What are physical sunscreens you would recommend?

Question

Hello! After patch testing a couple of sunscreens, I can definitely conclude that my face does not like chemical sunscreens--patch testing on my arms and legs went just fine, but trying it out on my face just resulted in violent red rashes. :(

I was wondering if people had any physical-only sunscreens to rec? I'm combo/dehydrated and live in a temperate climate, and typically don't wear makeup. N20-25 but white-cast is not a deal-breaker. My skin, barring chemical sunscreens, is usually up for anything (have stayed away from actives and acids altogether until I can find a sunscreen that works for me).

I've been looking at the Innisfree sunscreens, since I've seen them mentioned a couple of times, but I'm not sure which one to try out of their 10(!?) variants.

Posted Jan 20, 2016, 5:25 AM UTC

624
spaispai•

I'm not certain about innisfree sunscreens, but I love Menturm Sun Bears Strong Super Plus. I believe it's physical only (but am on my phone and don't have the ingredients handy). It's water/sweatproof and doesn't seem to dry out my skin at all. I live in Michigan and in winter it's pretty dry to begin with, so this is awesome.

2
vallary•

I love this too, but it's physical/chemical combo, the UV filters are Titanium Dioxide, Zinc Oxide, Octinoxate and Uvinul A Plus.

1
quailleOPNC25|Pigmentation|Combo/Dehydrated|US•

I've seen that particular Menturm sunscreen mentioned at least a couple of times! Sadly, I think it's been discontinued, but thank you for the recommendation, since they'll probably release something similar in the near future.

1
myheartstragedy•

I'm currently using the Holika Holika Dazzling Sunshine Make Up Sun Cream Spf 45 PA+++. I find it alright as a physical-only sunscreen. It's tinted but there's still white cast but it evens out my skin tone and lightens it by reducing the redness. It's not drying, I have combo skin as well, and it leaves a satin finish, not matte and not oily. I will like it more if the fragrance wasn't that strong (I might be more sensitive to fragrance in skincare) but it works great for the price, it's really cheap.

2
quailleOPNC25|Pigmentation|Combo/Dehydrated|US•

Thanks for the rec! And the warning about the fragrance, which is something that my skin doesn't react to, but my nose does. I'll look into it when I do my next haul.

1
SleepySluggum•

I've had similar experiences with chemical sunscreens. The only chemical sunscreen that wouldn't break me out was La Roche-Posay, but oh that price tag! I now use the Innisfree eco safety no sebum sunblock spf 35 PA+++ (I'm not in the sun that often, but still wear it everyday). And it hasn't made me break out at all! It does have a bit of a white cast, but not enough to bother me.

2
quailleOPNC25|Pigmentation|Combo/Dehydrated|US•

Oh man, the La Roche-Posay is pretty pricey, but it sounds promising? I feel like a ton of AB sunscreen is chemical-based, so I'll make a note of the non-AB recs too!

1
itza_trapfosho•

I like The Face Shop Natural Sun Eco Sebum Control. It's gentle and I don't notice too much of a white cast. I'm in the same boat as you with chemical sunscreens.

2
quailleOPNC25|Pigmentation|Combo/Dehydrated|US•

Huh, cosDNA shows it has a couple of chemical sunscreens if I'm not mistaken? But maybe the physical/chemical nature of it makes the formula milder overall. Thank you!

1
itza_trapfosho•

Oh! It was recommended by someone else on this sub and I just took it at face value. I don't know what it is that is so different but I'll tell you it doesn't give me the reaction that CeraVe am gave me. Or the Misha blue bottle.

1
kthienaii•

Alright, I know this may be a dumb question but how do I know what sunscreen is a physical sunscreen or a chemical sunscreen? :(

2
DoraemonCatAcne/Pigmentation|Oily|ES•

If you see Titanium Dioxide or Zinc Oxide high on the ingredients list, it's a physical sunscreen. If not, it's a chemical itchy b***h.

You can also have mixed sunscreens, as the one I use in non-sweat season, the Bioré Perfect Face Milk SPF50+/PA++++. Although it has chemical ingredients it doesn't tingle or hurt my eyes, even if I use it on both my eyelids. It also dries matte without drying my skin so it's a winner here. Too bad its waterproof features are terrible, as it melts down with sweat, so in summer I use the Innisfree Perfect Sunblock Waterproof SPF 50+/PA+++. This one is 100% physical and 100% waterproof.

1
quailleOPNC25|Pigmentation|Combo/Dehydrated|US•

Thanks for the concise explanation and both recs! I've seen Bioré recommended a lot and I was looking for 100% physical sunscreen from Innisfree.

1
calias•

We've got the same skin and I'm also in a temperate climate, although I'm a little closer to NC20. I've got the Innisfree Eco Safety Perfect Sunblock in both the regular and waterproof; they're SPF 50+/PA+++. I think it works fine on me, although it can be a little prone to pilling if you really slather it on. If you apply in thin layers and wait for your previous skincare layers to set a bit it won't be as problematic.

It will give you a white cast, but that's dependent on how much you put on. I also don't wear makeup often and find it kinda blurs imperfections a bit haha. The white cast is stronger in the regular than the waterproof (which seems to have some tint to it).

1
mizliuNC15|Redness|Dry/Normal|US•

I use the same and I'm NC15, so it actually helps lighten up my face a bit and slightly cover up redness and acne scarring. Still on the hunt for something with SPF50+ PA++++ that's affordable...!! I should've asked my parents to find some Japanese sunscreens while they were in Taiwan this past month DX

1
quailleOPNC25|Pigmentation|Combo/Dehydrated|US•

Skin twins! /high fives and offers a sheet mask.

Thank you for the recommendations, I'll definitely look at both of them.

1
calias•

No problem! /swaps you a sheet mask back

1
hibaobao•

I tried the Innisfree Eco Safety Waterproof Sunblock and it was quite drying so I'll be saving that for summer. Right now I use Missha All Around Safe Block Waterproof Sun 50+ PA+++ and its working better, though not quite perfect. :)

1
quailleOPNC25|Pigmentation|Combo/Dehydrated|US•

Thanks for pointing out that the Innisfree one was drying for you. I think that won't be an issue in the summer once I've moisturized and repaired my skin barrier a bit, but until then I'll try less drying ones!

Where did you get the Missha sunscreen?

1
hibaobao•

I've gotten it from RoseRoseShop and TesterKorea for pretty cheap. You can also get it directly from Missha's website or even on ebay. I've also heard great things about Goodal's sunscreen.

1
dethleib•

What's the fragrance level like on the Missha block?

1
hibaobao•

It's there, but much milder than the bb creams iirc. I unfortunately don't have the innisfree with me to do an accurate comparison, but from what I remember, they were about the same. Those are the only 2 AB sunscreens I've tried though since physical only spf is harder to come by.

1
dmhu•

I've been testing the Innisfree Eco Safety Perfect Waterproof for a couple of weeks and am very happy with it. I found that the non-waterproof version had more fragrance, which my sensitive nose didn't like. My sensitive face hasn't broken out (at least not yet and if so, only a little clog here or there) and the smell of the waterproof version isn't as strong. I tried the Goodal Mild Protect but am pretty sure it contributed to some clogged pores. I also found the scent to be too much for me. Good luck!

1
quailleOPNC25|Pigmentation|Combo/Dehydrated|US•

Yeah, I've found sunscreens to be tricky and pore-clogging too. Thanks for telling me what Innisfree sunscreen works for you!

1