r/Guitar•
Funkytown

[Question] Bought New Acoustic Guitar, luthier says neck has a small "flip" and needs work to make it right. What to do?

QUESTION

Background: Lurker here. I've been playing casually for about 15-20yrs. I'm into funky/bluesy/soulful stuff.

I've been playing the same laminated top Yamaha acoustic that I learned on, and I was overdue to upgrade. Found an "amazing deal" on this Breedlove, marked down to $999, and able to talk another $100 off down to $899. Sounds awesome. Punchy bass. Just needs a setup, right?

I forgo the $42 GC setup an opt for a luthier with glowing recommendations from a friend for a $75 setup. I just got a call from said luthier, explaining that the neck has a small "flip" near the sound hole, and when he gets the neck as straight as he likes, and the action where he likes, there is some buzzing from the 14th fret up. Needs some work. $175 all-in to get it right.

He says this is worryingly common. Taylors are pretty good, but Martins and Gibsons often suffer from this too(?). I told him this is a brand new guitar, and asked if I should take it back (I didn't mention my "amazing deal")? He said "Maybe"? He's not asking for any money for the work he's done so far, so I don't think he's trying to gouge me at all.

Should I just chalk it up to the price of a killer deal, and consider the additional $100 discount on the guitar as wealth-transfer to support my local luthier? I would have been happy to pay $999 +$75 setup, but I want to have an awesome guitar at the end of this, not something I feel I compromised on and got chopped up.

What do?

Posted Feb 5, 2016, 3:44 AM UTC

25
eruerableGibson/Gretsch/Rickenbacker/Fender/Mesa/Fractal•

I'd get it done, a lot of reasonably high end acoustics have a bit of a ski ramp toward the end of the neck. The notably exception to this is Taylor, something to do with how they make their guitars.

At the end of the day your guitar will play better than you'll reliably get from a brand new $1074 instrument.

2
FunkytownOP•

Thanks for the advice. I decided to just do it. Looking forward to getting it back!

1
electrodan•

You got a super deal on that guitar, if you like the sound of it then I would say the repair would be worth it.

Rising tongues on acoustics are pretty common, especially when they have lived in rough conditions, and especially when those conditions are early in the guitar's life. Music stores with a lot of solid wood instruments often have a hard time keeping all of their stuff properly humidified. This often leads to issues like you're experiencing. The issue you're having was likely why the guitar was such a steal. Like your luthier said, it's a pretty common problem that is definitely fixable without any issues arising in the future.

FYI, If you bought it through an authorized dealer, it is still covered under warranty. Depending on the extent of the problem they may or may not be willing to take care of the issue for you.

1
FunkytownOP•

Thanks for sharing your insight. I called Breedlove and left a message. No reply yet. I went down to visit the luthier and talk to him. I'm convinced he will do a good job. Opted for the fix. Looking forward to getting it back!

2
tazman137•

You sure its not a $175 'flip' of your money into his pocket that he spotted?

1