[WSIG] Akrotiri or 7 Wonders: Duel

WSIG

Hey All, A good 70% of the games I play are with only one other person, because of this I wanted to procure another dedicated 2-player game. I've done a bit of research and have narrowed down my results to these two choices.

Below are my reasonings for each choice.

Akrotiri:

  • It's Pretty
  • Pick up and Deliver - I don't have any game in my collection with this mechanic
  • Tile Laying - This mechanic is also under-represented in my collection

7 Wonders Duel:

  • I played 7 wonders a couple times and enjoyed it
  • Push/Pull mechanic seems interesting
  • I like building things in front of me

For reference, here are the games I enjoy playing with 2-players:

  • Patchwork
  • Roll for the Galaxy
  • Pandemic: The Cure
  • Suburbia
  • Isle of Trains
  • HIVE

I think I'll enjoy either of the two games, but I'm only willing to buy one. I'd really appreciate y'alls opinions!

Posted Jan 13, 2016, 6:35 PM UTC

2029
Luke_Matthews•

Akrotiri is fantastic. It's one of my wife and I's favorite two player games. It blends the tile-laying/exploration and pick-up-and-deliver mechanics well, and the card mechanics for "discovering" temples is really fun. It's very elegant. The difficulty and tension ratchet up nicely as the game progresses, and makes for some very close contests.

I own, but have not yet played, 7 Wonders Duel, so I can't comment on them comparatively. That being said, I've played plenty of 7 Wonders and I'm familiar with the rules for Duel, and I'm not sure it can be easily compared to Akrotiri. They're wildly different experiences.

8
SpelunkzillaOPSuburbia•

Yeah, I realize that they're completely different games. It kinda turned into a coin-flip of which to get. I couldn't decided so I turned to the community. Thanks for your input regarding Akrotiri!

1
Luke_Matthews•

Anytime. :)

1
wisegy84Troyes•

I'll second the recommendation for Akrotiri. We've only played a couple times so far, but it really is a great game. The decisions each turn are tough to make, but the game is very simple to learn. It really comes down to a bit of a race to "find" all of your temples. My wife and I both like it a lot so far and I think it will continue to be enjoyable.

1
cquinnProgLords Of Vegas•

I own and have played both, although I've only played Akrotiri once so far. Akrotiri is a little bit longer as far as game length goes. I think I would pick Akrotiri over Duel as it does a good job of making you feel "smart", it's very satisfying to find and uncover a gold level temple. The way you can affect the market by tile laying is very interesting as well. I also really enjoyed Duel, but the decision tree seemed a lot smaller and I think I'll get tired of it faster. I also have Patchwork and Roll for the Galaxy. If you get Pachwork to the table more often I would suggest to pick up Duel, but if you play Roll more often pick up Akrotiri.

5
FusionkastKeyflower•

You really should get both! Since you are only going to purchase one for now, based on the games you enjoy, you will probably enjoy Akrotiri the most.

The games you listed are mostly strategic in nature which Akrotiri is. The flow of the game requires you to plan ahead, compete for resources and position your temples in ways that benefit your positioning better than your opponent. The game also ramps up towards the second half and produces a nice brain burn.

7 Wonders Duel is more tactical in nature. There is a constant push and pull between obtaining progress on your board while negating your opponent key cards. You are constantly trying to not have to pay for resources while forcing your opponent to, keeping a watchful eye to the technologies being acquired, denying blue victory point cards, and of course the tug of war of the military track. There is less future planning going on in 7 Wonders as your focus is more in the immediate now.

So if you are looking for something different than your favorite 2P games go for 7 Wonders Duel. If you want something right up your alley go with Akrotiri. Both are great and very different from one another.

3
SpelunkzillaOPSuburbia•

Thank you for your in-depth response. I am defiantly leaning towards Akrotiri, and will probably pick it up. Haha, now I feel like it will only be because of my unwillingness to step outside my comfort zone.

1
kurt-wagnerTerra Mystica•

I'm in that same ratio of two player games. Some games my wife and I love are Jaipur and Mottainai. We just bought 7 Wonders: Duel, but have yet to play it. Lost Cities is pretty good as well.

u/r2d8 getinfo long

2
r2d8boop boop beep•

^r2d8 ^issues ^a ^series ^of ^sophisticated ^bleeps ^and ^whistles...

Details for Jaipur (2009) by Sébastien Pauchon. 2 p; 30 minutes; img

  • Mechanics: Hand Management, Set Collection, Trading
  • Average rating is 7.5439; rated by 12032 people
  • Average Weight: 1.5533; Number of Weights 797
  • Board Game Rank: 94, Family Game Rank: 9

Description:

Jaipur, capital of Rajasthan. You are one of the two most powerful traders in the city.

But that's not enough for you, because only the merchant with two Seals of Excellence will have the privilege of being invited to the Maharaja's court.

You are therefore going to have to do better than your direct competitor by buying, exchanging and selling at better prices, all while keeping an eye on both your camel herds.

A card game for two seasoned traders!

When it's your turn, you can either take or sell cards.

If you take cards, you have to choose between taking all the camels, taking 1 card from the market or swapping 2 to 5 cards between the market and your cards.

If you sell cards, you get to sell only one type of good per turn, and you get as many chips from that good as you sold cards. The chips' values decrease as the game progresses, so you'd better hurry ! But, on the other hand, you get increasingly high rewards for selling 3, 4, or 5 cards of the same good at a time, so you'd better wait!

You can't sell camels, but they're paramount for trading and they're also worth a little something at the end of the round, enough sometimes to secure the win, so you have to use them smartly.

Jaipur is a fast-paced card game, a blend of tactics, risk and luck.


Details for Lost Cities (1999) by Reiner Knizia. 2 p; 30 minutes; img

  • Mechanics: Hand Management, Set Collection
  • Average rating is 7.12153; rated by 22685 people
  • Average Weight: 1.524; Number of Weights 2542
  • Board Game Rank: 275, Family Game Rank: 38

Description:

Lost Cities is a card game in the Kosmos two-player series. The game consists of a single deck of cards of rank 2–10 in 5 different colors with 3 special "handshakes" ("HS" in scoring examples below) in each suit. There is also a board which functions only to hold and organize discarded cards and is largely superfluous. Games last around 15 minutes. This is generally considered a good "couples" game and is often recommended for people with non-gamer partners.

The object the game is to gain points by mounting profitable archaeological expeditions to the different sites represented by the 5 colors. On a player's turn they must always first play one card, either to an expedition or by discarding it to the appropriate discard pile, and then draw one card. There is a separate discard pile for each color and a player may draw the top card of any discard pile or the top card of the deck. Cards played to expeditions must be in ascending order but they need not be consecutive. Handshakes are considered lower than a 2 and represent investments in an expedition. Thus, if you play a red 4, you may play any other red card higher than a 4 on a future turn but may no longer play a handshake, the 2, or the 3.

The game continues in this fashion with players alternating turns until the final card is taken from the draw pile. The rest of the cards in hand are then discarded and players score their expeditions. Each expedition that has at least one card played into it must be scored. Cards played into an expedition are worth their rank in points, and handshakes count as a multiplier against your final total. Expeditions start at a value of -20 so you must play at least 20 points of cards into an expedition in order to make a profit. If you are left with a negative value and have a handshake, the multiplier still applies. A 20-point bonus is awarded to every expedition with at least 8 cards played into it. The player with the most points wins the game, but it is typical to play 3 matches and add your score from each to see who wins.

Scoring example 1: an expedition has a 2,3,7,8,10 for a total of 30. This expedition is worth 10 total points: 30 minus the initial -20.

Scoring example 2: an expedition has 2 HS, and 4,5,6,7,8,10 for a total of 40. This expedition is worth 80 total points: 40 points for cards, minus the initial 20, ×3 for the 2 multipliers, plus the 20-pt bonus for playing 8+ cards.

Scoring example 3: an expedition has 1 HS, and 4,6,7 for a total of 17. This expedition is worth -6 total points: 17 minus initial 20, ×2 for the multiplier.


Details for Mottainai (2015) by Carl Chudyk. 2-5 p; 30 minutes; img

  • Mechanics: Card Drafting, Hand Management, Set Collection, Variable Phase Order
  • Average rating is 7.15739; rated by 856 people
  • Average Weight: 2.9231; Number of Weights 78
  • Board Game Rank: 914, Strategy Game Rank: 472

Description:

"Mottainai" (pronounced mot/tai/nai) means "Don't waste", or "Every little thing has a soul". In the game Mottainai, a successor in the Glory to Rome line, you use your cards for many purposes. Each player is a monk in a temple who performs tasks, collects materials, and sells or completes works for visitors. Every card can be each of these three things.

You choose tasks to allow you to perform actions, keeping in mind that other players will get to follow up on your task on their next turn. Clever planning and combining of your works' special abilities is key, as is managing which materials you sell.

Mottainai is a deep, but quick, game experience.


1
SpelunkzillaOPSuburbia•

Thanks for the suggestions! I'll look into them.

1
XonimEclipse•

I wish I could weigh-in with more detail, but while we own both of these games, we have yet to play either of them. I will say that having already watched runthroughs for both of them, I think Akrotiri would get my vote -- though I am ALWAYS biased toward tile laying games (I love them!), and like you, I don't have another "pick up and deliver" type game.

1
TibbelExperimental Train•

I can't speak about Akrotiri, but 7 Wonders: Duel is fantastic! Most of the decisions have multiple contributing factors. (How much will this building cost me? How much does my opponent want the card underneath? If I don't get the next military, will I be in trouble? etc...)

1
eyesoftheworld72Agricola•

I own both. Akrotiri is certainly the meatier of the two. It is very unique and combines a lot of different mechanics.

If I had to choose, I would pick Akrotiri. I actually prefer the card drafting in Among the Stars better than 7 wonders duel

1
SpelunkzillaOPSuburbia•

Thanks. I've never looked into Among the Stars, but will do some research on it before I get 7 Wonders Duel. Does it play great with 2?

1
eyesoftheworld72Agricola•

Yes. It plays great with two. There is an official 2p variant that works very well. There are a few expansions for it and it's a very different theme. Civ games, while great, have been done to death.

1
elporkoz•

i haven't played 7 Wonders Duel, but i have to say that Akrotiri is SO good. definitely pick this up!

1
Reddit_is_gross•

I own both.

Akrotiri is heavier and more "brain burning". It's also significantly less interactive. It's more of a slow, strategic puzzle than Duel.

7 Wonders Duel is faster paced and more aggressive. The card drafting doesn't have as much weight behind it. It's much more of a... well, more of a duel than Akrotiri.

They're both good but I definitely prefer Akrotiri. Here's what I don't like about Duel: I don't feel like I am building a civilization in front of me. I feel like I am manipulating the array of cards to leave my opponent with as few good options as possible and occasionally I pick up a card I actually want. My opponent is doing the same to me, so often I don't have any real choice myself and it goes into auto-pilot. Akrotiri has its faults, but the decisions are consistently more interesting.

1
SpelunkzillaOPSuburbia•

I appreciate the response, and this does knock 7 Wonder Duel a little bit down for me. The main reason I was looking into it was for the feel of building a civilization in front of myself. The description you gave make the game seem a little frustrating to play. I'll have to look more into it.

2
y0j1m80Go•

Both. That said Duel will likely get played more often, as it's much shorter and takes up way less table space. They are both superb games though.

1
y0j1m80Go•

That said I honestly have to give my vote to Akrotiri.

1
Robletron•

A few weeks ago I'd have said Akrotiri hands down. It's a fantastic game. But more recently me and my other half seem to have replaced it with Tobago. Tobago keeps that treasure hunt theme and involves a lot more interaction with us both trying toco tribute clues. The major difference is that Tobago is not tile laying, and there isn't an economy as such. As much as Akrotiri ticks all my boxes, it seems much easier to get Tobago to the table!

1
SpelunkzillaOPSuburbia•

Thanks, haven't heard of Tobago. I'll look into it.

1
massi_xFive Tribes•

My wife and I own, love and regularly play both of them.

I'd lean more towards 7 Wonders: Duel as it is a faster paced, easier to set-up and overall funnier game than Akrotiri but honestly, buy both of them and you won't regret.

Akrotiri has long been my favorite 2 players' game, way better than Patchwork in my humble opinion; but then 7 Wonders: Duel came, reclaimed the throne and it is now the best 2p game I've ever played in my life.

That said, Akrotiri deserves to be in any 2p collection since it is a very solid game with a lot of depth!

1
SynanthropicViticulture•

Vote for Akrotiri. It's great mechanics, not a huge huge footprint, easy to get down but replayable (due to its nature). Duel fell flat for us, and was just a little thin and aggressive. We loved The Cave and Tobago for a similar feel!

1
Cazaderon•

Havent tried Akrotiri but 7 wonders duel is good fun. It has complexity and many mecanics that avoid game to be one sided which is pretty important for a 2 player game.

And the cards are pretty ^^

1
MaddenMan73•

I like both, for dueling I prefer 7WD, it's got that "evil" opponent vibe but Akrotiri is fun too!

1
junk2saLe Havre•

7 Wonders Duel is MUCH better than Akrotiri in my opinion.

0
SpelunkzillaOPSuburbia•

Thanks for the response. Was there anything about Akrotiri you didn't like? What made 7 Wonders Duel the better game for you?

1
junk2saLe Havre•

Funner. It had all the good feel of 7 Wonders. I don't particularly find tile laying a compelling or fun mechanic.

1