My case interview experience

I wrote the below several months ago, now i feel comfortable enough to post, opinions?

First case interview for one of the big firms today - and only one in the pipeline. I'm still processing what happened and trying to work out whether I'm shit and how to regain my confidence.

After all the pleasantries, i'm given the study, full side of A4 including 3 years accounts. I'm asked to identify the problems and consider solutions. Its in essence a business growth question where there is limited cash, trying to expand too many business areas at once and owner reluctance to expand.

So I ask some clarifying questions about the case which gleamed very little of use. I carry on regardless, I start talking and drawing my tree for structure when I'm stopped by the interviewer and told there's no need for it. Ok...

I resort to doing it all verbally without any written structure which is bloody difficult as a novice. I s to ascertain which route of expansion should be focussed on so i ask for data on the industry or rivals. Nothing. I'm then told to get off the fence and pick a single expansion option (there were 3) and take it forward.

I pick one which sounded reasonable and start doing a 3Cs and a P framework as I'm gettimg quite stressed at this point. I try to segment the customers, no data, asked for price sensitivity info, no data, customer wants, no data. I move onto product, same response until I'm told that I don't need to go through all those areas, then asked how to convince the owner this is a good idea. Hold on, I've not even worked out if it is a good idea!

I fudge my way through the rest, and bungle my way through the 'chat'. I put so much time and effort into my prep as I really wanted the job, completely hollow inside after it.

Posted Jan 21, 2016, 7:20 PM UTC

48
ArtDealer•

1/2 the time the interview isn't about your knowledge. It's more about how comfortable the interviewer feels about putting you in front of a client. Are you going to wear your big kid shoes? Will you start an infantile whine and say 'like' a lot when arguing a point? Sounds like you acted professionally, so you're golden.

5
Crash_Coredump•

Will you start an infantile whine and say 'like' a lot when arguing a point?

For me, uptalk and vocal fry are instant deal killers

0
Cincy_OTR•

You'll be fine. It's hard to judge candidates in case studies so often interviewers will try to stress out the candidate to see how they will react. I'm sure you did fine..

4
fastspanishBig 4 Healthcare•

this. objectively it sounds like you were going through all the correct motions (framework, writing it out, talking through your structure). could just be a pressure test where they don't even care what your approach/answer is.

also, u/Cincy_OTR you ever been to The Eagle, or that doughnut shop down the street?

3
Cincy_OTR•

Yea! I'm assuming your talking about Holtman's, best damn donuts for $1!! Haven't been to the eagle yet tho

3
fastspanishBig 4 Healthcare•

Yes! was staffed in Cincy a few times. The Eagle has some pretty incredible fried chicken, worth checking out.

3
lumberjack233•

I had a very recent interview with a MBB with uncannily similar experience with OP (quickly glanced at OP username and it didn't seem I made a post when sleepwalking). It's been a week now and no news so I assume i got dinged.

Still, I am wondering the same thing as OP: what should I do when there is no data, or only very preliminary data (made up on the spur of the moment) provided for all the possible branches? I was really conflicted in the interview since I always try to steer clear of making statements without data backing up, but there is clearly pressure to take a stance and answer the question. Sure I can make a hypothesis, but the hypothesis could very well be wrong and waste precious time to prove, other times hypothesis can hardly be quantifiable, in which case it's just me talking out of my ass.

2
GG-MBB•

I put so much time and effort into my prep as I really wanted the job, completely hollow inside after it.

I hope you still don't feel like that, OP.

2
m4r1uz91•

OP I Guess this is a little old, and maybe I won't get a response - what kind of prep did you do? How would you change it ? How did it help you?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1