r/MHOCPress•
peter199

New Labour: Opinion

It is often seen as the premature death of John Smith as the thing which allowed New Labour to be born but in reality the seeds of New Labour were laid many years previous by Neil Kinnock. While Kinnock was seen as a man of the left he is remembered by many as the man who moved labour away from the left towards the centre. From the ‘Labour listens’ policy review of 1987, to Kinnock’s expulsion of the militant left he was the man who laid the groundworks for Blair and Brown to ultimately pull the party to the centre. For many, this was the beginning of the betrayal which seemed to slow under John Smith (although he did introduce one member one vote for conferences) who wasn’t as eager as Blair was to make the shift. However, Smith’s health would ultimately fail him and the way was paved for New Labour to come to fruition. Just five months after Smith’s death Blair unveiled all to conference; ‘New Labour, New Britain’ was alive.

After some eighteen years of Tory rule, Britain voted in New Labour with a landslide victory for Tony Blair. 336 Tory seats became 165, 271 Labour seats became 418 New Labour seats - a sea change in the political landscape. And yet, what had changed? A government which was ready to reform the UK may have been in power but did it actually do much? Sure it delivered things like devolution and House of Lords reform but it was all half-baked. Devolution was delivered in a lopsided way which meant that the infamous 'West Lothian Question' was now prised open once more. The House of Lords had its hereditary peers, mostly, removed but it still existed as an unelected monolith down from the Commons. I wouldn't argue that either of these things were bad, but for a Governing party which commanded over 400 MPs surely this is overly cautious. New Labour had the opportunity to finally tackle the Lords issue which has plagued modern Britain since 1909 but all they brought themselves to do was to remove the most archaic part – it was still fundamentally the same institution merely the inbuilt Tory majority had been removed. Even things like the minimum wage are things which, while are a good thing, aren't ideal. The minimum wage is a symptom of weak Trade Unions and the party founded by Trade Unions could've done something to strengthen industrial democracy ensuring that people could collectively bargain for better pay and conditions. Instead a sticking plaster approach was taken to the issue of low wages – something which characterises the New Labour years.

And when it came to economic policy, New Labour seemed to offer very little in terms of change. A continuation of Tory spending plans followed by a sharp rise in funding for social security and public services did occur however, even in this approach New Labour merely seemed to concrete in the ideals which Thatcher had introduced. Blair abandoned the traditional Labour position on universal provision of public services through policies like top up tuition fees and a move to target the welfare system at specific groups; and then went onto oppose universalism when other parties introduced the concept back into public services. Furthermore New Labour seemed to have taken lessons from the Tories when it came to economic policy after major change. Much like the Tories fifty years previous, New Labour merely paused over what the consensus in British politics is - a move towards a smaller and smaller state. Privatisations under New Labour did reduce (privatising a ‘mere’; £5.7bn compared to £64.9bn under Thatcher alone) but they have picked up once more under the Tories (with £37.7bn already privatised by Osborne) showing that the opposition have only acted to slow our progress to the Thatcherite goal - not to stop or reverse any progress already made.

The parallels with the 1950s are uncanny; the Tories then did not opt to ‘de-nationalise’ much bar steel and road haulage was ‘de-nationalised’; just as New Labour did not opt to ‘de-privatise’ much bar the rail infrastructure. This approach to just putting off whatever the Tories might next have install is inherently short termist in a number of ways. Firstly, it gives the New Labour project a lifespan which is determined by whatever the Tories do when they next re-enter power. New Labour does not act so much as an opposition since it does not refute the fundamental pillars of Thatcherism. The most it does is it makes Thatcherism ‘neater’ so to say, it messes around with what went on making it work better, but it doesn’t fundamentally change things. Take the NHS, yes the NHS improved under New Labour, but the effects of the Thatcher era were not changed; New Labour made the Tory reforms work better. The 1990 NHS and Community Care Act was the start of tory degradation of NHS services and instead of removing the costly internal market system New Labour merely made it work better and utilised it to its full potential (in the creation of foundation trust hospitals and Blair’s desire for hospitals to have financial independence (the latter was ultimately blocked by Brown)). Secondly, and most damaging for New Labour, is that in pursuit of their policies New Labour erodes its core voters. As Tony Benn summarised after the 2003 New Labour conference ‘When [you] look at 'New Labour' [you] wonder whether it wasn't like trying to light a bonfire on a frozen lake - looked marvellous, bright lights, shining white, but you melted away your own support.’ – this was ultimately the thorn in New Labours rose and was demonstrated clearest in Scotland. As Scottish Labour lost in 2007 they begun to oppose many of the SNP policies which had been adopted from Labours past; things like free tuition fees and prescriptions soon became opposed by the party which painted itself as the party of the left. But as Benn said in 2003, the electorate had been tolerant of New Labour but as soon as an alternative arrived on the scene, the lake begun to give way. Lastly the kind of politics and narratives which New Labour accepted shifted the economy and how it is managed into a far more short term way of doing things. Gone were the days where the economy was looked at in a strategic way with investment made by the state when needed. The New Labour administration as much as any post-1979 Tory administration relied on the financial sector heavily to boost tax receipts and overall economic growth. In doing so it neglected infrastructure and allowed us to drift onwards without any real core skilled core outside the financial sector. Just like the Tories did with Labour in 1951, New Labour paved the way for Thatcherism to survive beyond any form of Labour Government.

As a project New Labour seemed to be born with much energy, hope and optimism. As 1997 approached the New Labour machine was polling at 58% and Tony Blair rode a wave of public support finally into Downing Street backed with a majority of 179 (and 43% of the vote). When 2001 came around Blair rode once more into Downing Street with a huge majority of 167 (and 40% of the vote), however, after the Iraq War Tony Blair and his project seemed to be losing momentum and come the 2005 General Election New Labour won just 35% of the vote (the lowest of any majority Government in the UK ever) but due to the nature of the electoral system this granted New Labour 355 seats – a comfortable majority. Despite this win, moves were made within the party to oust Blair. Many felt he has overstayed his tenure and Chancellor Gordon Brown felt that Blair had broken the deal they had made back in 1994. As the possibility of a coup neared, Blair announced that the upcoming Labour conference would be his last. In May 2007 Labour lost control of the then Scottish Executive and seemed to be on the decline with the electorate but following Brown’s appointment as Prime Minister in June 2007 New Labour's poll ratings were transformed.

With Brown seemingly came a new lease of life for the project; they went from trailing the Tories by 5% to leading them by 6%. Brown faced two terrorist attacks in London and Glasgow, not the easiest of starts for a new PM, and yet remained high in the polls. Surely Brown would go to the country to seek a fresh mandate – the answer came on October the sixth - no. Immediately after, the Tories regained their lead in the polls and just a month later were leading New Labour by 8%. It seemed that in just one decision he had obliterated his own credibility and that of his party. As David Cameron said at PMQs ‘[Browns] the first Prime Minister in history to flunk an election because he thought he was going to win it!’ a cruel taunt to Brown who was now disgraced to the country. The possibilities had that 2007 election occurred are endless. It is almost certain New Labour would’ve been returned, albeit with a reduced majority, allowing them to manage the country and the economy for longer after the financial crisis. Had the economic growth which was being shown in 2010 been sustained throughout the period, it is unlikely that New Labour would’ve been totally destroyed come this hypothetical 2012 General Election. With no omnishambles budget we could well have seen New Labour survive (in some shape or form) beyond 2012 possibly in coalition with the Liberal Democrats until 2017. Who knows, had Brown not condemned the project to the political scrap heap we may have seen Labour in some form or another come 2020. Regardless of the hypothetical it seems that Gordon Brown, a key architect in the New Labour project, was the man who unintentionally brought the whole thing to an end.

So, was New Labour really necessary to get a Labour Government? The Blairites and those who believe in the project would argue that only with the work of Blair and Brown could Labour regain high office; but are they really correct? The answer is obvious – no. It is easily argued that all that was needed for a Labour Government come 1990 was for Neil Kinnock to go; but Labour are not as ruthless when it comes to leaders who won’t win as the Tories are. Kinnock leading Labour into 1992 was in retrospect a bad decision, especially when you look at the Kinnock which was presented to the electorate. A man who had been polished by spin doctors but was still seen as someone not to be trusted; and why should the electorate have trusted him? He started out as a man of the left and slowly moved to the centre, abandoning many of the views he had once held dear such as unilateral nuclear disarmament and the need for Lords reform. To quote Tony Benn in 1995 ‘I would’ve hated to have gone down the same path as Neil Kinnock; abandoning your deepest held beliefs only to discover no one believed a word you said’ – appropriate words which sum up where Labour went wrong in 1992. Compare Smith to Kinnock. Smith was seen as a trusted figure, a Scottish bank manager from the days where bank managers were trusted. Had he led Labour into 1992 he may have propelled Labour to a hung Parliament; as even the exit poll for 1992 suggested. Even with the chain of events which did happen, New Labour’s short term thinking and destructive nature didn’t need to happen. Labour were polling 50% in 1993, under John Smith. Anyone could have led Labour into 1997 and won, the spin that the New Labourites have put on the need to ‘modernise’ and become ‘electable’ is little more than spin. Ultimately the New Labour path was not a necessary path to take in order to gain power. The destruction of Labour’s core values and core voter base was not something that was needed to secure a Labour Government. The argument that Labour needed to change in order to gain power, is simply untrue since Governments lose and Oppositions win not on policies but on voter fatigue of the incumbents in marginal seats.

Posted Jan 14, 2016, 8:09 PM UTC · edited

843
jb567The Rt Hon Baron of Ripley | Pirate DL | Lab Chief Whip in Lords•

Governments lose and Oppositions win now on policies but on voter fatigue of the incumbents in marginal seats.

I feel that this is unfortunately more true than we want it to be

5
peter199OPIndependent Trains | Duke of Lennox•

indeed

3
theyeatthepooThe Independent•

Again, this shouldn't really be in this sub. It's not about MHOC.

4
athanatonOnly the Structuralists deal in absolutes•

Everything that is political is MHoC appropriate. Parties don't exist in a vacuum, the only people within the political space are not politicians, there are many others adding their opinions on political events and theories past and present. And indeed, politicians do the same, they have to, just look at the Learning the Lessons report. Longer-form development of political theories and retrospectives on political events is esssential to the growth and development of parties as well as to the opinions of the political sphere. To excise that from MHoC, to have everything entirely focused in the minutiae, in the nitty gritty such as whether basic income should cover 16 year olds, both limits the level and scope of political discourse we can offer our members, and represents another way of making MHoC limited and unrealistic.

8
theyeatthepooThe Independent•

I could not disagree more. This particular sub is designed to be a place for articles, newspapers, magazines etc that relate to the MHOC universe at the very least. Having a place for that improves the MHOC experience, it makes it more rounded.

MHOC doesn't exist in a vacuum, that is acknowledged. We know that other subs exist and RL newspapers exist in which articles such as these are published. They inform our opinion of politics and political theory and we act on that, if we consume such material.

By making this sub a place for generic articles about politics all you are doing is reducing the space in which MHOC exists and allowing this to become a generic political sub.

I mean, its one thing to write an article about a generic issue or political argument that exists outside of MHOC, but these articles specifically exclude the existence of MHOC and so diminish the experience. u/peter199's article would never have been written in MHOC because Labour have been so successful on a left wing manifesto.

So for somebody coming to this sub to take part in MHOC, when they read this article, not only is it irrelevant to MHOC but it takes them out of the experience.

MHOC is not a place primarily for the discussion of political theory, its a place to simulate a model parliament and the world that surrounds it. This article and others like them ignore that world.

2
ieya404Tory Scum•

Oh take a hint for once in your life. You have an opinion. Many other people have a different opinion. You don't get to censor all dissenting views here. Deal with it.

FWIW MHOC's world history is the same as ours up till its start (barring divergence over devolution), so this is a perfectly cromulent article anyway.

4
theyeatthepooThe Independent•

I have an opinion and I'm voicing it. I don't have the power to censor anyone.

2
peter199OPIndependent Trains | Duke of Lennox•

ok

6
ieya404Tory Scum•

On the other hand, where better to post a thoughtful political piece without cluttering up the main MHOC sub, while still reaching a good chunk of model Parliamentarians?

10
theyeatthepooThe Independent•

Why would we post a random political opinion piece on MHOC at all? We have subs for that. This has nothing to do with the model world, in fact it ignores it all together.

At the very least put it in the strangers bar.

4
demon4372The Rt Hon. Earl of Dwyfor AL PC ¦ MoS for Federalisation•

Stop being such a salty moany fucker and shut up

3
IntellectualPoliticsMP | SSoS for Wales & Defence | Chair NatSec. | Cav. | CG | Tory•

Hardly random, given the current status of the Labour Party.

1
peter199OPIndependent Trains | Duke of Lennox•

exactly :)

1
theyeatthepooThe Independent•

Maybe you could try r/politics instead?

2
akc8Labour Chairman •

I enjoyed the read I'm looking forward to more from you lot, have a beer on me.

3
peter199OPIndependent Trains | Duke of Lennox•

thank you and eyy I get you 8)

1
RachelChamberlainQuestioner•

Very interesting article, I recommend Steven Fielding's book "The Labour Party: Continuity and Change in the Making of New Labour' for a revisionist take on it.

2
peter199OPIndependent Trains | Duke of Lennox•

Thank you, and I shall look into that I do find this subject quite interesting so thanks!

2
thechattyshow#LIBPRESSREVIVAL2016•
2
peter199OPIndependent Trains | Duke of Lennox•

..?

1
ThatThingInTheCornerSenior Journalist•

woah

2
demon4372The Rt Hon. Earl of Dwyfor AL PC ¦ MoS for Federalisation•

Great article, i hope we see this trend of stuff like this continue

2
peter199OPIndependent Trains | Duke of Lennox•

thank you! guess it depends if we have time etc.

1
AlbechtVonRoonThe Vanguard Leader | North Yorkshire MP | Duke of York•

New Labour are nothing but a party of Jews and Commies!

2
peter199OPIndependent Trains | Duke of Lennox•

Commies

wishful thinking

1
AlbrechtVonRoonThe Vanguard•

Just to note, that isn't me.

3
thechattyshow#LIBPRESSREVIVAL2016•

You have an r.

u/Bznss is this dupe allowed? It intents seem pretty malicious to me.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
NettlthSinn Féin•

Pretty good article. I often see people saying "oh well actually Blairism started with Kinnock", when discussing the topic, and I'm inclined to disagree. I think Kinnock is a red herring in this respect. "Blairism" is merely a modern face of the kind of opportunism that has always been present in social democratic and labour parties. Labour wasn't a pure-bred, principled socialist party before Kinnock or any of the "modernisers". Its always been a party of many tendencies which moves to the left when under the pressure of the working class (a move resisted by the right, of course). Just as now in Corbyn's Labour Party, the right have been dealt a blow by the working class and are trying to cling on to power based on their usual, hypocritical, self-serving slogans about "electability" and "moderation".

2