[dmg] vs [crtD]

I've seen a lot of talk about one being better than the other. Are they really that noticeably different? I'm debating picking up some advanced fleet weapons, but if crtD is so much better than dmg, I might find another route.

Posted Jan 31, 2016, 9:46 AM UTC

210
lady_alternateSachika@Rakhona | Team Space Princess | Aggronaut Cheerleader•

Unless your crit chance is terribly low (sub 15%) or you're at the very high end of DPS (over 100k) then you're really not going to notice much difference between them.

General rule of thumb (assuming MK14 gear, average piloting skill): DMG is slightly better for non-Romulan Tacs. CrtD is slightly better for everyone else.

Follow the links here to your level of gear and piloting skill to see the raw maths.

5
breovusMcCullough@Skemta | Engineer•

This really needs to be stickied or something. It's getting asked an awful lot. Here is the basic run down:

Is your character an engineer or science captain?

  • [CrtD]x3 [Pen] is the most ideal weapon mod combination in the game.

Is your character a tactical captain?

  • [Dmg]x3 [Pen] is the best mod combination in the game.

What if I want/have [CrtD]x3 [Pen] on my tactical captain?

  • There is nothing stopping you, and this is still an amazing combination of mods for any character. You don't need to spend tens of millions of EC getting [Dmg]x3 [Pen].

Wait, I thought [CrtD]x4 or [Dmg]x4 is better??

  • It's not. Pen is hands down the single best mod in the game. CrtDx4 and Dmgx4 weapons are still pretty amazing, so (again) if you're running those you don't have to feel super pressed to get Pen mods on new weapons.

I think CrtH/Acc/... is a better mod and think you're being biased.

  • We are biased... because math. Rock your Accx3 if you want, there isn't anything "wrong" about that. It's just not mathematically the most optimal mod for most people.
3
TheFallenPhoenixAtem@iusasset | STO Builds Moderator•

The information is on the STO Builds wiki.

Yeah, yeah, we could stand to update/clean that up, it's something u/h2o4dp was working on before his sabbatical.

Also, searches.

3
h2o4dp@h2o4dp, Aggronaut, /r/stobuilds mod•

facepalm this is the kind of thing I don't miss. That guy is a top fleet player!

2
breovusMcCullough@Skemta | Engineer•

It was kind of veiled sarcasm, because you're right... use of that magical yet unloved search feature would easily turn up answers to these kinds of basic questions.

You know what we should do? Squeeze an entire FAQ page into the r/stobuilds banner! Can't miss that! :p

2
howieloader•

Is [Acc]x3 still the best for PvP... I haven't played in a couple of years, and when I had quit [Acc]x3 was absolutely the best PvP mod...

1
Imperium74812•

Not that PvP is thriving, but...

I seem to recall a discussion with napkin math: an Acc mod is still nice, or two Acc mods at most. After that, point of diminishing returns occur.

The bottom line is this: the game's meta evolution has affected PVP. Accuracy is not a huge issue (but still some in PvP), although manny accuracy bonuses exist outside weapon mods. Epic weapon mod earns [Acc/Dam] already. [Pen] has become best mod. Immunities and chaining them have surpassed high defense/speed score. In theory, one can chain immunities for up To 43s continuously if I recall..,

2
howieloader•

Thanks for the explanation...

1
Starmada9801OP•

So.. then advanced fleet weapons should be avoided as they are dmgx3 and not crtDx3, correct? I'm an engineer captain in a beam boat.

1
robotichitchhiker•

They shouldn't be "avoided." Their bang-for-buck ratio is among the best in the game. But if you're chasing perfection and have the time/cash, you want [CrtD]x3 [Pen] marginally more in the current meta. Since they're harder to get, you may want to get the advanced fleets for now until you can get better.

4