Santa without the reindeer carriage?

*This question is for everyone but especially people who think that veganism makes sense.

*I recently came across a Christmas post depicting a Santa running on foot to deliver gifts with a caption on the lines of "Santa drops his animal driven carriage , lets the animals free and his fat, meanwhile getting rid of his BP problem and his diabetes while bringing you gifts."

*I understand the fitness part of it, and I am completely pro-non-violence, but there seems to be something wrong with letting the animals free logic.. and when I thought more about it there seemed something not very strong in the not having animal dairy logic.. Since if vegans would have it, we would not eat any cereal/pulses in any form until agriculture is highly advanced(eco friendly) and mechanized (does not involve animals). That in turn requires a high level of R & D resources in the country. We all know how the countries who got rich, got rich.(I am generalizing, but not without reason) So that in turn requires blood-shed and loot. The logic seems flawed doesn't it?

*Unless we grow our own food, and do not travel in cars(/ambulances included) or use any form of advanced tech, we're indirectly supporting/using the products of violence?

Posted Dec 26, 2015, 5:13 AM UTC · edited

025
Hellishnoob•

If only I could understand your stream of consciousness.

Unless we grow our own food, and do not travel in cars(/ambulances included) or use any form of advanced tech, we're indirectly supporting/using the products of violence?

Kind of.

9
fishy2OP•

I am so sorry for being obscure. I have tried to explain it better in the reply to the other comment. Sorry. If you'd like I'd copy and paste it here. Just thought it'd be redundant.

2
OCDFood•

We don't have to get rid of all technology that ever caused suffering, we would literally go back to foraging if that were the case. Instead, take our current technological advances, cease the animal usage, and make do with what we got. The state we're in right now I believe we can research whatever technology we could need without undo suffering.

It's good to think about all the minute interconnections of everything, but this is a step too much - if we stop using cars, the suffering to research the cars doesn't go away, it already happened. If we are more careful to not hit animals with our cars, that can reduce suffering and thus does matter (not that that is even feasible, but that's another discussion).

9
mithrasinvictus•

Using cars, or buying products that were shipped using fossil fuels still poisons the atmosphere. Animals still died for your food. Even if we switched everything to renewables, animals would die from mechanical harvesting and on the windshields of transport vehicles.

2
OCDFood•

Yes I agree that driving and buying things that are shipped are bad for the environment and thus for animals. However, much less suffering happens with veg*nism than without. The only way to get rid of the suffering that you're talking about is if everyone homesteads and the world is vastly overpopulated for that. Making do with what you got and trying to bend the world ever closer is better than refusing to get closer to the end goal because it isn't completely philosophically sound.

2
bobodod•
1
fishy2OP•

But the fact is that there are currently countries without the resources to implement eco friendly tech and by wanting to use advanced tech(because as vegans we don't want to use animals for our sake and for agriculture we need animals if we are lacking in advanced tech) we are encouraging them to follow in the footsteps of those with the tech. Therefore we are either being unfair to a large populace of the world by demanding that everyone be vegan AND animal domestication (use) be ceased then this populace will be left with nothing to eat.

Ask the rich countries if they'd be willing to share the loot and plunder of many centuries with the whole world and NOT DONATE(because that is mere rerouting of resources - read "Confessions of an economic hitman")-so everyone has the resources to implement advanced tech- been years since they've had it but they have not. If you look at the case of India - where I come from - farmers commit suicide everyday because of lack of resources.
Of course it makes sense to not directly kill/torture animals - but does it make sense to not use animals for advancement of humans? That logic seems flawed. In fact, it seems if you can use animals without being cruel and if you are not to greedy you save the world decades of plunder and loot which will then lead to you being technologically advanced and 'vegan'.

1
Hellishnoob•

What kind of advanced tech you are talking about? Harvesting machines, pesticides, fertilizers? It's not rocket science. It can be shared and sold, and farmers in developing world are going to use it anyway if they want to increase their yields.

FFS, no one demands people in developing countries to live by a standard made by people in developed countries. First and foremost, we aim for the cruelest form of animal exploitation—factory farming. We want people with the same capabilities as we have to go vegan. We, people in developed countries, should not use animals because WE CAN. Those who can't and have to do it to survive aren't the people we are aiming to convince, aren't the people we judge for not being vegan. No one demands those people to starve or to stop their progress. They are free to decide that on their own though, but veganism doesn't imply that we should force them to do it.

You are strawmanning here. You haven't read the definition of veganism and call 'that logic' flawed, while you are the only one who follows that logic. The definition of veganism clearly states that one excludes animal exploitation as far as possible and practicable. If you can't, you don't. You are free to call yourself vegan if you are using animals when it's the only way to survive, if you are still trying to avoid cruelty. By definition, people in developing countries who can't live without using (even eating) animals, if they have the intention on not being cruel to animals and to avoid unnecessary exploitation, CAN BE CALLED VEGANS.

Veganism is a personal decision, lifestyle, philosophy, not a political ideology. We don't force anyone to follow it, don't make laws, don't discriminate based on it. How the hell we are being unfair when we don't knock at the doors of people in developing countries and don't DEMAND them to go vegan?

Veganism has context. This context is our life in developed world. We don't demand african tribes to value human rights, we don't demand animals in the wild to not rape other animals. We have more power and a capability of moral reasoning, thus we have more responsibilities.

2
fishy2OP•

*I like your definition. Makes sense.

*I am a little uncomfortable with the last line you wrote.

*Just one addition. If a person is vegan and wants to protect animals-and they can-since they have the power and the resources - wouldn't they want to share their resources - so others can too? This is rather rhetorical - the point is - do they?

*Listen I'm not fighting with you - this is not personal-I'm thinking about the concept of veganism.

1
Hellishnoob•

If a person is vegan and wants to protect animals-and they can-since they have the power and the resources - wouldn't they want to share their resources - so others can too?

Of course they would. Sounds absolutely reasonable.

Listen I'm not fighting with you - this is not personal-I'm thinking about the concept of veganism.

I took it personally, because it is what I believe in, and it sounded from you like veganism doesn't make sense from the very first line. Sorry for overreacting, though.

1
AlbertoAru•

Just 2 points:

  1. Veganism avoid the use of animals so exploiting animals to pull your cart doesn't seem a very good way to respect them.
  2. Veganism is incredibly good but not a panacea, you are going to keep killing animals since you walk on ants and other insects and you can't avoid it but there's a lot of more kind of animal exploitations that you can avoid. There's a Bite Size Vegan video about being 100% vegan, probably you'd like to check it out.
3
fishy2OP•

I will check out the video. Thanks. About your first point - this is exactly the point I'm making - to avoid using animals you need to be technologically advanced, for that you need to be a rich nation, and to be a rich nation you need to do all sorts of violent and unfair things. Therefore, is no animal use really a sustainable objective at all?

1
AlbertoAru•

This is not about being sustainable, this is about respecting the lives of living breathing sentient beings.

About tech, ask r/vegan, we are 60k users there

1
mithrasinvictus•

Spoiler alert: Santa's reindeer are fictional characters and not living breathing sentient beings.

5
AlbertoAru•

Oh C'mon man!! you have destroyed my childhood!! I'm gonna tell mom!!

3
fishy2OP•

Yes, and respecting these sentients' lives sustainably. Because nobody's going to save these lives if in the process you cease to survive. I don't understand why you did not like the word sustainable. I think you would like everyone to respect other lives, continuously over time.

1