r/2007scape•
mallocer

Something to keep in mind when balancing blood/soul xp rates

The experience rates of blood and soul runecrafting are, understandably, a hot topic right now. Lots of people are doing trial hours, tracking xp through OSBuddy, and posting the results after 1 hour.

However, there is an important caveat to keep in mind when using xp tracking tools: the internal timer usually starts when you first gain exp. For blood/soul runecrafting, there is a significant delay between the start of training and this moment. The timer would start naturally when you turn your first inventory of dense essence blocks into dark essence, though some people reset it just before crafting for the first time at the blood or soul altars. However, these two start times occur approximately 2:45 and 6:45 after beginning to mine the first inventory of dense blocks.

In a 60 minute tests, these "pre-xp" times introduce significant bias. A method that is truly 45k/h would be observed to be 47.1k/h and 50.1k/h respectively, while a method that is 38k/h would be observed to be 39.7k/h and 42.3k/h respectively.

Granted, people are getting above these xp rates in hour-long tests and beating the corresponding xp/h increases for longer periods of time. But it's important to keep these biases in mind when thinking about potential kneejerk nerfs; for example, if Jagex assumed at face value that souls maxed at 53k/h and tried to nerf them down to 45k/h, the true xp rate would end up lower than the polled value.

Jagex should reevaluate the xp rates themselves, using a timer starting from the moment a character starts mining essence blocks, or take the effect I detailed above into account when considering player-submitted xp rates.


That concludes my point, but I wanted to list all the other pros/cons of the current xp rates for completeness (since people will inevitably bring these up as arguments in isolation):

  • Bloods/souls are more afk than other training methods - this is true, and they form a new end of the APM gradient (lavas >> abyss nats > astrals >> bloods/souls). However, it's really only the mining that is very afk (60% of total time spent for souls); the running and chiseling APM is similar to other non-lava runecrafting methods, and comes at fixed intervals (2:15 to mine 25 essence blocks). It's not quite the same as traditional afking where you check back periodically.

  • These methods are much less cash/hr than double astrals or double nats at similarly high requirements (77 and 90 vs. 82 and 91). Lavas are a level 23 training method and remain the fastest exp; there is room for high-level methods that are semi-competitive in experience and have other perks (less APM/reliance on hotkeys, mildly profitable).

  • It is always expected that perfect clicking will yield a higher xp rate than what is commonly listed or accepted as a reasonable max xp rate. For example, the EHP for lavas is 60k/hr, but people regularly do 65-67k lava hours.


Edit: I think people are getting caught up in the middle section and the afk issue. I agree the afking with souls is significant - 60% of total time - and is probably similar for bloods as well, and that there should be a rework to shift more of the total time onto running/chiseling/etc. But my primary purpose of this post was to point out the xp rate measuring discrepancies. Others have gone more in-depth about the afk level being a little too much.

Posted Jan 8, 2016, 12:48 AM UTC · edited

7441
VonDukes•

Lol, everyone calls zeah trash xp, yet want to nerf the only decent xp it gives. Go figure.

89
clowntears•

good xp rates --> "devaluing muh achievements"

bad xp rates --> "omgg dead content jagex"

there's no pleasing everyone

40
The_Bronze_Scrub•

Sure but at least if they somewhat favour the second demographic they can make updates, the first probably wouldn't be happy with anything.

7
clowntears•

I agree, I don't think new content should be limited based on a few player's accomplishments.

4
Toon-World•

Because they stated Zeah wasn't going to offer the best methods of training. Some things on Zeah need buffs (almost everything from the looks of it) and some need nerfs. Not that hard to understand.

1
Thelatestart•

books were 100K/hr that was good. it got patched. idgaf about souls being 60K/hr that they are at max if people do those instead of nats/astrals more gp for me

0†
Roonskape•

They said it would be a high-effort runecrafting method, and it's clearly not seeing you can AFK so much, that's why people are upset about it

0
OSRS_Final•

They never said the activity itself would be high effort. They said you would be able to get the polled xp rates if you took a high effort approach to it.

I wasn't getting the polled xp rate for bloods because I wasn't using the abyss and didn't use staminas, for example. I suppose that would be low effort.

4
WUMIBOCor blimey mate, what are ye doing in me pockets?•

There's nothing wrong with the current rates. You can start crafting bloods at level 77 so let's start there. Your options until 82 are lavas for the fastest xp and loss of gp, nats/laws/deaths for slow xp with some money, single astrals for faster xp than nats/laws/deaths with lower profit, and bloods for decent xp and some profit. Nats and maybe laws/deaths will be more gp/h than bloods, but bloods are significantly more xp with comparable profit. Single astrals are less xp and gp(?) p/h, so bloods trump that method. Nats, laws, and deaths are typically a pre-75 method, so there's not much being devalued by bloods here. The most viable options for 77-82 are clearly bloods for some profit, or lavas for loss of gp and significantly more xp/h. Personally, I think lavas take the cake for 75-82. Now you're at double astrals, just over 30k xp/h and about 1m gp/h. Or, you can do bloods for a little more xp and less than half the profit p/h. Neither of those negate each other and both are perfectly viable methods, I personally think double astrals are a better choice. Your next milestones will be souls at 90, and double nats at 91. You have a gap of 82-90/91 where double astrals and blood runes are perfectly viable methods for a combination of xp and profit, lavas still being the fastest xp with loss of gp. Souls and double nats share the same relationship as bloods and double astrals do. People complain about souls being too close to lavas in xp/h, but, the only area I see this being a problem is 90-91 rc. Lavas are not typical for a post 91 (now 90) method. Sure, if you want to rush 99 rc, but, the general consensus I can gather from high leveled runecrafters is to switch to double nats at 91 and if you do lavas post 91 you're in a small minority. Now, the viable methods for 91-99 rc are souls for more xp and far, far less gp/h than double nats which are far more gp/h and like half the xp/h. I don't think any old methods are being devalued, while new and viable methods have been added, which I think was the goal for Zeah and I personally think they nailed the runecrafting aspect. For reference, I'm 83 runecrafting.

24
Ejolu•

Eloquently put sir. Thats exactly how I think about it too.

3
IRL_im_black•

Unrelated, but I think you should use paragraphs, it's a bit more enjoyable to read that way imo.

1
WUMIBOCor blimey mate, what are ye doing in me pockets?•

Yeah sorry I just kind of go on a rant without thinking about it haha

2
zeahsucks•

I think they're great where they are right now. They give iron men a reasonable method of rcing rather than playing zulrahscape for months on end. Also for mains it is a great alternative which is still alot slower than lava's but has a good afk feel without being too afk.

22
flykiddy•

Can you mine essense near a bank or something now? Not too familiar with it. Thanks

1
My_wifii•

Its a new type of essence called dark essence.

1
brycekk•

Leave runecrafting alone, fix necro spell book, make ensouled items untradable(we need a prayer method that WONT be funded/farmed by bots.) so that i can get more then 2k prayer exp a task while at the same time they take away my ability to use high alch.

13
ADA_Novak•

RC as is on 07 is absolute aids, adding afkable methods to a game whos main draw is being afkable is good

13
monsterhunter445IGN: Lord Snoke•

I agree with you wholeheartedly.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
BoulderFalcon•

There is a huge difference between less click intensive and "Afkable."

Afkable is Runespan, and that did kill runecrafting, and absolutely devalued it. Adding some mining is not the same, though.

-1
n0thinglasts•

If you don't like it don't train it.

-5†
Zarchim•

If you don't like something don't complain about it.

Basically what you're saying.

1
yotecayotesince 2009•

Soul runecrafting may be slightly better xp and more afk than double nats, but remember, double nats are far more profitable as souls start to crash. This balances the two methods, and seeing as this is the only useful skilling method on Zeah right now, there is no reason for it to be worth. I'm sorry your runecrafting cape won't make you look as special now crybabies.

5
iChecky•

The poll said HIGH EFFORT and these rates are easily achievable while being afk.

2†
SlayHelm#Stud•

A totally selfish opinion, but I dislike the fact that people can afk RC (it is afk, you can't deny it, it's not even comparable to real RC) for pretty good xp/hr (remember the days when 26k xp/h training RC was good) and while doing this they profit, meanwhile people who did lavas spend 100s of hours doing much more click intensive RC and spent money on it (upto 4-5gp/xp at one point?) for what seems to be not too much more xp/hr...

2†
RaleurFrancais•

just because it was absolutely horrible to train before doesn't mean it should stay that way

-1
SlayHelm#Stud•

That's pretty much like saying why not add bonfires and runespan, just because a skill is difficult why should it stay difficult.

Nice fucking logic

2
RaleurFrancais•

No, that's saying that this skill is too retarded to train for most people, why not make it slightly more user friendly. Not necessarily totally broken.

Nice fucking logic

0
SlayHelm#Stud•

How is it retarded? Tons of people have 99, someone (and soon multiple people) has 200m rc, it's a fine skill, it's just low xp/hr and requires more focus than fletching. If you don't like rc then don't do it, don't ask for soul runespan.

1
Reap3rXD•

91 is the highest level needed for a diary/quest, after double nats its just bragging rights anyways, I don't see why they would make it easier to 99.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
syluks•

Just wait 'til people realize its like 5k mining xp/h too which gives just as much EHP

1
RuneMystery•

what about they make the mining process shorter (get the blocks faster) and reduce the xp per block? this way you will have to do more runs per hour wich means more effort

1
renyzen99/99•

Honestly I'm fine with less intense but less exp/hr content like MLM and the new RC methods. The more casual players get to play more relaxed while the hardcore ones can still do the really intense methods for max exp/hr.

0
SWMangerino•

I like the last point of yours, so many people comparing Lavas on 60k/h to the absolute max of souls, should compare it to the max on Lavas as well then, i.e. 67k'ish.

Also when posting xp/h of souls, at least do 5 hours or more, the first few hours are heavily influenced by the startingminutes.

0
Ejolu•

Also not to mention any boost in exp/hr received by using ahk/mousekeys should NOT be counted towards the maximum exp rates. Since even Jagex themselves have stated you risk being banned if you're using these programs.

-1
n0thinglasts•

Needs to be nerfed hard. Afk needs to go where you click for every ess and the exp needs to be lowered.

-4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
muktheduck•

Let's be real here - its an osrs version of runespan. Less xp but more profit (compared to runespan). About as afk. It completely devalues the skill.

-5†
Ninja802•

It's not even close to runespan LMFAO

5
Lnfinite_godsup•

they said it would be 45k/hr and would be click intensive. It's 50k+ and afkable. So it should be click intensive and 45k/hr like they said. If they wanna create afkable rc that's 50k+/hr, they should poll that.

-8
mallocerOP•

My point isn't that they shouldn't nerf it down to the intended 45k exp/hr rate. Jagex has said they will do so if they find it necessary, and I agree that they should. My only point is that people are claiming souls are 50-54k/hr, but the measurement techniques in use are overestimating the exp by 2-5k/hr. The nerf needed for soul runes is something in the range of 5-10% of current exp, but the measuring artifacts of a single hour of OSBuddy's exp tracker could indicate a nerf as large as 20% of current exp, which would make the max xp lower than the polled value. The same thing holds true for blood runes, with slightly different numbers.

Jagex's response about a possible nerf focused solely on the xp rate, so I didn't want to go too in-depth on the AFK issue in the main post. For what it's worth, I agree that the mining portion of bloods/souls is unexpectedly AFK, though the running around/chiseling is roughly analogous to the running/pouch handling of other rc methods. It is by far the most AFK of major runecrafting methods; the closest thing to it is double nats with tai bwo teles. Bizarrely, the Jagex employees seem surprised when people bring this up with them on Twitter; they point to the dark essence, chiseling, and altar running as evidence that these runes aren't AFK, though the mining part is a huge percentage of the time and very AFK.

So I think Jagex meant really did mean for these runes to be "high effort" crafting - but then they plopped down the normal rune essence mining mechanics and ruined it. But this is more of a grey area than the exp rate, where we can quantify the difference between proposed and actual exp rates and come up with the right nerf number. I think people would rather see a less AFK method at the correct 45k exp/hr than a still very AFK method at 40-42k exp/hr, which is what will happen if Jagex only looks at the feedback in a cursory fashion.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1