Lady Gaga beat Kirsten Dunst for the Golden Globe... BULLSHIT

I watch both shows and Kirsten was by far the better performance. Im very upset!

Posted Jan 11, 2016, 2:47 AM UTC

477127
chefjl•

It's just a golden globe, hon. We gotta go.

436
jeric13xd•

Don't worry, hon. You'll get the Emmy

64
malyfsborin88•

OK then...

15
HannibalFannibal•

OKthen...

2
ReadyToSquareUp•

Pacman Jones?

-2
frahm9•

And for what? A little bit of gold.

4
briastkam•

Regardless, I think we all know that American Horror Story and Fargo aren't even close to the same level of TV.

151
toomuchpork•

Not to mention this season of AHS and this season of Fargo

68
tgcg•

*Any season of Fargo

57
dmacb54•

IMO there hasn't been a season of AHS worth watching since Season 2.

29
WildCatWildCat•

Oh man Asylum. I'd erase my memory of that show just to watch it again. Those twists were great.

16
LorneMalvoGirl•

AHS is for people with extremely low IQ's.

-10†
dmacb54•

Seasons 1 and 2 were alright. Not even close to Fargo, but they were enjoyable.

19
R8iojak87•

Hey! I watch that show lol. But it's not near as good as fargo :)

6
grumblebuzz•

I watch them both and I consider myself a pretty intelligent individual; however, one is dumb, mindless, gory fun and the other is serious, thought-provoking prestige television. One deserves awards; the other doesn't.

12
_TheRedViper_•

I really like Fargo and agree that it is miles ahead of AHS, but i wouldn't call it "thought-provoking" tbh.
Can you elaborate on that point?

3
grumblebuzz•

The stories just provoke a lot of thought and dissection in me, particularly viewing the characters choices from my own moralistic standpoint. Like what would I do if I were in the shoes of average people like Lester Nygard or Peggy Blumquist, caught up in this escalating shitstorm that I started purely by accident? How would I react?

Also, sometimes just the little things in Fargo keep me thinking about the show long after an episode ends. What did a look that a character gave another mean? Is something oddly out of place in a scene possibly symbolic of something? How will a cryptic comment from a character possibly play into something else later on? etc.

10
LorneMalvoGirl•

Fine, AHS is predominantly for people who have no standards when it comes to TV or film. They lack the ability to identify a good story, cinematography and direction. Place these same people in front of Fargo and their minds would wander.* You're an exception! * I've seen it first hand, I watched Fargo season 1 episode 1 with three of my friends, who love AHS, and they didn't understand what was going on, lacked concentration and preferred checking their phones every 5 minutes. :(

-12
matty_a7•

i enjoy good story, cinematography and direction and still watch AHS. I don't think it's anywhere near the level of Fargo, Game of Thrones, the Americans etc.. But I can sometimes watch a show that lacks some of those aspects and still be generally entertained. I don't have to watch all tv with such a critical eye.. Sometimes there's nothing wrong with watching a show that is just entertaining and not structurally perfect. That said, I think this current season is stupid and really only enjoyed the first two seasons. Plus, I only really started watching because my gf was watching it and it was a show we could watch together that I can tolerate.

5
WinStark•

I know lots of people who love both shows. It's not mutually exclusive.

4
grumblebuzz•

I've discovered over my years as a fan of AHS that the fan base is filled primarily with what I refer to as "TV adrenaline junkies." They don't really care about story or character development and are mostly just in it for the "WOAH! THAT'S FUCKED UP!" factor. As a matter of fact, when there are too many straight dramatic scenes or too much story-building set up, they complain at the top of their fingertips to any internet forum that they can of being "bored." It's a shame because there have actually been some really great actors, portraying really poignant characters and story arcs throughout the series, but more and more as the seasons go by, it becomes less about those things and more about the outrageousness because that's what the fans so vocally want. Without Jessica Lange there to make Ryan Murphy reign it in and keep it somewhat credible, I give them one or two more seasons before it becomes too stupid for me to even watch anymore as a guilty pleasure.

1
MrWinklestein•
11
Daevar•

Why don't you stick your elitist bullshit to wherever? I loved Fargo, both seasons, and I'm just as outraged about this specific Globe category as anybody else in this thread. Still, I like watching AHS for the topics and aesthetics, I'm a horror and camp enthusiast. Yes, this season of AHS has been lacking on almost all accounts, and besides maybe three-ish characters this series as a whole has been pretty shitty, but remind me - what does this have to do with my IQ, if I like watching intricately woven plots like in Fargo on one hand and stupid yet aesthetically pleasing horror nonsense on the other?

Yeah, that's right, hon. Now go away and grow up.

7
LorneMalvoGirl•

I was obviously joking about people's IQ, and I wasn't generalising ALL people who watch it to have a lack of appreciation for good TV. But it isn't a coincidence that I know so many people, who are obsessed with AHS, that wouldn't even give Fargo ANY remote consideration, ultimately because they know that they wouldn't mentally be able to engage in it. Stop acting so offended, that wasn't what I was trying to do. I was simply stating obvious observations.

-5
Daevar•

See, those aren't "obvious observations", well, maybe for you, because you're hanging out with people you see as dimwits, but that's your loss and no reason to belittle other people you don't know and enjoy a more diverse taste in TV series than you do - acting like Fargo has the most complicated plot of all times isn't helping, either, it isn't exactly The Wire or True Detective.

1
sickofstew•

It's so baaaaaaaad that people think it's good writing. They have these quirky one liners that are trying so hard to be poetic. What's the plot of the show, I wonder? I can't even pinpoint at a moment where one character was consistent or even had unchanging principles.

1
My_Normal_Account•

I didn't watch yet but I can't fucking believe that. Like this has to be a joke. LADY GAGA!?!? LADY FUCKING GAGA IN HER FIRST STUPID ROLE IN FILM???? Beat a multi decade veteran actor with by far one of the best performances I've ever seen in my life. But, this shit is a popularity contest regardless so who cares.

98
prof_leopold_stotch•

Yeah that was one of the categories I read the nominees ahead of time and thought it was a done deal for Kirsten Dunst. Very surprising.

25
megatom0•

Yeah this is really crazy to me. I mean even folks over on r/AmericanHorrorStory don't think she is doing that great of a job in the show. The general opinion there is good to awful, half of them clamoring for Lange to come back.

Personally I think Gaga is fine in her role but there is no nuance to her character, she isn't really sympathetic or particularly likable. I feel like Gaga carries the role with her charisma and sex, but it isn't a complicated part at all. It is crazy Dunst would lose to her in that role. Jesus....

21
Not_A_Master•

Well she was in Machete 2 and Sin City: a Dame to Kill For as well.

I've not watched this season of AHS, but based on what I saw in those two movies I doubt she was of Dunst's calibre.

I will say her part in Sin City was pretty damn solid, probably one of the three bright spots of the film along with Joseph Gordon Levitz's segments and Eva Green, but she's always the best thing in something terrible.

6
Daevar•

She's not even close to the best female roles in AHS, though. Kathy Bates, Denis O'hare (well, not a female role in the sense of the Globes, probably) and Mare Winningham outshine here vastly.

I like Lady Gaga in general, but her role in Hotel is little more than wearing great costumes and make-up littered with mediocre acting.

5
Not_A_Master•

I never said she was, just that what I've seen of her has been fine. No one should win an award for being fine, especially in an era of amazing television performances like we're living in now.

1
DrScientist812•

Not to mention her shitty attitude regarding her nomination (i.e. screaming and jumping up and down like a child). No class.

3
Onesharpman•

If no one cares, why are you so upset?

-13
ksemog•

Kirsten Dunst losing to Lady Gaga is like Meryl Streep losing to Amy Schumer. Infuriating.

77
ambermonkeyOP•

Agreed! Though I thought Amy schumer was really good in Trainwreck, better than I expected.

15
mrtitkins•

I was pleasantly surprised as well. The whole movie was great.

3†
megatom0•

Amy did a great job in trainwreck even if it wasn't a stretch for her. Gaga is just kind of there. I'll be honest there is one part in AHS where they do a flashback and I thought the character Gaga was playing in the flashback was the lady from the Progressive commercials, that is sort of the level of acting we are dealing with.

4†
LorneMalvoGirl•

Well one thing we can say is how stunning Kirsten Dunst looked last night, she put Lady Gaga to shame!

3
fawltywiring•

As Karl Weathers in another life once said, "I still think awards are stupid. But they'd be less stupid if they went to the right people."

43
TommyDangerously•

In another life

In the same life! Weathers doesnt age, changes his name and moves. Doesnt lose badassery and is still the breakfast king!

6
yachster•

There's still plenty of meat on that bone!

2
tall_funny_tattooed•

Have you seen the video of Leo Dicaprio laughing his ass off when Gaga won? It's priceless!

36

He was not even laughing at her; the circlejerk is real...

15
lillargy•

Link?

4
shrederick•

I googled it and this was the first result. It's great.

1
Hips_n_nips•

That website is cancer.

18
KalaniKawehiKapono•

The whole gawker complex is a fucking cesspool if you ask me.

8
shrederick•

Definitely. It was just the first and only place I could find the video at the time.

2
TexanZombie156•

I mean, it's Golden Globes, they're kinda a joke, but still, stupid as fuck choice

29

Just curious, what makes you think Golden Globes are joke? I like Fargo a lot too, but have you even seen Lagy Gaga's performance? I haven't, and won't judge till I see it, if I ever do.

3
TicTacsss•

Well, I have seen her performance and have to say that it's ridiculous that she'd win. It wasn't a terrible performance by any means. It was just average. She's not an actress and it shows.

12
Leeloo_Sebat-Dallas•

Side-by-side with Dunst's performance especially, absolutely it was only average

7
canadiancarlin•

Earlier in the evening, Ricky Gervais makes a joke about corruption in the Golden Globes, "Who wouldn't want a Golden Globe, especially if your company's already paid for it?"

Then we see Lady Gaga beat Kirsten Dunst. That's the joke. I haven't seen American Horror Story, so I'll freely admit I'm incredibly biased, but Kirsten kicked down the door after years of little notoriety and gave us a character that made us laugh and scared at the very same time.

I haven't heard anything about Gaga's acting career, other than the fact that apparently she has one.

8
bhath01•

The Golden Globes are a joke considering that The Leftovers garnered 0 nominations but AHS and fucking Empire actually won awards. Those two shows aren't even close to the level of season 2 of the leftovers.

5
DrScientist812•

They're a bunch of starfuckers. They nominated The Tourist with Angelina Jolie and Johnny Depp, for Christ's sake.

3
TexanZombie156•

They're a bit of an industry joke, they don't really have any calibre. Everyone knows that it's an excuse for the Hollywood Foreign Press to get all the big celebs in one room and meet everyone, that's all it's ever been, hell Ricky Gervais even mentioned that at least 4 or 5 times last night alone

2
scuczu•

I saw it, it was bad, like not just bad, but laughingly bad, like she was trying really hard, and just feel flat everytime you are supposed to be impressed

1
Onesharpman•

So if they're a joke, they'd still be a joke if Kirsten Dunst won, right?

1
TexanZombie156•

Yep. They might make the right choices here and there but as an award in general they're meaningless, they have no acclaim to them, they insist solely so the Hollywood Foreign Press can meet all the celebs and that's it

1
Onesharpman•

I don't think that's why, but OK.

0
TexanZombie156•

Oh I promise you it is. For TV it's only really the Emmys that matter, Globes are just a bit of fun. I mean I saw a perfect post last night with someone comparing the Globes to WWE but for film/TV geeks. We all know it's fake but it's just fun entertainment to watch

5
thefablemuncher•

She's not even the best actress in AHS this season. Why she got nominated over Kathy Bates, Sarah Paulson, and Angela Bassett is pure nonsense.

EDIT: I would even pick Chloe Sevigny over her, despite being a supporting role.

28
DornishMasterPlan•

I'd put anyone else from AHS over Gaga. Her acting has been awful. I have no idea how she won over Dunst. I'm actually mad at how she won. Goes to show you these awards shows are paid and a joke.

7
Vanbone•

I agree wholeheartedly. The quality acting on AHS is a major reason I continue to watch the show, despite writing that is sometimes pretty awful. But Lady Gaga wasn't even on par with many of the other cast, she did a passable job, but not an impressive one. I have no idea how she was even nominated.

3
SpinnerofWool•

I found it hard to believe that Lady Gaga was even nominated, much less won. Drugs are bad kids, mmmk?

27
ambermonkeyOP•

I found her performance very bland. It had to be for ratings or press or some bullshit. Kirsten killed it this season, I think the Emmys are still to come? All these awards make me angry lol, that I even care too!

26
SpinnerofWool•

In all honesty, I gave up on AHS halfway thru this season (but adored most of the four that proceeded it - I say most of cuz lets face it, the latter half of Coven wasn't up to the usual standards). Gaga was stunt casting at it's most blatant.

8
schleppylundo•

Honestly I'd rank this season over 3 or 4. Hated those, think this one's alright and kept itself interesting a lot longer than the two that preceded it.

5
megatom0•

I'm the same. I think she is good in the role but nothing noteworthy (other than her ass in select costumes).

4
watcher45•

Agreed. The whole golden globes tonight was mostly bullshit except for a few clear winners, like mr. Robot. Kirsten Dunst was clearly better, she was just screwed over.

15
megatom0•

Yeah this is really bullshit. Gaga is fine in AHS but it is mostly just vamping (pun intended fuck it) and sex scenes. As far as acting go it is very flat. I'm honestly surprised she was nominated. How the fuck did Dunst not win for this season. She was a character I hated so much at episode 2 or 3 but then grew a lot of sympathy for by the end and it was in good part to Dunst's nuanced performance. Jesus that is fucked.

14
Funslinger•

The only acting she's really had to do in the season was in the very first episode, and it was actually pretty bad. Since then, it's been Blank Stare Cold Bitch.

1
Vanbone•

I'm not one to get upset at awards, but this seems kind of silly. Lady Gaga performed fine, but she wasn't even the best actress on AHS. Kirsten Dunst was given a challenging role, and she regularly stole the show with it.

10
Adalbrosios•

Won't matter to Kirsten Dunst. Heard she's fully realized!

8
VonDinky•

Kirsten Dunst, Fargo, Patrick Wilson? :O :O

WTF IS GOINN ON??? RAGEEE!!!

7
thefablemuncher•

For what it's worth, not even Frances McDormand won in the same category last year. No offense to Maggie Gyllenhaal, but no way was anyone in that same category even in the same league as McDormand in Olive Kitteridge. McDormand went on to win the Emmy award.

Sometimes I think the HFPA deliberately awards the second placer so they can give them their due recognition, because more often than not when it comes to both the Emmys and Oscars, these same Golden Globe winners didn't stand a chance against the "real" winners.

6
ruetaine•

What bothered me most was that her acceptance speech was so fake and cheesy, so long, too long, as if she had won an Oscar. Argh!

6
whitesquare•

I had watched previous seasons of American Horror Story and found this season to be completely unwatchable. Lady Gaga my fucking ass. This angers me.

5
TommyDangerously•

Its all political. Shes acting for the first time and shes already super famous, it was rigged. Dunst shouldve won!

3
fuck-dat-shit-up•

The fact that Jeffery Donavon didnt even get a nomination reminded what a bunch of bullshit the awards are. Lady Gaga had no reason to be nominated. It's a big circle jerk off. Kirsten is better than this.

3
kickstand•

Just remember that somewhere out there, Pia Zadora is polishing her Golden Globe award.

3