Central Virginia. One guy says maple, another says hornbeam, I say neither but idk.

Central Virginia. One guy says maple, another says hornbeam, I say neither but idk.

Posted Jan 20, 2016, 10:45 PM UTC

1616
treerabbitSE Michigan•

Definitely not maple-- maples have opposite branching and this is alternate.

Could you upload a better photo of the buds? I can't make out anything clearly in this photo.

11
hellrunnerOP•

http://imgur.com/VWGAFKP

mostly stupid glove though

2
treerabbitSE Michigan•

Neither the buds nor bark look like hornbeam (Carpinus sp.) to me-- unfortunately, though, I'm not sure what it is.

4
kslusherplantmanEl Paso/Southern NM, Horticulturist & Commercial grower•

Need some leaves at the least...

0
treerabbitSE Michigan•

Meh, a lot of times if you have bark an a good photo of buds/leaf scars, that's plenty-- but in this case the photo's just not clear enough (and also I'm not as familiar with flora of Virginia as I could be)

3
SweaterFish•

I'd look in amongst that groundcover growing under it. There's bound to be some leaves in there from last season. Though there does seem to be a lot of trees in that neighborhood, so it might be hard to be sure which ones came form this tree.

2
shushupbuttercup•

Iron wood/musclewood? Basic guess.

1†
treerabbitSE Michigan•

Bark doesn't fit.

3
PrairieDropseed•

I would say Carpinus caroliniana, American hornbeam.

1†
treerabbitSE Michigan•

Bark looks too textured to me

3
vtslimVT, Zone 5•

If it weren't for the photo of the twigs I would have said that bark was Cladrastis.

1
kslusherplantmanEl Paso/Southern NM, Horticulturist & Commercial grower•

Hahahaha so nobody can determine what this is...

below I mention needing leaves and I get downvotes, well clearly we need leaves in this case assholes, I wasn't wrong, otherwise those people who down voted, why not tell us what this tree is without leaves

1