Textual evidence for a Varys/Faceless man conspiracy (Spoilers Main)
Im doing a reread and noticed an interesting connection between Varys and the faceless man "Jaqen H'ghar". We know from ACOK that Jaqen was given to the Nights Watch by Ned, along with Rorge and Biter: The worst were the three he'd found in the black cells who must have scared even him, because he kept them fettered hand and foot in the back of a wagon, and vowed they'd stay in irons all the way to the Wall. Later we find out that Varys not only disguised himself as a goaler, but he was functionally in charge of the black cells since the time of Aerys, under the false name Rugen. And those cells did not have many guests. From Jaime's 'investigation' into Tyrion's escape:
Certain of them [reports] went to the master of coin, others to the master of whisperers. All to the chief gaoler and the King's Justice. It has always been so in the dungeons." Longwaters scratched his nose. "Rugen was here when need be, my lord. That must be said. The black cells are little used. Before your lordship's little brother was sent down, we had Grand Maester Pycelle for a time, and before him Lord Stark the traitor. There were three others, common men, but Lord Stark gave them to the Night's Watch. I did not think it good to free those three, but the papers were in proper order. I made note of that in a report as well, you may be certain of it."
So, in the memory of Longwaters, these cells were very infrequently used at least during Roberts reign. Besides Rorge, Biter and the faceless man, everybody in them was a high ranking political prisoner sent down by either the Hand of the King or the King himself.
So why exactly were these three 'common men' down there?
So, here is my tinfoil: Varys or Illyrio hired Jaqen, and Jaqen cooperated in his imprisonment with the known repulsively criminal Rorge and Biter as cover. Likely Robert had not used the cells in a very long time, and Varys convinced him to open them up for these 3 under some contrivance. Jaqen would then patiently wait to carry out a targeted assassination during a crucial moment in the Illyrio-Varys conspiracy. His payment would likely have been unrestricted access to whatever he wanted in Oldtown after Westeros was delivered to Illyrio and Varys. However, plans went awry starting with Jon Arryns death and the Starks coming to Kings Landing. Jaqen decided to try and take his payment solo.
*edited for formatting
Posted Feb 4, 2016, 9:47 PM UTC · edited
That's a fascinating argument. I don't quite think it works, but I have yet to see a satisfactory answer to "how did a faceless man end up in the black cells?"
Why I don't think it works: to my knowledge, the faceless men work in secret. Their "partners" don't know what they are partners to. They are Kaiser Soze. They trick people, like Pate, into helping them if need be, but I don't think they network in the open, like "hi, I'm a faceless man. let's conspire ". I might be wrong though. I look forward to see what other replies you get on this.
That's my main question about the whole situation. It seems very hard to believe that he just happened to get locked up. He had to want to be there. Personally, I've always wondered if he intended to go to the wall to look for the book(s) that Aemon had.