong, the US is nowhere near the top in shipbuilding. It's 10th, and both China and South Korea shipbuilding production is more than 70 times as high in terms of tonagge.

We used to compete for who made the best aircraft and aircraft engines in the world.

I'm pretty sure its between GE, P & W, and Rolls Royce to this day.

You guys kicked off the industrial revolution, and you've spent the last forty years refusing to fight to protect everything you've gained. You've shut everything, and let your market share get bought out by others.

Yeah, they shut down lower wage industries for more profitable high wage industries. How is this a bad thing?

8
centurion44Milton spoke to me from a burning treasury note•

I'm pretty sure its between GE, P & W, and Rolls Royce to this day.

Naw bruh, theres this dope aeronautical firm in Malaysia that makes engines now.

2
MrDannyOceanpenguin economist•

WUMBO COMIN'

7
jielingOP•

He didn't even come :( here I am, hoping for some snark in the comments and nothing happened!

2
jielingOP•

Rule I after my Spanish class is over amigos!

2
SnapshillBotPaid for by The Free Market™•

Snapshots:

  1. This Post - 1, 2

^(I am a bot.) ^(Info ^/ ^Contact)

1