Why do you guys use Plex for your movies instead of just itunes?

A few days ago I downloaded the despecialized versions os the Star Wars movies, dropped them into itunes under home movies, went into the options and added the cover art and changed the category to "movies" and now they appear with the other legitimate movies. I was able to watch them on my Apple TV without a hitch. What am I missing?

Posted Dec 14, 2015, 7:41 PM UTC

231
hungarianhc•
  1. Plex allows a variety of formats (xVid, h.264, h.265, and more)
  2. Plex allows you to store your movie collection on a separate server. I have almost 900 movies and lots of TV shows. There's no room for that on my laptop.
  3. Plex allows you to stream your content from any device in any location. I have been on the other side of the world with my iPhone, and I can immediately stream my home library. I can even plug in my iPhone via lighting AV adaptor / Airplay to get the movies on the TV.
  4. Plex allows my to selectively sync content to my iPad / iPhone for flights. I don't need to store all my movies on my phone, but if there are a couple I want to watch, I can put them on. It will actually re-encode the file to a lower res format for me, if I like, rather than just copy the whole thing.
  5. Active development. We get major iTunes updates about once a year. The Plex guys make updates to the server / variety of clients every few days.
  6. The UI in plex may not be perfect, but iTunes has become one of the most cumbersome programs out there.
  7. Variety of clients / no lock-in. I love Apple, and I live primarily in an Apple world, but I like not being locked in. Plex makes clients out there for pretty much every platform. We have a TiVo Roamio, and we use the Plex app on there to watch a lot of our content, for example. My parents use the Roku plex app.

Those are just some of the reasons off the top of my head. There are more.

23
parttimehuman2OP•

Thanks, man. Very informative.

4
alllmossttherrre•

I went Plex for many of the same reasons. But one big reason is that I have a lot of content in formats collected over the years and iTunes won't deal with without time-consuming transcoding, but I could load them into Plex and they play right away.

Also, as much as I like Apple, iTunes has become difficult to manage. If Plex was worse and iTunes was better, I might be using iTunes. But the problem is that Plex is pretty good and iTunes has been going downhill, so the balance tips to Plex.

The openness has been a big draw, knowing that in the future I can easily migrate the media to a simple NAS as the server, and that I can play back on non-Apple devices or just a web browser.

1
TrancePhreak•

Not all movies are in a format iTunes accepts. Plex has other capabilities that are nice as well (like saving local on an iPhone, etc).

15
MojoMercury•

You know you can sync content to iOS devices through iTunes.

-1
mredofcourse•

Right, but there's a difference here. Suppose I have a huge library at home or on a seed box. With Plex, I can download a file (or stream) from anywhere via Plex pretty much regardless of format or platform.

3
jeffbenjam•

Blu Ray rips look way better than iTunes Store purchases. Dat bitrate.

7
StevesRealAccount•

You can play movies locally with iTunes just fine, although I don't know what it does for/about DRM.

What you can't do (yet) is stream movies from anywhere. With a Plex server set up, I can connect to my home Plex server from anywhere in the world and stream any movie in my collection to a computer or mobile device.

5
parttimehuman2OP•

oh got it. That's pretty cool.

3
ZESTYTACOSAUCE•

Quick question. I got plex a bit back, set it up, but haven't really used it since. If my main server is my MacBook, does that have to be on to access the server on other devices?

2
idlephase•

Yes, the server has to be on.

8
ZESTYTACOSAUCE•

Gotcha thanks

0
StevesRealAccount•

Yes it does (to my knowledge, at least - probably worth asking in r/Plex where there will be people who are far better experts than I).

1
BrownsFanZ•

How do you get the correct address for it? Do you have a static ip?

2
TrancePhreak•

It uses a login system. I've never had to set up an IP with it, but I do use the same login and everything shows up.

3
BrownsFanZ•

Oh yeah, don't know why I forgot about that. So I'm guessing you use the paid version?

1
MojoMercury•

No it's part of having an account. I know j don't play but can login and stream.

2
TrancePhreak•

Nope, I don't have a paid account. There's really a lot of functionality before you have to pay. The only thing is some platforms require payment to work (like Xbox One), although DLNA works there anyways.

1
solefald•

Because I am not going to plugin my MacBook into the TV every time I want to watch a move. Both of my TV's have a native Plex client.

2
TheyCallMeKP•

Streaming (with on the fly transcoding) outside your network is the biggest feature IMO

2

I use it for my friends libraries mostly.

1
jeff-the-exploder•

I keep planning to switch to Plex, but my $100 craigslist MacMini iTunes Server just keeps rocking. DRM is not an issue, and I can stream to any device in the house. No monthly costs either like with Plex Pass.

Don't get me wrong, I'm a big Plex fan and will probably switch once I get an AppleTV4.

1
lvlegabyte•

I dislike using iTunes for one, I dislike it's UI and it feels like it's trying too hard to be automated which restricts options I'd like to have as well as bloated. But I also rip my DVDs and Blu-ray into Lossless MKV files which last I checked (long time ago, could be different now) is unsupported. I also like using Plex on my android devices, chromecast as well as my Apple devices flawlessly.

1
aldrinjtauro•

Because I repurposed an older computer into a NAS with OMV Debian. Plex makes it easy to stream stuff to multiple brands of devices and can transcode unsupported formats automatically.

1
vhalen50•

For the plex app on my Xbox one upstairs. Silky smooth streaming with an extremely attractive UI.

1
RockstarGTA6•

You can let other people watch your movies with plex Other people not in your house , I get the movies and my family enjoys watching new movies for free

1
tornsouls•

Becauae I rip my blurays to MKVs.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
yoloswegs•

I tried Plex and disliked it. I have stuck with iTunes Home Sharing for years, its been the best thing for me yet. What really makes it is the app iFlicks 2

0
v8xd•

Is there even a good reason to use itunes nowadays?

0