Convince me that Bank of America is not the best place to keep my money

Planning

Bank of America receives poor reviews and most people around here prefer Ally, Schwab, Fidelity, or a credit union. I have researched all of these options and have concluded that Bank of America is still the best bank for me, but I am open to being convinced otherwise.

I think it is best to evaluate a checking, savings, and investment account as part of a complete financial package and not in a vacuum.

Checking advantages of Ally, Schwab, Fidelity, etc.: reimbursed ATM fees, no maintenance fees, free checks.

These advantages are matched from Bank of America through its Preferred Rewards Platinum Honors. The disadvantage is that I have to keep $100,000 with Bank of America, but Merrill Edge counts so I could keep my IRA and taxable accounts there. Platinum Honors also gives up to 100/month free equity and ETF trades.

When taking into account the 75% rewards bonus it creates a very competitive credit card for general use: BankAmericard Travel Rewards Visa Signature ($0 AF) - 2.625% back on everything. I could then supplement with one additional card such as one of these:

  • BankAmericard Cash Rewards Visa Signature ($0 AF): 3.75% gas, 2.75% groceries.
  • Bank of America AAA Member Rewards Visa Signature ($0 AF): 3.75% AAA/travel, 2.75% groceries/drug store.
  • Barclay SallieMae ($0 AF): 5% online shopping, restaurants, online travel.

In order to exceed these benefits it requires using multiple cards for fairly specific categories of spending or paying attention to rotating categories. My monthly spend is not that high so micro-managing more than two cards is not worth it to me. I would be open to any combination of two cards that has a better overall value.

The advantages of this setup:

  • Easy to transfer funds between accounts.
  • Physical branches if I ever need it (notary, etc.).
  • Cash ATM deposits. I realize I could keep $1,500 at Bank of America to avoid the monthly fee and then transfer the money into another checking account, but there has to be an advantage to the other account to make this frequent inconvenience worth it.
  • Convenance of having all of my major accounts at one financial institution.

Disadvantages:

  • ATM fees on foreign transactions. However, the Travel Rewards card has no foreign transaction fee and I’ve never traveled internationally. Schwab checking has no foreign ATM fees and no minimum balance so I could keep an empty account and transfer money if I plan to travel internationally.
  • Poor interest rate on savings for emergency fund. If I kept $20,000 in an Ally savings account I could earn 1% ($200/year). However, I am at the point where I don’t think I need to keep that much in an FDIC-insured account. If I invested my emergency fund in a conservative ETF I could earn more than 1% and still liquidate quickly if I needed $10,000+ in cash. I have a charge card I could immediately use for $10,000+ while waiting on the transfers. I can’t think of a scenario where this would cause a problem.

I think this setup is extremely convenient day-to-day while still retaining competitive rewards. Am I missing anything that would make other options a superior choice?

Posted Feb 11, 2016, 4:58 PM UTC

015
forbearance•

BoA + Merrill Edge is a pretty good combo if you got a good amount of money to invest.

2
monkeywelder•

I have had a BOA business account for years. And I've never had a problem with them. Youre looking at bad reviews from less than .0001 percent of the total account holders.

The only thing that's been a problem is that they really are not "of America" there are a lot of places where they don't exist Colorado and Pennsylvania come time mind. But there are more. When youre travelling and need access to a branch it can be a PITA.

1
ItsSLEOP•

The only thing that's been a problem is that they really are not "of America" there are a lot of places where they don't exist Colorado and Pennsylvania come time mind. But there are more. When youre travelling and need access to a branch it can be a PITA.

Yeah it is strange that Bank of America has chosen to pull out of certain states.

They're in all of the areas I will commonly be and the free ATM access helps if I travel to a non-serviced area. There are very few national banks where this wouldn't be a problem with anyway.

1
Vosslen•

Boa's products are OK, you have a good setup with them in this little bundle. I'd probably do what you do, just be sure that if you need new products in the future (securities based loans, mortgage, etc) that you evaluate rather or not it's competitive. Don't just assume they're going to be good because they're good in everything else.

The main reason Boa gets bad ratings is because their customer service is shit and their policies with fees are harsh. You won't have either of those issues though because of the amount within your relationship with them. They'll kiss your ass just to keep you around.

1
ItsSLEOP•

just be sure that if you need new products in the future (securities based loans, mortgage, etc) that you evaluate rather or not it's competitive. Don't just assume they're going to be good because they're good in everything else.

That is a very good point and I would be sure to shop around for any significant loans.

It's mostly the day-to-day stuff that I am trying to figure out now so I can set it and forget it.

1
Vosslen•

You've got a good setup for day to day. I'd look at maybe a crest card from an outside lender for some diversity on your credit report, but if you have a good score don't bother. Other than that you're in a good place and I see no need to change

1
wijwijwij•

I think your analysis is comprehensive, but I would say that the Platinum (rather than Platinum Honors) may give you pretty much everything you want, and only requires you to have $50000 there. I think it drops non-bank ATM reimbursements down to 1/month rather than unlimited. But honestly, if you are using BoA, their ATMs are so ubiquitous this is unlikely to be a problem.

Another minor perk, which you didn't mention, is a free safe deposit box in the brick-and-mortar location of your choice.

The interest rate on BoA checking isn't as high as the online banks you mentioned. But this probably isn't high on your list of priorities.

1
ItsSLEOP•

I think your analysis is comprehensive, but I would say that the Platinum (rather than Platinum Honors) may give you pretty much everything you want, and only requires you to have $50000 there. I think it drops non-bank ATM reimbursements down to 1/month rather than unlimited. But honestly, if you are using BoA, their ATMs are so ubiquitous this is unlikely to be a problem.

You are correct, but it would also not get the last 0.25% rewards bonus. I'm not sure I would desire to keep significant amounts at multiple banks as I am trying to keep things as simple as possible.

Another minor perk, which you didn't mention, is a free safe deposit box in the brick-and-mortar location of your choice.

Yep! That is another $20-30/year in value.

The interest rate on BoA checking isn't as high as the online banks you mentioned. But this probably isn't high on your list of priorities.

The amount I keep in checking is really only used as a buffer for month-to-month expenses. There's no reason for me to keep more than $10,000 in there and I could get by with much less.

1
wijwijwij•

it would also not get the last 0.25% rewards bonus.

I just didn't want to think you were putting $50000 extra into BoA savings account at .1% (or less) when you could be saving it at 1% somewhere, gaining $450. You'd have to have $180,000 in credit card spending for the .25% boost to make up for that $450. If your balance is actually invested using Merrill Edge services, I'm less concerned, as I suspect your are going to have a greater benefit.

FWIW I think pairing your BoA services and having a Schwab mostly empty HYIC account for international travel purposes is a good combo. It's what I do ... so of course I agree. If you have no international travel plans, though, you could hold off on that until you do travel.

1
ItsSLEOP•

I just didn't want to think you were putting $50000 extra into BoA savings account at .1% (or less) when you could be saving it at 1% somewhere, gaining $450. You'd have to have $180,000 in credit card spending for the .25% boost to make up for that $450. If your balance is actually invested using Merrill Edge services, I'm less concerned, as I suspect your are going to have a greater benefit.

I don't even think I would bother opening a Bank of America savings account. The extra $50,000 would be deposited into Merrill Edge which would have the same returns as if it were in any other broker.

1
yowen2000•

I will offer up one reason as far as checking goes: use high interest checking, Lake Michigan Credit Union, Consumers Credit Union, Option One Credit Union, just to name a few options. They have interest rates ranging from 3 to 4.59%.

You do have to meet requirements, here's some reading: http://www.doctorofcredit.com/high-interest-savings-to-get/

1
ItsSLEOP•

high interest checking

I've done research on these accounts, but the requirements seem extremely annoying. It's the debit card transactions that would require some management from me every day.

There is also some cost to using debit instead of credit for transactions that work to negate some of the better interest rates:

  • Average daily balance is lower because debit transactions will be ran immediately instead of paying a credit card in a lump sum each month. (I think? I might be misunderstanding this)
  • Zero or reduced rewards for debit usage.
  • Reduced perks versus using a rewards credit card: extended warranties, emergency travel assistance, price protection, travel insurance, etc.

Intangible disadvantages:

  • I still have to keep another checking account for cash deposits.
  • Transfers between my investment and credit accounts will take longer.
  • Micro-managing transactions onto cards (Does this purchase need to go on the debit or can it go onto credit?). These extra and very frequent decisions could lead to quicker decision fatigue.
1
yowen2000•

Just an 3% LMCU account at $15k balance pays out $37.50 a month.

Debits? Do you shop at Amazon? Reload your gift card balance 50 cents at a time. Buy your <$5 purchases with it and you can hit 10 quickly and easily. All the other requirements are very easily met.

With the method above you lose a TINY bit in CC reward potential, that's about it. You get a risk free return on your checking/emergency fund balance, sounds great to me! But I'll admit, some people just don't want to mess with it and that's fine. But I'm happy to rake in the $450 a year. And possibly more as I save more money over the years.

1
ItsSLEOP•

I will re-evaluate this option, thank you.

I used to have a high-yield checking account with a local credit union. They ended up reducing their rates from 3%+ down to 0.20%. If I go this route it has to be with the understanding that in the future I may have to move somewhere else and redo all of my ACH payments, etc.

1
yowen2000•

LMCU has been great to me, I've banked with them for 5 years now. They've held it at 3% that whole time.

1