Can't decide.

Got a new job a few months ago been saving up and think it's time I get my own car. I can borrow family car if need be so wanted something fun and nice as opposed to just a commuter car but still want something I could drive everyday.

Was thinking of a new Subaru WRX, but was looking at some used lots and dealers and saw I could get a fairly low mileage newish bmw for a similar price that would obviously have a much nicer interior, and similar or better performance. But I just get worried about insuring and maintaining one, everyone tells me I'll get a moneypit buying a bmw. I mean for the same price range as a new wrx, I could get a 2008 M3 which ok is fairly old now but it's a V8, a bmw, and just nicer in every way, or even a 2014 M235, although that would be an automatic.

Or I could just go cheap, could get a Ford Focus ST for about $17000, or a Subaru BRZ for about $16000, but both are slow, the focus is ugly and garish, but I hear they're still both really fun to drive, and I'm assuming cheaper to maintain and insure than the BMWs or even a WRX. Plus I probably wouldn't be paranoid as hell about parking them anywhere and could maybe work on them myself without ruining the value for not having dealer service which seems to be of importance with BMWs.

Basically, just want something fun, not gonna make me paranoid financially(I could afford any, so long as maintenance doesn't become ridiculous on say the M3), Could go as high as about $32,000 or so, but ideally under $24000 unless I love the car, still gotta take test drives.

Random question, would a used dealer get pissed or annoyed if I want to test drive multiple vehicles? There's a lot that has basically all the cars I'm interested in but dunno if they'd just think I'm out for joy rides if I wanted to look at multiple cars.

Posted Jan 7, 2016, 2:38 AM UTC

53
Awkward-Bear•

If a dealer gets pissed at you for wanting to test drive more then one car, invite them to suck on your balls and then you should leave.

5
streetlightnings•

I have the new WRX, it's a great car, obviously isn't as luxurious as a BMW but it'll probably give you less headaches down the road if you're looking to keep the car. Otherwise, I'd go with the M235i, fantastic car, although it's about 6+ k over your price range, and it doesn't really sound like you can(should) afford it. The '08 M3 is a great car but it's a 8 year old BMW, if you're mechanically inclined it might not be that bad, otherwise...

BRZ is both way slower and less useful than the other cars. I think hatches look stupid so I can't contribute on the Focus ST.

Regardless of whether or not a dealer "should" let you test drive multiple cars, if you dress somewhat decently they'll probably let you, the models you're looking at aren't anything too special.

3
VoiceInsideOP•

I hate hatches too, the focus is last on my list but heard it was a good driving car. And the brz is nice but ya idk if I'd even enjoy it since there's no good driving roads anywhere close to me so a slow car meant for handling doesn't sound too promising.

The 235 was listed online for $32000 which i could do the financing and insurance for just worried about maintenance. But they took the price down so maybe it was a mistake or some kinda ruse.

1