Declined + 1* vs No Rating at all

With the seemingly endless influx of newbies that have no clue what "value" is, would you rather have them "1* you" because of a horrible (but FUN!) counter-offer then have you decline and move on?

Once you get to a certain level of number of ratings, i think it's better to pile on some more feedback, even if it's 1* then it is to have none at all.

Thoughts?

Posted Dec 17, 2015, 12:12 AM UTC

25
Lachryma_ud•

With blind trades I get I try to counter some amount of them to try to teach them to trade base for base. However most of them tend to time out which is discouraging.

2
ComoKhaozoitek•

I typically use ignore

2
PretzelThins6•

There hasn't been a mutual attempt at dealmaking until counter or convo. I tend to counter.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Rinneeeeegimme your TKs•

I just started last week, and now I have 7 TKs, a few inserts and a few golds. I can't believe I offered white base for a 1000cc insert.

My first offer ever was rated 1*. Now I'm running at 107 trades with 4.6/5. Sometimes though there's this asshole who'd say "Hoarding all white x. 1:1 any white card" and once you offer him his hoard and take your hoard he declines and rates 1 star. This has happened to me around 5 times already.

1
jainaskyJAINASKY•

I've been getting traders like that. One white card for either Finn monogram, a specific Boba Fett or bb8 card. Since the requests are so specific and it's always a 1* rating trader I think it's someone trying to take advantage there's no way that many people are looking for those exact 3 cards each time when they just started today and have no ratings and I rarely post on the feeds lately.

I just decline and set to ignore.

1