Donald J. Trump on Twitter: "Ted Cruz complains about my views on eminent domain, but without it we wouldn't have roads, highways, airports, schools or even pipelines."
Posted Feb 1, 2016, 7:20 AM UTC
Posted Feb 1, 2016, 7:20 AM UTC
Ted Cruz wasn't complaining about your views on eminent domain because you support public infrastructure, Donnie-boy. Ted Cruz was complaining about your views on eminent domain because he doesn't think old ladies should be kicked out of their homes so you can build a fucking casino.
Guess it's not a popular view here, but I agree with this. Obviously the founding fathers thought eminent domain was a necessary evil for the greater good, but it should only be exercised for public benefit, not private.
How about not at all?
Yep, I think a common fallacy of our movement, (I myself have been guilty of this), is ascribing everything the framers did to some greater good or plan. When in reality, many of the founders were very wealthy statists, not looking to eliminate the state, so much as replace it with their own to profit off of. While they may have touted lofty claims of freedom etc., they had no problems squashing rebellions of their own, (whiskey rebellion). I can't help but find it somewhat ironic that many of the men allegedly fighting for the right to self determination and liberty would have no issues killing those who opposed their regime.
The fallacy exists because of the shameful way that the concept of liberty in some ways peaked at a time where any other national government than hereditary monarchy with relatively few limitations to absolute power was considered radical and even treasonous and slavery was an accepted condition.
Libertarianism is the natural successor, but too many are shortsighted and only want to return to that peak of liberty as enshrined by the Constitution (or Articles of Confederation).
We can do better and create a state of human liberty and independence from rule that the forefathers never dreamed of as they laid the groundwork.
The thing about the founding fathers of the United States is that they were at the very forefront of history suggesting, in one of the largest steps since the Magna Carta, that maaaaaybe the government shouldn't have absolute power.
As is hopefully always the case, we continue to move forward and realize its role is increasingly unnecessary.
While I disagree that it should be used at all, the Supreme Court decided to allow it to be used and given to private persons.
Why do statists have such a fetish for roads? Every time I see it brought up, I think it's a joke.
My response is to tell them that roads are less than 1% of the federal budget.
Yeah exactly. I'll concede that the government should build our roads if these statists agree to dismantle every other part of the government and its budget.
I'll even let them run the fire department!
As long as we let them play with the lights I think it'd be a done deal.
I think its because they're trying to covey how basic yet vital the state is. Everyone uses roads everyday but without the state, they would disappear!
That's one hell of a magic trick.
I like to say "Okay, conceded. The government should only exist to create roads. That'll be about a 99.5% budget cut."
which the gas tax would pay for...
"Muh roads!"
OH MY GOD! HAHA!
I'm pretty sure the complaint is about kicking elderly widows out of their houses to make room for billionaires but go on making the "muh pipelines" argument.
And this is the supposed opposition to the socialist left. What a joke. You'd think he'd have at least bothered to form an opinion on this beyond 'muh roads', but nope.
This is one candidate that is only kinda "right".
Either way, conservatives are not anarchists.
Isn't that always the way with statists? Even if you manage to convince them an action is immoral, they will then list all the policy based reasons why we have to continue doing the immoral action.
I imagine many conversations in 1800s on slavery shifted from the morality of owning a human being to whether getting rid of slavery would destroy the South's economy. Can you imagine a person using economic arguments to justify slavery? Can you imagine just how many people rolled their eyes at Abolitionists' "unrealistic" moral arguments.
morality of owning a human being
"Black" people weren't considered human.
Many held this view. But there were those that didn't and still supported slavery.
Alright, I love Trump, but I'll admit that he's wrong on eminent domain.
But without the state, who would have stolen the land to build the roads?
And who would have stolen our earnings to overpay private contractors to eventually get around to building the roads?
See, the state is totally necessary to build roads!
[deleted]
Private contractors intentionally drag out state jobs to get paid more. This is a well-known issue.
[deleted]