Analysis of top compositions and builds

Discussion

To gain more insight into the most viable character combinations and builds, I browsed through the top ranked players and compiled a spreadsheet accordingly. This was mainly to help gain confidence in my 'more permanent' character development decisions. I used the abyss as a metric for top players on the global server. I could have just-as-well used top ranking on one of the legendary raids, both have pretty much the same set of players. Also, the list was compiled over the past couple weeks, so the precise order isn't worth noting. Also, the sample size is relatively small, but notable enough for some insights. Personally, I'm in the CS150 range now and abyss level 79 (mid 30's abyss rank last week). I run Paladin, Cleric, Assassin, and Illusionist... but I've debated on the druid and warlock as well.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1OB5VpMDxsBm9QzhR0Vwzz9N3tOtt1RTnSAoRenSiMDM/edit#gid=864199404

A few observations:

  1. Each team has 1 tank, 1 healer, 1 physical damage, and 1 wild card.

  2. All tanks were viable: Paladin (10), Reaver (5), Defender (5).

  3. Cleric (7) and Druid (13) are viable, but no mystics were found.

  4. There are no particular pairing of tank/healer that stood out more than others.

  5. Paladins/Druids are more common, but its unclear if they are 'better' from this information data alone (small sample size).

  6. Assassins (9) and berserkers (9) are evenly common. Thief (2) is less common. Not however, that the later release of this character could be the reason so few are seen. Most veterans players may have already been 'committed' to assassin/berserker when thief was released.

  7. 'Wild card' 4th character is very diverse. Some are second tanks (4), second healers (2), second physical damage (4), but most commonly are Illusionist (5) or Warlock (4).

  8. No mystics were found. Only one mage, and only one scout were observed.

  9. Defender, Assassin, Berserker, Illusionist, and Warlock, and druid had very stable skill selections.

  10. Paladin, Reaver, and Cleric had more variety.

For newer players however, please note that these top build's might not be the best characters/skills to use when getting to heroics. For example, I found that the mage was very strong up to CS100, while illusionist was terrible.

Update: 11) Illusionists are always paired with Assassins, Berserkers have no consistent pairings.

Posted Jan 27, 2016, 11:14 PM UTC · edited

640
benihime-xbla•

Very interesting. I agree in that since the Brigand and the Mystic came so late people already had a working combination and didn't bother with the later classes.

On the mage, it was actually my first leader -- due to the fact that it's aoe damage is second to none until CS100 (you're pretty accurate here). Also single target was how I started to beat content (with sleep) because it mitigates a lot of damage, and the mages strength was AOE which was often counter intuitive.

Scout is similar to the mage where it feels clunky. Brigand definitely has a lot of potential with the recent changes to Multiple Strike.

2
MrProb•

I agree in that new classes aren't used not because they're underwhelming but most players already committed to some other classes, you need to level them to 50, get gear and find skill scrolls for them, not every player has the privilege to be able to provide everything for all their characters.

Although Mystic looks weaker than the other 2 healers because she wears robe and doesn't have any defensive passive like Druid.

2
DerpElve•

Cool compilation!

This should be named analysis of top compositions for the Abyss, though, since that's the list you used as reference. I run a completely different character and skillset for the Abyss than for normal stages. I'd guess the top players change to the Abyss as well, most likely. Unless the Abyss gets ridiculously easy at higher CS.

The Paladin has been from the beginning the easiest tank to use. His damage skills are pretty good to gain aggro so it's the simplest mechanic. Reaver and Defender need to be played in specific manners to be more efficient, with the Pally you can just hit and succeed.

The Druid is very much better than the Cleric at basically all dungeons. I still refuse to change since I like my Cleric too much. Druid has Swiftmend, Regeneration and Wisdom. Dispel and heal in one skill and a no-turn-heal for basically all allies. She has her damage reduction passive as well. Mystic is pretty good, really good so I'm surprised to see her not there. Her continuous multistrike and the afterlife passives are so amazing. Spirit partition works miracles for the Abyss stages as well.

I also noticed that the Brigand is crazy damage-wise. The Assassin pales in comparison to most of the damage dealers, even though I hate to say that. I feel that all the starter characters are easily replaceable. I'd love to see some changes made to the Cleric and Assassin. The Defender is on its own since there's nothing much that can be done to fix his specialisation.

Just some thoughts on your observations.

2
Streon•

I'm glad to hear you think the brigand had potential, because that's the one I'm working on. What have you been seeing to draw that conclusion?

1
Odvar•

Wondering this also which is the best to go with as skills for her. Im working on her and zerker as an extra DPS

1
Streon•

Personally, it seems like most of her strength comes from the free bleed on normal attacks, so I'm looking at skills that complement. GM lacerate is obviously in the build, so that leaves 2 free slots. I have multiple strike in now, and it looks even better with the reduced CD, so I think I'll keep it. That leaves primal strength, primal growth, and frenzy out of what seem like the top options. Lacerate + primal strength is the most mana hungry combo I've seen, so until I get the mp regen for it, I'm thinking regrowth, but I could be wrong about that but or any of this.

1
Forefal1•

I would disagree with a lot of this. Cleric is very comparable to Druid and better when you need a lot of healing. Brigand WAS worse than both berserker and assassin in terms of damage output. New update may change that. Assassin if you can keep aggro off may be top physical DPS.

1
MrProb•

I actually think Brigand DPS is worse than Assassin BUT as a Brigand you can go all out with much less worrying about her dying or gaining aggro for extended period of time while Assassin has to be very careful and occasionally pass the turn.

1
exotrxOP•

I actually did some calculations/simulations earlier to compare assassin and brigand assuming the same build of GM lacerate, primal strength, and primal regrow. The biggest difference at the time in terms of passives were better damage % for assassin vs bleed damage.
Armor ignore on multistrike was minimal, since most damage was bleed or primal. My justification for choosing the assassin as higher was because the bleed damage wasn't scaling with multistrike... Rather, it would only help stack it a bit faster. That said differences were nominal. Now, with the buffs, it's probably a slight edge on thief.

1
exotrxOP•

Another factor is that the multiple strike skill is now better... It might be comparable to primal strength at a fraction of the mp cost.

1
MrProb•

I don't get it, isn't 3 turns CD do not make any different from 1 turn CD ? since the buff last 3 turns anyway.

1
Forefal1•

Don't misinterpret, multiple strike still only targets a single enemy, just if that enemy dies, you can now recast it so it can always be up.

1
Forefal1•

Why was most damage bleed or primal? Unless I'm mistaken, every basic attack and even the casting of lacerate is physical. Sure, GM lacerate piles extra damage on top with it's DOT, and primal is nice at maybe 40-50% extra damage, but your regular attacks and lacerate casts are a serious portion of your damage, all physical. Getting no armor resist on them is sick, like 20-70% extra damage sick. Some top builds run the ignore armor ability, giving up a whole slot just for it. Brigand gets that for free on multistrikes, pretty damn nice.

1
DerpElve•

I was going to comment about this. I would say classes are damage-wise pretty balanced. You get AP/SP from gear so you can only gain so much of it. Skills have the damages fixed as well.

It comes down to the passives to make the biggest difference and mostly they just do different things.

I have no idea how the ignore DEF works since we don't have any data on how much armor mobs actually have. It could be either a huge difference or none at all. Assassin's passives are ok, they increase damage. But, you need to 1) attack 4th turn for crit and 2) not have aggro. I think those are the biggest problems. The Brigand is pretty trouble-free in her passives. Building for multistrike is pretty easy and normal attacks are unavoidable most of the times.

So anyway, you can choose whichever character and you'll pretty much be doing fine. Until the fix GM Lacerate, there's no difference which character you use for the cookiecutter build.

1
wunshot2014•

The 1 turn cooldown is an improvement because if you kill whatever it was targeting, you can go ahead and choose a new target.

I'm pretty sure that Brigands DPS is higher now that they received a buff and nerf'd the GM lacerate (which is the only skill that made Assassin godly).

1
Anusien•

The lack of diversity in skills is amazing.

1
Anusien•

So the Reaver just sucks, huh?

Edit: I misread the graph, sorry.

1
Forefal1•

Um, no?

1
Anusien•

Oh I totally missed the Reaver (5). I even went back and double checked looking for it.

D'oh.

1
benihime-xbla•

Reaver probably holds hate the best and an adequate dps.

1
wunshot2014•

I don't see how this is the case. Most Reavers on my friends list (mine is crap) have drain life, revenge, and something else like primal regrowth. I can't get this reaver to hold hate at all unless I cast revenge, then have everyone else not attack until round two. Then when I get to the next stage I'm effed as the reaver's revenge hasn't popped yet and I can't get enough aggro and my dps get one shotted during round 1.

2
Anusien•

I suspect having Wipeout (which is a mass attack, so a ton more total damage) on top of Drain Life is a big impact.

What I don't understand is why no one has had success building a Defender like that. It has more native aggro gaining. Is it just the lack of a second good damage skill? (Reaver and Paladin both have Wipeout; Reaver has Drain Life and Paladin has Shield of Punishment.)

1
MrProb•

Nope I don't know how you translated that into Reaver sucks, it's actually the opposite and arguably the best physical DPS class for end game content.

1
benihime-xbla•

I noticed most players doing cs200 content are going all plate classes.

1
Forefal1•

Many are using druid and/or assassin who don't wear plate.

1
benihime-xbla•

I see a lot of priest with vitality and patience with defender using steady and outcry. Looks like their dps is the berserker and probably Jude for the 4th? The nerf that prevents same classes was probably to stop double defender trivializing content. You can make Jude tank copying steady with patience and vitality im sure.

1
wunshot2014•

The nerf that prevents same classes was probably to stop double defender trivializing content. You can make Jude tank copying steady with patience and vitality im sure.

I was using Warrior with SBL/Numbness/Time Reversal paired with Illusionist using Wisdom/Copy/Time Reversal. Didn't even bother using a second illusionist in the friend slot (although you could have).

I was able to get up to Abyss level 119 in practice mode with that set up. Now with the Time Reversal nerf I can't get higher than 103, and that's starting from level 101. The cycle runs out after 3 levels of mobs and you're completely defenseless.

I know it was total cheese, but it was fun while it lasted. :)

1
DeltaFrame•

Even with the nerf it still works. Just need more planning and good mp reg for illusionist. Also a good dps not wasting time (at this point a very good dps helps). Im stuck 119 as well but not because of the running out of SBL, but because of the bug which doesn't let you attack or use skills when you abuse that tactic. Usually illusionist turn comes up and you see defender's skills and weapon instead of illusionist's build.

Going with my legit team today to move up. Hopefully the judgement tokens start to appear soon cause i dont need war tokens anymore.

1
Forefal1•

I'm curious why illusionist is always paired with assassin. As far as the physical DPS goes, assassin may be the worst one to pair illusionist with.

Compare breakthrough on the different classes.

Assassin already gets crit 1/4 the time, so 25% of the crit bonus is wasted. They get 30% more crit damage though and the numbers work out near even. Additionally, breakthrough assassins will either need distract or will pick up aggro, losing their 20% damage bonus.

Berserker can time breakthrough with fury, doubling his damage when he's already doing 50% more, making breakthrough more powerful on him. When he picks up aggro he can tank reasonably.

Brigand benefits from multistrike defense reduction, powering breakthrough. Additionally the multistrike allows her passive to double trigger. When she picks up aggro, any hit on her will drastically reduce it, protecting her.

I wonder if we see the illusionist assassin combo simply because those who use illusionist happen to already have assassin as their dps.

1
MrProb•

I agree with you here, I personally like Brigand a lot when I first saw her but I was too committed to Assassin.

I think as Brigand, you can always go all out as long as you can revive or buff her a little bit in end game contents where she could get one shotted.

1
exotrxOP•

I'm still on the fence about the illusionist... While I've been using him, I didn't commit any of my newest tier gear to him. Breakthrough/awaken just concentrates the aggro on one character. I use a tank that's 30 CS ahead of me and it still isn't enough... It's only good for bursting down a small enemy on multi-mob waves... Or doing a final push. I use it to break the shield on the Abyss caster waves.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
DeltaFrame•

I use reaver brigand and cleric to farm 200. 0 issues. I also pick friends berserker as a second damage dealer (avoid peeps with frenzy) incase brigand gets 1 shotted cause im still using blood set. Thanks to boss dropping useless mp gear which i dont need for her.

I haven't seen end game (as in best build) scout, but i have seen end game assassin and he was truly amazing. Im very satisfied with brigand (even before they buffed her) and berserker. Most of the server use berserker. Most of my FL use berserker and paladin as their leader. i think the characters are balanced for end game events. Just need to find good synergy and understand their ups and downs.

1
exotrxOP•

I was 50/50 on assassin and scout before the buff, but went assassin (somewhat regret it now). I've been using 200+ brigand friend which has gotten me some ridiculous clear times on 175 content. I might switch once I get enough Rank 4 physical scrolls for another GM lacerate. First however, I want GM wipeout on my paladin.

1
DeltaFrame•

GM lacerate Is quite good and source of unwanted aggro. I only use it on bosses in 200 every 2 turns to keep it up... Otherwise i just hit auto attack playing it safe ant mode style.

Luckily the bosses give ATK+ every turn so reaver can still put decent damage to help. building her with multistrike and crit And have her with gm PS while brigand can have fun with multiple strike free of mp stress. A bit of synergy to keep things smooth.

1
MrProb•

Thanks for this interesting bit, haven't read yet but will do so soon !

0
Locquemarinier•

Really awesome work man. Is it possible to add the CS of each character used then we have a rough gauge of the equipment level?

0